2021 Mercedes-Benz E-Class vs 2021 Honda Accord

The 2021 Mercedes-Benz E-Class emerges as a pinnacle of luxury and versatility, boasting a broad selection of body styles, engines, and customization options. With its mid-cycle update enhancing infotainment, engines, and styling, the E-Class caters to a wide range of preferences, from efficiency and quietness to opulence and power, particularly highlighted in the tested AMG E53 with its mild-hybrid powertrain. In contrast, the 2021 Honda Accord takes a significant leap forward, refining its feature set, adding a trim, and prioritizing safety, all while maintaining competitive pricing. This approach has positioned the Accord as a formidable contender in the midsize sedan market, earning it widespread acclaim.

Performance ratings from CarGurus reveal a slight edge for the Honda Accord (9 out of 10) over the Mercedes-Benz E-Class (8 out of 10). The E-Class's shift to electrified powertrains in its E450 model introduces a complex, yet refined driving experience with a blend of power and efficiency, albeit with some models feeling underwhelming without the hybrid assist. The AMG variants, however, deliver exhilarating performance, marrying luxury with sportiness in a way few can. The Accord's two engine options provide a balanced mix of efficiency and excitement. The turbocharged 1.5-liter engine offers commendable fuel economy and performance, while the more potent 2.0-liter turbocharged engine brings a zestier drive, particularly in Sport trims, without sacrificing too much efficiency.

In terms of form and function, the Honda Accord, with 9 points out of 10, edges out the Mercedes-Benz E-Class, which scored 8, particularly when considering everyday practicality. The E-Class, with its luxurious cabin and redesigned infotainment system, offers user-friendly controls and a sophisticated driving environment. However, its functionality in terms of passenger comfort and luggage capacity varies significantly across models. The sedan version offers 13.1 cubic feet of luggage space, which is decent but may not meet the needs of all users. The All-Terrain wagon variant, however, significantly increases versatility with enhanced ground clearance and a more generous cargo capacity, making it a more practical choice for those needing extra space. On the other hand, the Accord distinguishes itself with practicality, providing a roomy and comfortable cabin for five and a substantial trunk space of 16.7 cubic feet. This capacity ensures that the Accord can handle a wide range of daily tasks and longer trips with ease. Combined with a thoughtful array of convenience features across all trims, the Accord demonstrates Honda's focus on creating a sedan that balances comfort, daily usability, and practicality, solidifying its position as a top choice for consumers seeking a practical and efficient vehicle.

Technology ratings favor the E-Class, with a perfect 10 out of 10, over the Accord, with a still-impressive 9 points. Mercedes' MBUX system offers a more advanced, albeit complex, user experience. Its touch-sensitive controls, detailed customization options, and high-end optional features like massaging seats set a high bar. The Accord's technology suite, while comprehensive and user-friendly, delivers essential connectivity and convenience features across all trims, including an 8-inch touchscreen, smartphone integration, and an array of audio and charging options. While not as advanced as the E-Class's offerings, it provides a solid tech experience for its price point.

Safety assessments also show a slight preference for the E-Class, which earns 10 points out of 10 to the Accord’s 9. Both vehicles boast impressive ratings from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS). The E-Class's array of standard and optional safety features, including innovative technologies like Pre-Safe Sound and rear side airbags, offer unparalleled protection. The Accord, meanwhile, provides a robust safety package standard on all models, including the Honda Sensing suite of driver-assist technologies, reinforcing Honda's commitment to safety without necessitating a move up in trim levels for advanced features.

Cost-effectiveness ratings starkly differentiate the two, with the Accord scoring a perfect 10 out of 10 and the E-Class a 5 out of 10. The E-Class's starting price and cost of options can quickly escalate, making it a premium choice for those willing to invest in luxury. Conversely, the Accord offers exceptional value, with a competitive starting price and a gradual increase across trims that aligns closely with its features and performance enhancements.