Used Subaru Legacy for Sale nearEast Setauket, NY
350 vehicles found
Shop with transparent pricing.
Only show listings that include dealer fees- Year:
- 2012
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 170 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Graphite Gray Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 27 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Off Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 84,798
- Stock #:
- 008606
- VIN:
- 4S3BMBC63C3008606
Sponsored by Bart's Automotive Sales
2012 Subaru Legacy
2.5i Premium AWD
84,798 mi
$9,494
- Year:
- 2025
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Magnetite Gray Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 3,476
- Stock #:
- U19369
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAF68S3026176
Sponsored Listing
2025 Subaru Legacy
Premium AWD
3,476 mi
$29,120
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Crimson Red Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Slate Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 11,526
- Stock #:
- 6100I
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAF69R3003290
Sponsored Listing
2024 Subaru Legacy
Premium AWD
11,526 mi
$24,575
- Year:
- 2014
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 173 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Venetian Red Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 28 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 77,115
- Stock #:
- B16221A
- VIN:
- 4S3BMBD63E3018604
2014 Subaru Legacy
2.5i Premium AWD
77,115 mi
$10,173
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Crystal White Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 25,661
- Stock #:
- U19064
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAB61R3002365
2024 Subaru Legacy
AWD
25,661 mi
$23,097
- Year:
- 2020
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Crimson Red Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Gray
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 89,228
- Stock #:
- KY2971A
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAF61L3024402
2020 Subaru Legacy
2.5i Sport AWD
89,228 mi
$16,070
- Year:
- 2017
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 175 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Gray (Tungsten Metallic)
- Combined gas mileage:
- 29 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- White (Warm Ivory)
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 117,472
- Stock #:
- UC7084
- VIN:
- 4S3BNAC69H3011251
2017 Subaru Legacy
2.5i Premium AWD
117,472 mi
$10,165
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Crystal White Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Gray
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 19,601
- Stock #:
- 20003MA4
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAC69R3010809
2024 Subaru Legacy
Premium AWD
19,601 mi
$24,122
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Magnetite Gray Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 5,404
- Stock #:
- S08516U
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAD65R3008828
2024 Subaru Legacy
Premium AWD
5,404 mi
$25,429
- Year:
- 2020
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Ice Silver Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Gray
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 56,697
- Stock #:
- X7737
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAG65L3006399
2020 Subaru Legacy
2.5i Sport AWD
56,697 mi
$20,076
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 175 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Crimson Red Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 29 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- White (Warm Ivory)
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 102,744
- Stock #:
- L06659U
- VIN:
- 4S3BNAB68J3023429
-$2,009
2018 Subaru Legacy
2.5i AWD
102,744 mi
$14,181
$12,172
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Cosmic Blue Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 20,686
- Stock #:
- 526US326
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAN68R3008644
2024 Subaru Legacy
Limited AWD
20,686 mi
$25,839
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Magnetite Gray Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Slate Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 16,626
- Stock #:
- 526US299
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAN63R3005974
2024 Subaru Legacy
Limited AWD
16,626 mi
$25,995
Recommended model year:
2024 Subaru Legacy
Shop 2024 Subaru Legacy »With 1,346 currently listed for sale and an average price of $25,173.00, 34.7% of 2024 Subaru Legacies for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2024 Subaru Legacy 5 / 5 stars.
90.9% of 2024 Legacy models on CarGurus are accident free.
The 2024 Subaru Legacy features standard all-wheel drive, a spacious interior, and advanced safety technology, making it a reliable choice for families and winter driving.
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Cosmic Blue Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 16,214
- Stock #:
- US8287
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAD67R3006370
2024 Subaru Legacy
Premium AWD
16,214 mi
$23,148
- Year:
- 2022
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Magnetite Gray Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 47,899
- Stock #:
- P2D0881B
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAD60N3018371
2022 Subaru Legacy
Premium AWD
47,899 mi
$20,525
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Crystal White Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Slate Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 25,955
- Stock #:
- U6266
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAD61R3002198
2024 Subaru Legacy
Premium AWD
25,955 mi
$22,562
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Ice Silver Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 17,405
- Stock #:
- U15176T
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAN64R3003280
2024 Subaru Legacy
Limited AWD
17,405 mi
$26,598
- Year:
- 2021
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Crystal White Pearl
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- White (Warm Ivory)
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 79,132
- Stock #:
- 18975W
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAD61M3018975
2021 Subaru Legacy
Premium AWD
79,132 mi
$16,985
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Magnetite Gray Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 25,650
- Stock #:
- X7733
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAD61R3003416
2024 Subaru Legacy
Premium AWD
25,650 mi
$24,396
- Year:
- 2019
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 175 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Silver
- Combined gas mileage:
- 29 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 74,968
- Stock #:
- XPA2073RJ
- VIN:
- 4S3BNAB63K3013022
2019 Subaru Legacy
2.5i AWD
74,968 mi
$16,422
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 175 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Twilight Blue Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 29 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Titanium Gray
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 72,227
- Stock #:
- 26Z194
- VIN:
- 4S3BNAN68J3032028
2018 Subaru Legacy
2.5i Limited AWD
72,227 mi
$17,163
- Year:
- 2020
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Ice Silver Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 174,272
- Stock #:
- HM3156
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAN68L3021157
2020 Subaru Legacy
2.5i Limited AWD
174,272 mi
$10,687
- Year:
- 2024
- Make:
- Subaru
- Model:
- Legacy
- Body type:
- Sedan
- Doors:
- 4 doors
- Drivetrain:
- All-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 182 hp 2.5L H4
- Exterior color:
- Magnetite Gray Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 31 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Continuously Variable Transmission
- Mileage:
- 26,259
- Stock #:
- 110659
- VIN:
- 4S3BWAN64R3018247
Sponsored Listing
2024 Subaru Legacy
Limited AWD
26,259 mi
$26,985
FAQs
How much does the Subaru Legacy cost in East Setauket, NY?
How many Subaru Legacy vehicles in East Setauket, NY have no reported accidents or damage?
What fuel types are available?
4.6 Overall rating
Customers say
The Subaru Legacy has consistently impressed owners across many model years with its strong all-wheel drive capability, comfortable interiors, and commendable fuel efficiency. Drivers appreciate the reliability and safety features, which make it an excellent choice for winter driving conditions. However, some complaints frequently arise regarding the vehicle's acceleration and power, with many wishing for a bit more performance, especially in the sportier models. Overall, the Legacy is regarded as a dependable, practical sedan that balances comfort and driving enjoyment.
AI generated from the text of customer reviews.
Filter by year
Filter by rating
What people say
Drea U
Reviewed a 2017 Subaru 2.5i Limited AWD on Aug 15, 2025
For the year, the car has a great amount of modern features. Drives great in the snow, is comfortable with plenty of room, driver assistance features all worked as they should. The only thing missing is Apple CarPlay/android auto. You simply cannot compare anything to the Legacy. Maybe a BMW 5 Series. In terms of value - the legacy wins every time.
Anonymous
Reviewed a 2014 Subaru 2.5i AWD on Mar 16, 2025
I Love this car, my favorite color and drives so smooth and can't say enough how much room there is.
Katie O
Reviewed a 2009 Subaru 2.5i AWD on Mar 16, 2025
Had this car for 6 years, honestly a fantastic vehicle. If you’re a Top Gear fan, One of the 2 models approved by all 3 gents (Jeremy’s antics aside). Had standard Subaru head gasket leak - but never got worse. Got Harmon Kardon speakers inside, great AC, awesome AWD. Loved this car to death! Highly recommend - will keep you safe in snow. Just upkeep on maintenance and it’s your ride or die.
Danny P
Reviewed a 2013 Subaru Legacy on Mar 11, 2026
So far so good! Low mileage, one owner car that was all dealer maintained. Only 115,000km on a 13 year old car. Its the 3.6R limited trim so it also has nice extras.
Subaru Legacy Trims
| Trim type | MSRP |
|---|---|
| Touring XT AWD | $40,110 |
| Sport AWD | $36,410 |
| Limited AWD | $35,920 |
| Premium AWD | $29,110 |
| AWD | $26,810 |
Subaru Legacy Price Trends
CarGurus tracks the prices of millions of used car listings every year. See how the average price of Subaru Legacy prices has changed over time.
See more price trendsCarGurus recommends the 2024 Subaru Legacy
Summary
With 1,346 currently listed for sale and an average price of $25,173.00, 34.7% of 2024 Subaru Legacies for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2024 Subaru Legacy 5 / 5 stars.
90.9% of 2024 Legacy models on CarGurus are accident free.
The 2024 Subaru Legacy features standard all-wheel drive, a spacious interior, and advanced safety technology, making it a reliable choice for families and winter driving.
Why it stands out
The 2024 Subaru Legacy stands out in the midsize sedan market due to its long-standing reputation for safety and reliability. It is equipped with standard all-wheel drive across all trims, which enhances its performance in various weather conditions. The introduction of advanced driver-assist technologies, such as the EyeSight safety suite, further solidifies its appeal to safety-conscious buyers. Additionally, the Legacy offers a comfortable ride with a spacious interior, making it an excellent choice for families. Its competitive pricing compared to rivals like the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry adds to its attractiveness, providing modern features and technology at a more accessible price point.
Other model years to consider
- Average price: $13,080.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 35.8%
- User rating: 5 / 5
- Total listings: 674
- Average price: $14,534.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 36.1%
- User rating: 5 / 5
- Total listings: 674
- Average price: $27,652.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 35.0%
- Total listings: 1,116
These recommendations are based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from July 13, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.
Recent expert test drives
2020 Subaru Legacy
- Expert review8/10
- MSRP$22,745-$35,895
- Avg. price$18,309
- User rating5
2021 Subaru Legacy
- Expert review8/10
- MSRP$22,895-$36,145
- Avg. price$20,299
- User rating5
2015 Subaru Legacy
- Expert review8/10
- MSRP$21,695-$29,595
- Avg. price$10,715
- User rating5
Relevant articles
The Best Cars for New Drivers in 2026
Common advice suggests the best first car to buy is a beater, but you may want to shop new. Even budget-friendly new cars come equipped with safety features that can prove invaluable for new drivers.
The Best Family Sedans of 2026
Advanced safety features that were once exclusive to luxury cars are now standard on many family sedans. And while sedans might not have the space of an SUV or a minivan, they do have efficiency on their side. Here are our top 10.
The Best AWD Cars for Under $10K in 2026
All-wheel drive (AWD) cars have benefits even for drivers who never see snow or rain—and they can be found for less than $10,000 if you know what to look for.
