2021 Toyota Tundra vs 2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500

The 2021 Toyota Tundra may carry a design from the mid-2000s, but its age is considered by some to be its best attribute. Toyota has managed to keep the Tundra relevant through key updates and special editions, despite its older design. The truck's simplicity and reliability in the face of newer, more technologically advanced competitors have kept it a strong contender in the full-size pickup segment. Conversely, the 2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 received significant updates, particularly to its interior and the introduction of the new ZR2 off-road performance model. These changes, starting from the LT trim upwards, signalled Chevy's commitment to improving the Silverado's appeal and functionality, addressing previous critiques and elevating the truck's standing in a fiercely competitive market.

Performance ratings show the 2021 Toyota Tundra at 6 out of 10. Its standard 5.7-liter V8 engine provides solid acceleration and a decent towing capacity, although it lags behind competitors like the Ford F-150 in terms of towing capabilities and fuel efficiency. The 2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 is rated 7 out of 10, with the ZR2 model focusing on off-road performance. Despite not leading in horsepower and torque, the ZR2's suspension and damping systems are praised for their ability to handle a variety of terrains with ease. The Silverado's overall performance is deemed acceptable, with an emphasis on its off-road capabilities rather than outright acceleration or towing prowess.

In terms of form and function, both the 2021 Toyota Tundra and the 2022 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 excel with ratings of 8 out of 10 from CarGurus experts, despite their distinct design philosophies and target audiences. The Toyota Tundra offers versatile cab and bed configurations to suit various needs, including the Double Cab and the more spacious CrewMax. The CrewMax model, in particular, provides expansive legroom and a substantial cargo area in the cabin, thanks to fold-up rear seats, enhancing the truck's practicality for carrying passengers and indoor cargo alike. The focus on spaciousness and the optional in-bed storage lockers speak to a design optimized for utility and secure storage. Chevrolet's Silverado 1500 design includes robust grab handles and optional off-road high-clearance side steps to assist entry and exit. The Silverado's interior is marked by a leap in sophistication, with notable improvements such as optional 10-way power-adjustable, heated, and ventilated front seats, and ample rear seating space ensuring comfort for all passengers. The truck's cargo box depth contributes to a generous capacity, complemented by the innovative MultiFlex tailgate system, which enhances utility and ease of access to the bed. This system, alongside the available hard tonneau cover and spray-in bedliner, underscores Chevy's commitment to combining form, function, and security in cargo management. Both trucks demonstrate a strong focus on marrying functionality with user needs, whether through Toyota's pragmatic approach to cabin and storage space or Chevrolet's blend of comfort, technology, and off-road readiness.

Technology ratings for both trucks stand at 8 out of 10. The Tundra's infotainment system, despite the truck's older design, meets current standards with features like Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. Toyota has effectively updated the system to cater to modern demands without overcomplicating the user experience. The Silverado's new infotainment setup features a larger touchscreen and integration with Google's digital assistant, though some aspects of the system, such as response times and intuitive use, have room for improvement. Nonetheless, the inclusion of advanced tech like a rear camera mirror and head-up display positions the Silverado as a technologically competitive option.

Safety ratings favor the Tundra at 9 out of 10, highlighting Toyota's inclusion of advanced safety features as standard. The comprehensive Safety Sense P suite provides a high level of protection and driver assistance, making the Tundra a leader in its segment for safety. The Silverado receives a 7 out of 10, with Chevy Safety Assist standard across the lineup. While it offers a robust array of safety features, the absence of certain systems like blind-spot monitoring on lower trims marks where Chevrolet could have enhanced the Silverado's safety profile.

Both trucks earn a 7 out of 10 for cost effectiveness. The Tundra's value lies in its blend of old-school ruggedness with modern features, presenting a straightforward, reliable option for truck buyers. Its fuel economy and pricing structure reflect its positioning as a practical, no-nonsense choice. The Silverado's pricing strategy, particularly for the ZR2 model, aims to offer competitive value through off-roading capabilities and interior quality. Chevy's approach targets brand loyalty and the appeal of new features and designs to attract buyers.