2020 Mercedes-Benz E-Class vs 2021 Honda Accord

CarGurus experts have rated both the 2020 Mercedes-Benz E-Class and the 2021 Honda Accord highly for their look and feel, each receiving a score of 9 out of 10. The 2020 E-Class showcases a rounded, smooth body reminiscent of its predecessors, offering versatility with its available sedan, wagon, coupe, and cabriolet forms. Its design is conservative yet rich, featuring a traditional thin-laced chrome grille or a sport grille with a prominent Mercedes emblem, complemented by delicate LED lighting and a choice of wheels that enhance its visual appeal. The interior is a highlight, with multi-tone leathers, aluminum, and wood accents, alongside high-resolution digital screens and ambient lighting that can be customized to the driver's mood. The 2021 Honda Accord, facing stiff competition in its segment, stands out with a mid-generation refresh that introduces a wider, restyled grille for a more sculpted appearance. The LED headlights and redesigned fog light openings contribute to its sophisticated look. With trim levels ranging from LX to Touring, the Accord offers a variety of alloy wheel designs and an exclusive Sonic Gray Pearl paint option for certain models. The interior, available in cloth or leather depending on the trim, emphasizes sophistication and comfort, with features like a power moonroof reducing headroom but adding to the luxury experience.

Performance ratings from CarGurus indicate a preference for the 2021 Honda Accord over the 2020 Mercedes-Benz E-Class, with scores of 9 and 8 out of 10, respectively. The E-Class, with its turbocharged 4-cylinder and optional V6 engines, offers a blend of power and sophistication, characterized by smooth acceleration and a comfortable driving experience. AMG models introduce higher performance levels, but the E-Class maintains a focus on luxury over outright speed. Fuel economy varies with configuration but generally aligns with expectations for the luxury segment. In contrast, the Accord offers a choice between a turbocharged 1.5-liter four-cylinder and a more powerful 2.0-liter turbo-four, both delivering efficient performance with a focus on daily drivability. The Accord's FWD setup and tuned dynamics provide an engaging driving experience, with fuel economy that excels, particularly in models equipped with the smaller engine. Paddle shifters in Sport models and an upgraded braking system highlight the Accord's balance of performance and comfort.

Functionality aspects reveal a divergence in design philosophy, with the E-Class continuing with a complex version of its COMAND system that lacks touchscreen functionality, making it less user-friendly. Despite this, its interior design and functionality, from seat controls to storage solutions, are well-thought-out, offering a comfortable and spacious environment. The Accord excels in daily usability, offering a comfortable and practical interior with standard convenience features, ample seating space, and a generous trunk capacity, further enhancing its appeal for families and daily drivers.

Technology offerings in both vehicles are impressive, with each scoring 9 out of 10 from CarGurus experts. The E-Class boasts advanced features like semi-automated driving systems and a sophisticated infotainment setup, albeit with a steep learning curve due to its lack of touchscreen functionality. The Accord counters with a more accessible 8-inch infotainment touchscreen, standard connectivity features, and additional tech in higher trims, presenting a well-rounded tech package that enhances both convenience and safety.

Safety ratings highlight the strengths of both models, with the E-Class earning a perfect 10 from CarGurus, thanks to its comprehensive suite of advanced safety features and top ratings from NHTSA and IIHS. The Accord closely follows with a score of 9, offering a robust array of standard and available safety technologies, earning top marks from safety organizations and reinforcing its reputation as a safe family vehicle.

Cost-effectiveness is a decisive factor, with the Accord scoring a perfect 10 against the E-Class's 6. The E-Class commands a premium, justified by its luxury status and advanced features, but faces significant depreciation. The Accord, meanwhile, offers compelling value across its trim levels, with competitive pricing, efficient powertrains, and a balance of features that cater to a wide range of buyers.