2019 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 vs 2020 GMC Sierra 2500HD

As two General Motors full-size truck lineups, the Chevy Silverado and the GMC Sierra have a lot in common and are often compared. The light-duty Silverado 1500 is less frequently cross-shopped against the heavy-duty Sierra 2500HD, but that comparing the two is still worthwhile. The 2019 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 represented more than just a vehicle; it embodied a lifestyle and a source of pride for Chevy enthusiasts. With its redesign, the Silverado not only maintained its allegiance to the iconic gold bowtie but also introduced a more sleek and modern design, coupled with versatile configurations to meet a wide range of needs and preferences. From its multiple cab styles and engine options to its advanced technology and off-road capabilities, the Silverado 1500 was designed to impress, fulfilling both work and leisure demands with ease. The 2020 GMC Sierra 2500HD took a somewhat different route, elevating the concept of a luxury pickup to new heights with its Denali sub-brand. This offered a blend of capability and upscale features that set it apart in the heavy-duty truck segment. The Sierra 2500HD Denali was not just a workhorse; it was also a statement of style and performance, equipped with powerful V8 engine options, innovative towing aids, and a plush interior that challenged the luxury offerings of its competitors. Despite its functional roots, the Denali trim brought a level of refinement that appeals to those seeking both power and prestige.

Performance-wise, the Silverado 1500 is rated at 6 out of 10, offering a wide range of engines, including a notable turbocharged option and the powerful 6.2-liter V8. Despite its versatility, the truck's fuel economy and occasional transmission issues detract from its overall score. The Sierra 2500HD shines in this category with a rating of 9 out of 10, thanks to its robust V8 engine options that deliver exceptional towing and hauling capabilities, making it a powerhouse for heavy-duty tasks.

The 2019 Chevrolet Silverado 1500 secures a 7 out of 10 rating for form and function. While primarily purchased for its appeal in addition to its utility, the Silverado doesn't shy away from delivering competitive towing and hauling capabilities. Its maximum towing capacity is noted at 12,200 pounds, and its maximum payload rating measures 2,250 pounds. Chevrolet highlights the Silverado's Durabed cargo box for its durability and increased volume, alongside user-friendly features like enhanced bumper corner steps and a new power-release tailgate, contributing to its practicality and convenience. The 2020 GMC Sierra 2500HD shines with a perfect score of 10 out of 10, underscoring its formidable functionality tailored for heavy-duty tasks. It offers a staggering towing capacity of up to 18,510 pounds with a fifth-wheel or gooseneck connection and a payload capacity of up to 3,979 pounds, showcasing its superior strength and capability in the heavy-duty segment. The Sierra 2500HD's versatility is further amplified by its various bed and cab configurations, including options for both standard and long beds across different cab styles. The Denali trim, exclusively available with the crew cab, adds luxury without compromising on the truck's inherent functionality. Chief among these functionality features is the innovative MultiPro tailgate. It’s also fitted with expanded bed steps to accommodate larger work boots, epitomizing the blend of sophistication and work-readiness that heavy-duty truck owners desire.

Both trucks score high in technology, each earning a 9 out of 10. The Silverado 1500 features the Chevrolet Infotainment 3 system, a high-definition reversing camera, and various connectivity options. Similarly, the Sierra 2500HD is equipped with the GMC Infotainment 3 system, offering easy-to-use interfaces and advanced features like the MultiPro tailgate, demonstrating both trucks' commitment to integrating cutting-edge technology for convenience and safety.

Safety ratings for both trucks stand at 8 out of 10. The Silverado 1500 introduces several new safety features in 2019, including pedestrian braking and blind-spot monitoring. The Sierra 2500HD counters with its massive size and comprehensive camera systems, along with standard and optional safety packages that enhance driver confidence and security.

Cost-effectiveness is a category where both trucks receive a 6 out of 10. The Silverado 1500, while offering a variety of trims and configurations, faces criticism for its high price points and fuel economy that doesn't always meet expectations. The Sierra 2500HD, with its steep base price and costly options, particularly in the Denali trim, represents a significant investment, albeit one that delivers unparalleled capability and luxury in the heavy-duty segment.