Used Subaru Legacy for Sale in New York, NY

to
to

Filter Results

listing

Price

- Loading...
Includes Listings Without Available Pricing

Financing

Mileage

- Loading...

Delivery

Days on Market

- Loading...

Recent Listings

Vehicle History

Vehicle history data provided by Experian AutoCheck. This data, and any reliance on it, is subject to the AutoCheck Terms and Conditions and the CarGurus Terms of Use
Hide vehicles with:

Photos

Fuel Economy

- Loading...
()

Price Drops

Text Search

Add Similar Cars


1995 Subaru Legacy 4 Dr Brighton AWD Wagon Review
by Jonathan

“great car.”

its not the prettiest car there ever was, but its fast, sticks to the road like its magnetized summer and winter, tough as hell. mine only cost me two ball joints and the mass air flow meter in 100,000KM. takes alot of gas though. its not so bad at 100km/h, but wind it out a lil bit and you can almost see the needle drop.

Message Sent!

Whoops!

First
Loading...
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/09/09/21/05/2011_subaru_legacy-pic-4566185465387930225-152x114.jpeg

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited Used Cars in Greenwich, CT 06830

Great Deal
$3,196 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $10,186

Price: $6,990

Mileage: 75,923

Location: Greenwich, CT 06830

Average time on market: 15 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Graphite Gray Metallic Description: Used 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited for sale - $6,990, 75,923 miles with Navigation System, Sunroof/Moonroof, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (50 reviews) "Nice experience overall, the car sold before we could make an offer "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/03/04/21/22/2017_subaru_legacy-pic-3213114968007093801-152x114.jpeg

2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Carlstadt, NJ 07072

Great Deal
$2,753 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $17,295

Price: $14,542

Mileage: 29,586

Location: Carlstadt, NJ 07072

Average time on market: 38 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Twilight Blue Metallic Description: Used 2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $14,542, 29,586 miles with Bluetooth, Backup Camera
Avg. Dealer Rating: (34 reviews) "Overall excellent buying experience, place can get very busy at times, just continue working with the staff and they will deliver as promised. They do not have any hidden fees, all of the paperwork was clear, no surprises. Cars are priced very competitively, lots of rare luxury cars. Its hard to predict with used cars, but it seems that they do a good job mechanically inspecting their inventory prior to sales. "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/05/23/11/17/2015_subaru_legacy-pic-6015433551761889496-152x114.jpeg

2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Used Cars in Richmond Hill, NY 11418

Great Deal
$2,670 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $10,650

Price: $7,980

Mileage: 106,143

Location: Richmond Hill, NY 11418

Average time on market: 36 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Crystal Black Silica Description: Used 2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i for sale - $7,980, 106,143 miles with Bluetooth, Backup Camera, Navigation System, Premium Package, Alloy Wheels, Climate Package
Avg. Dealer Rating: (159 reviews) "I inquired about a vehicle and received good response from the Mandii, i was handed over to a salesperson who was awful I had asked for a purchase offer and after waiting 4 hours still had not received the fax , no return phone calls or any sort of courtesy to enlighten me as to what was taking place."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/07/10/19/31/2017_subaru_legacy-pic-2566858733896775801-152x114.jpeg

2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Hackettstown, NJ 07840

Great Deal
$2,533 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $17,828

Price: $15,295

Mileage: 30,646

Location: Hackettstown, NJ 07840

Average time on market: 38 days Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: 6-Speed CVT Color: Venetian Red Pearl Description: Used 2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $15,295, 30,646 miles with Bluetooth, Backup Camera, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (20 reviews) "Love my 2017 Subaru Outback, but not super impressed with the dealership. They were so busy the day I picked up my car, that I barely talked to my salesman. The battery was dead the first time I looked at it and still dead upon pick up. They did replace it, but I was not leaving until they did. Some of the detailing left much to be desired."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/05/24/02/32/2017_subaru_legacy-pic-6963895918563052536-152x114.jpeg

2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Hillside, NJ 07205

Great Deal
$2,334 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $16,834

Price: $14,500

Mileage: 30,721

Location: Hillside, NJ 07205

Average time on market: 38 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Gray Description: Used 2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $14,500, 30,721 miles with Leather Seats, Power Package, Navigation System, Alloy Wheels, Bluetooth, Backup Camera, Cargo Package, Heat Package, Premium Package, Climate Package
Avg. Dealer Rating: (76 reviews) "The guys at Cars2sell were very friendly and willing to work with me to buy the car,,,. My experience there was enjoyable and professional. I would recommend them to anyone looking for a pre owned vehicle."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/08/27/16/36/2011_subaru_legacy-pic-4117324076011364625-152x114.jpeg

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in New Brunswick, NJ 08901

Great Deal
$1,928 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $6,828

Price: $4,900

Mileage: 135,739

Location: New Brunswick, NJ 08901

Average time on market: 17 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Brown Description: Used 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $4,900, 135,739 miles with Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (16 reviews) "My girlfriend bought a car about 3 years ago from them and I just recently went myself for a Toyota matrix. Very honest dealership. Buy with confidence"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/09/16/15/49/2014_subaru_legacy-pic-4086080987383043075-152x114.jpeg

2014 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited Used Cars in Rahway, NJ 07065

Great Deal
$1,776 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $12,271

Price: $10,495

Mileage: 94,675

Location: Rahway, NJ 07065

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Twilight Blue Metallic Description: Used 2014 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited for sale - $10,495, 94,675 miles with Leather Seats, Sunroof/Moonroof, Adaptive Cruise Control, Alloy Wheels, Bluetooth, Backup Camera, Remote Start, Premium Package
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/08/21/00/11/2012_subaru_legacy-pic-8205277590922475948-152x114.jpeg

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Freehold, NJ 07728

Great Deal
$1,593 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $10,083

Price: $8,490

Mileage: 77,737

Location: Freehold, NJ 07728

Average time on market: 19 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Ruby Red Pearl Description: Used 2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $8,490, 77,737 miles with Bluetooth, Sunroof/Moonroof, Alloy Wheels, Climate Package
Avg. Dealer Rating: (93 reviews) "Quickly responded"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/09/10/11/08/2016_subaru_legacy-pic-8838357145509240606-152x114.jpeg

2016 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited Used Cars in Princeton, NJ 08540

Great Deal
$1,848 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $18,848

Price: $17,000

Mileage: 51,737

Location: Princeton, NJ 08540

Average time on market: 37 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Venetian Red Pearl Description: Used 2016 Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited for sale - $17,000, 51,737 miles with Backup Camera
Avg. Dealer Rating: (40 reviews) "Good and great dealer "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/09/03/14/44/2018_subaru_legacy-pic-23012206847930783-152x114.jpeg

2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Irvington, NJ 07111

Great Deal
$1,862 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $17,891

Price: $16,029

Mileage: 38,500

Location: Irvington, NJ 07111

Average time on market: 43 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Red Description: Used 2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $16,029, 38,500 miles with Bluetooth, Backup Camera, Aluminum Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (36 reviews) "They were not helpful at all. They are scammers! They have this price on carguru but tried to tell me it was priced at 14,000 when I arrived... After speaking with the receptionist multiple times to schedule test drive & pricing. I came all the way from PA for absolutely nothing! I will never do business here or give this dealer a referral! If the you have the car priced at 10,988 on carguru why would I go on the dealership website itself? They came up with so many reasons why the car is 14000.. Then tried to sell me a 2014 garbage Altima with more mileage & scratches. A bunch of crooks! Take your money elsewhere if you want tip top service. If I had the choice to give 0 stars I would."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/07/25/11/35/2017_subaru_legacy-pic-7861062069674031393-152x114.jpeg

2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited Used Cars in Saint James, NY 11780

Great Deal
$1,944 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $18,939

Price: $16,995

Mileage: 50,842

Location: Saint James, NY 11780

Average time on market: 40 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Ice Silver Metallic Description: Used 2017 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited for sale - $16,995, 50,842 miles with Bluetooth, Leather Seats, Backup Camera, Sunroof/Moonroof, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (16 reviews) "They were quick to respond, and pleasant to talk to."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/05/09/00/21/2015_subaru_legacy-pic-2038753041320489588-152x114.jpeg

2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Bayside, NY 11361

Great Deal
$1,516 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $12,515

Price: $10,999

Mileage: 76,825

Location: Bayside, NY 11361

Average time on market: 25 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Lapis Blue Pearl Description: Used 2015 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $10,999, 76,825 miles with Bluetooth, Backup Camera, Aluminum Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (2 reviews) "One of my greatest car buying experiences...everyone was so helpful....and cordial....if you want the best service ...this is where you want to go... ."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/02/22/18/21/2014_subaru_legacy-pic-7757937114348598717-152x114.jpeg

2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited Used Cars in Elizabeth, NJ 07202

Good Deal
$1,637 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $12,632

Price: $10,995

Mileage: 84,848

Location: Elizabeth, NJ 07202

Average time on market: 30 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Silver Description: Used 2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited for sale - $10,995, 84,848 miles with Leather Seats, Sunroof/Moonroof, Light Package, Power Package, Adaptive Cruise Control, Alloy Wheels, Bluetooth, Backup Camera, Climate Package
Avg. Dealer Rating: (29 reviews) "Great customer service! Everyone is very nice. The car is perfect. Drives perfect. Carfax perfect! I got my dream car! Thank you David!"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/07/02/22/10/2018_subaru_legacy-pic-3660442656706322842-152x114.jpeg

2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Hackettstown, NJ 07840

Good Deal
$1,833 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $19,128

Price: $17,295

Mileage: 32,888

Location: Hackettstown, NJ 07840

Average time on market: 43 days Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: 6-Speed CVT Color: Crimson Red Pearl Description: Used 2018 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $17,295, 32,888 miles with Bluetooth, Backup Camera
Avg. Dealer Rating: (20 reviews) "Went for a test drive then they told me I needed to put 15000 dollars down on a 23000 dollar car. They weren't willing to accept 6000. Very unstressed in selling anything that isnt a Subaru."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2019/09/10/19/11/2016_subaru_legacy-pic-3224225442250545179-152x114.jpeg

2016 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited Used Cars in Hackettstown, NJ 07840

Good Deal
$1,901 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $18,396

Price: $16,495

Mileage: 34,623

Location: Hackettstown, NJ 07840

Average time on market: 38 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 6-Speed CVT Color: Crystal Black Silica Description: Used 2016 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited for sale - $16,495, 34,623 miles with Bluetooth, Leather Seats, Backup Camera
Avg. Dealer Rating: (20 reviews) "Kept in contact and was very nice "
Next Page >>
Please wait ...
Please wait ...
First Previous
Page # of #
Next

Filter your search criteria!

A large number of listings matched your criteria. You are seeing the top 2,000 listings.

Used Subaru Legacy By Year

Vehicle Deals Starting Price Total Available
2019 Subaru Legacy 9 Great Deals $18,999 2,218 listings
2018 Subaru Legacy 23 Great Deals $13,200 567 listings
2017 Subaru Legacy 44 Great Deals $10,881 1,283 listings
2016 Subaru Legacy 32 Great Deals $8,694 1,071 listings
2015 Subaru Legacy 24 Great Deals $6,990 469 listings
2014 Subaru Legacy 17 Great Deals $4,900 285 listings
2013 Subaru Legacy 11 Great Deals $4,250 291 listings
2012 Subaru Legacy 7 Great Deals $3,750 238 listings
2011 Subaru Legacy 11 Great Deals $3,900 281 listings
2010 Subaru Legacy 7 Great Deals $2,991 194 listings

Why Use CarGurus?

We'll help you find great deals among the millions of vehicles available nationwide on CarGurus, and we'll provide you with dealer reviews and vehicle history for each one. After all, over 30 million shoppers use CarGurus to find great deals on used cars and new cars in their area. And when it's time to get rid of your old ride, sell your car simply and securely on CarGurus.

Once you're ready to narrow down your search results, go ahead and filter by price, mileage, transmission, trim, days on lot, drivetrain, color, engine, options, and deal ratings. And if you only want to see cars with a single owner, recent price drops, photos, or available financing, our filters can help with that too.