Used Subaru Legacy for Sale nearAnnandale, NJ

Filters (2)

Location:

Only show listings in NJ?

Include delivery listings?

212 vehicles found

Shop with transparent pricing.

Only show listings that include dealer fees
Year:
2016
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Black
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Red
Transmission:
6-Speed CVT
Mileage:
209,578
Stock #:
015312
VIN:
4S3BNAC63G3015312
Black 2016 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 6-Speed CVT
101 Motors LLC

Sponsored by 101 Motors LLC

2016 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

209,578 mi

Carlstadt, NJ
45 mi away
Great Deal

$4,194

Year:
2019
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Combined gas mileage:
29 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
196,339
Stock #:
013933
VIN:
4S3BNAF68K3013933
 2019 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Continuously Variable Transmission

Sponsored Listing

2019 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

196,339 mi

Irvington, NJ
35 mi away
Good Deal

$6,594

Year:
2024
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Black
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
38,886
Stock #:
29260545
VIN:
4S3BWAM65R3015357
Black 2024 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Automatic

 

2024 Subaru Legacy

Limited AWD

38,886 mi

Store transfer to Easton, PA
Price includes $149 shipping
Good Deal

$24,147

Year:
2025
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Cosmic Blue Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Mileage:
10,107
Stock #:
S8548
VIN:
4S3BWAD67S3030111
Cosmic Blue Pearl 2025 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive

 

2025 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

10,107 mi

Woodbridge Township, NJ
32 mi away
Good Deal
Manufacturer certified

$26,860

Recommended model year:

2024 Subaru Legacy

4.6

Shop 2024 Subaru Legacy »
  • With 1,016 currently listed for sale and an average price of $24,490, 34.6% of 2024 Subaru Legacy listings on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.

  • Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2024 Subaru Legacy 5 / 5 stars.

  • 85.4% of 2024 Subaru Legacy listings on CarGurus are accident free.

Research summarized using AI

Year:
2016
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
256 hp 3.6L H6
Exterior color:
Black
Combined gas mileage:
24 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
104,853
Stock #:
011328
VIN:
4S3BNEN63G3011328
Black 2016 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Continuously Variable Transmission
Price drop

-$1,009

 

2016 Subaru Legacy

3.6R Limited AWD

104,853 mi

Elmwood Park, NJ
44 mi away
Good Deal

$11,698

$10,689

Year:
2021
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Transmission:
8-Speed CVT
Mileage:
113,279
Stock #:
016716
VIN:
4S3BWAN62M3016716
 2021 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 8-Speed CVT

 

2021 Subaru Legacy

Limited AWD

113,279 mi

Carlstadt, NJ
45 mi away
Great Deal

$12,694

Year:
2025
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Cosmic Blue Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
11,436
Stock #:
BI7816
VIN:
4S3BWAD60S3025770
Cosmic Blue Pearl 2025 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Continuously Variable Transmission

Sponsored Listing

2025 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

11,436 mi

Parsippany, NJ
29 mi away
Great Deal
Manufacturer certified

$24,903

How much does the Subaru Legacy cost in today's market?

Used Subaru Legacy prices span a wide range depending on model year. Here's what the market looks like right now:

Model YearCurrent Avg. PriceYear-Round Range
2025$27,067$27,067 – $28,418
2024$24,480$23,733 – $25,055
2023$21,379$21,371 – $23,599
2022$20,271$20,271 – $22,310
2021$18,667$18,667 – $20,674
2020$17,138$17,138 – $19,463
2019$15,597$15,597 – $16,691
2018$14,087$14,018 – $14,838
2017$12,913$12,271 – $13,020
2016$11,715$11,356 – $12,252
2015$10,597$10,078 – $10,796
2014$8,691$8,187 – $9,003

The Subaru Legacy's current nationwide average price is $17,458, and its nationwide average price reached a low of $17,458 over the past year. Recently, prices have come down for the 2023, 2024, and 2025 models, making now a good time to shop recent model years.

Is the Subaru Legacy a good car?

Yes — the Subaru Legacy earns strong marks from owners across the lineup, and its standard all-wheel drive, comfort, and safety focus are recurring strengths.

The all-generations owner rating is 4.6/5 across every model year in the data.

Owners consistently praise the Legacy for its all-wheel drive capability, comfortable interiors, and practical everyday character. Fuel efficiency and safety also come up often as reasons shoppers like it.

Expert reviews rate the 2021 and 2020 models among the highest across all years.

The trade-offs that show up most often are uninspired styling, sluggish performance, and interior materials that feel cheap.

32.2% of listings are priced as good or great deals.

Are Subaru Legacy models reliable?

Owners consistently describe the Legacy as dependable, comfortable, and well suited to poor-weather driving. The strongest themes across the model years are its standard all-wheel drive, safety focus, and everyday practicality.

  • Owners rate the Subaru Legacy between 4.7 and 5 out of 5 stars across all model years in the data.

For used buyers, long-term ownership risk is generally tied more to condition, maintenance history, and prior use than to the model’s core appeal, so a careful inspection and vehicle-history check still matter.

What should I look for when buying a used Subaru Legacy?

Across all model years, at 68.8% accident-free, a meaningful share of listings has prior incidents — history verification is especially important.

Model YearAccident-Free %
202586.6%
202485.3%
202380.3%
202276.9%
202173.7%
202065.7%
201959.3%
201852.2%
201752.5%
201655.2%
201558.5%
201458.9%

Older model years carry meaningfully higher accident rates, so always verify the vehicle history report on pre-2022 models.

Key things to evaluate:

  • Safety package: Subaru EyeSight technology
  • Infotainment: standard 11.6-inch infotainment screen with Apple CarPlay and Android Auto
  • Fuel efficiency: The 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine gets an EPA-estimated 27 mpg in the city, 35 mpg on the highway, and 30 mpg combined. The turbo does slightly worse in terms of fuel economy earning 24 mpg in the city, 32 mpg on the highway, and 27 mpg combined.

Which Subaru Legacy trim should I buy?

The 2021 Subaru Legacy offers these trims:

  • Base: The entry model uses the 2.5-liter engine and gives you standard all-wheel drive, standard Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, and Subaru EyeSight safety tech. It suits you if you want the lowest-cost way into the Legacy lineup.
  • Premium: This trim adds the standard 11.6-inch infotainment screen, heated front seats, dual-zone climate control, and more convenience features. It is the best-value trim for many shoppers because it brings a big step up in everyday comfort and tech.
  • Sport: This version adds the turbocharged engine and 18-inch black wheels, giving you the stronger powertrain and a more distinctive look.
  • Limited: This trim adds leather upholstery, a Harman Kardon audio system, and more upscale cabin touches.
  • Limited XT: This version combines the Limited equipment with the turbocharged engine for stronger passing and highway performance.
  • Touring XT: This top trim adds the turbocharged engine along with the most upscale equipment in the lineup.

What Subaru Legacy do most buyers choose?

The Subaru Legacy years with the most listings are 2024, 2025, and 2023.

Model YearTotal ListingsGood + Great Deals %
20241,02035.1%
202584336.4%
202382834.1%
201667031.2%
201764931.7%
201862831.7%

These higher-volume years tend to be popular because they give you more inventory to compare, which can make it easier to find the right price, mileage, and equipment mix. They also often represent the most current versions of the model, which helps keep them attractive to used shoppers.

What is the Subaru Legacy's resale value?

Model YearCurrent Avg. PriceYear-Over-Year Change
2020$17,138−11.94%
2021$18,667−9.71%
2023$21,379−9.41%
2022$20,271−9.14%
2019$15,597−6.21%
2018$14,087−5.06%
2025$27,067−4.74%
2014$8,691−3.26%
2024$24,480−1.87%
2016$11,715−1.3%
2017$12,913+1.22%
2015$10,597+2.57%

Most Legacy model years are down year over year, which is good news if you want to buy used at a lower price than a year ago. A few older years are moving slightly higher, but the overall pattern still favors shoppers looking for value. The sharpest drops are concentrated in the newer and mid-cycle years, which can make recent used examples especially appealing.

The 2015, 2017, and 2016 model years have held their value best, with the smallest year-over-year price changes.

Is the Subaru Legacy safe?

  • 2021: 9/10
  • 2020: 10/10
  • 2015: 9/10
  • 2014: 7/10

The 2021 Legacy comes standard with Subaru EyeSight technology.

For the safest used buy, the 2020 model posts the highest confirmed score of 10/10.

Should I buy a used Subaru Legacy now?

Buy now if:

  • Price trend: The 2024 model is at −1.87% versus a year ago, and the 2023 model is at −9.41%.
  • Deal availability: The 2024 model has 35.1% good and great deals, and the 2023 model has 34.1%.
  • Sweet-spot year: The 2024 model has the most listings at a current average price of $24,480. The Subaru Legacy offers standard all-wheel drive, which gives it a strong all-weather character that many used-sedan shoppers value.

If you're buying used today, the 2024 model year offers the best mix of value and availability.

How does the 2024 Subaru Legacy compare to the 2024 Toyota Camry?

Spec2024 Subaru Legacy2024 Toyota Camry
Starting MSRP$24,895$26,420
Engine2.5L 182 hp H42.5L 203 hp I4
Fuel economy (city)27 MPG/MPGe28 MPG/MPGe
Fuel economy (highway)35 MPG/MPGe39 MPG/MPGe
Average used price$24,480$25,988
Listings available1,02010,542
Good & great deal share35.1%35.9%
Accident-free share85.3%79.9%

These recommendations are based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from November 17, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.

*CarGurus meticulously monitors the prices of millions of pre-owned vehicle listings, offering users precise and up-to-date market insights. Historical pricing data excludes any additional dealer fees as of May 3, 2026.

A better way to discover your best deal

Let us help you find a car you’ll love.