Used 2017 Subaru Legacy for Sale near New York, NY
86 results
CarGurus Analysis:
2017 Subaru Legacy
With 86 currently listed for sale near New York, NY and an average price of $11,175.00, 20.9% of 2017 Subaru Legacies for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2017 Subaru Legacy 5 / 5 stars.
59.3% of 2017 Legacy models on CarGurus are accident free.
The 2017 Subaru Legacy is well-regarded for its standard all-wheel drive, impressive fuel efficiency, and high safety ratings, featuring a comfortable interior and user-friendly technology.
CarGurus Analysis: 2017 Subaru Legacy
Summary
With 86 currently listed for sale near New York, NY and an average price of $11,175.00, 20.9% of 2017 Subaru Legacies for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2017 Subaru Legacy 5 / 5 stars.
59.3% of 2017 Legacy models on CarGurus are accident free.
The 2017 Subaru Legacy is well-regarded for its standard all-wheel drive, impressive fuel efficiency, and high safety ratings, featuring a comfortable interior and user-friendly technology.
Why it stands out
The 2017 Subaru Legacy shines as a mid-size sedan that has consistently offered standard all-wheel drive, a significant advantage in its class. Over its 36-year history in the U.S., it has been a pioneer in integrating safety technologies and driving comfort, which continues to attract buyers. The Legacy is particularly commended for its comfortable interior and space, making it suitable for both individuals and families. While it may lack the sporty flair of some competitors, the robust build and reliable performance make it a strong contender in the used car market. Moreover, prices for the 2017 Legacy are generally lower than those of similar models like the Honda Accord and Toyota Camry, allowing buyers to enjoy modern technology and safety features without breaking the bank.
Other model years to consider
- Average price: $22,881.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 38.0%
- User rating: 5 / 5
- Total listings: 108
- Average price: $16,268.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 35.1%
- User rating: 5 / 5
- Total listings: 57
- Average price: $12,166.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 18.3%
- User rating: 5 / 5
- Total listings: 93
This analysis is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from May 5, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.
Relevant articles
The Best Cars for New Drivers in 2026
Common advice suggests the best first car to buy is a beater, but you may want to shop new. Even budget-friendly new cars come equipped with safety features that can prove invaluable for new drivers.
The Best Family Sedans of 2026
Advanced safety features that were once exclusive to luxury cars are now standard on many family sedans. And while sedans might not have the space of an SUV or a minivan, they do have efficiency on their side. Here are our top 10.
The Best AWD Cars for Under $10K in 2026
All-wheel drive (AWD) cars have benefits even for drivers who never see snow or rain—and they can be found for less than $10,000 if you know what to look for.
5.0 Overall rating
Filter by rating
Anonymous
Reviewed a 2017 Subaru 2.5i Limited AWD on Aug 15, 2025
For the year, the car has a great amount of modern features. Drives great in the snow, is comfortable with plenty of room, driver assistance features all worked as they should. The only thing missing is Apple CarPlay/android auto. You simply cannot compare anything to the Legacy. Maybe a BMW 5 Series. In terms of value - the legacy wins every time.
Sarah A
Reviewed a 2017 Subaru Legacy on May 22, 2020
AWD AND 32+MPG. BEST SAFETY RATING IN THE BUSINESS. Most comfortable Sedan with a very useful interior. Voice controls for everything if you want! Super comfortable even at 63 Best Value in a Sedan that I have ever seen.
Paul R
Reviewed a 2017 Subaru Legacy on Jan 4, 2023
Stylish, dependable. Very comfortable and many extras. A good choice
Anonymous
Reviewed a 2017 Subaru Legacy on Jul 30, 2020
Comfortable, great mileage, beautiful, very high consumer reports rating! The 2015 was so good we bought another!
2017 Subaru Legacy Trims
| Trim type | MSRP |
|---|---|
| 3.6R Limited AWD | $31,640 |
| 3.6R Touring AWD | -- |
| 2.5i Premium AWD | $23,995 |
| 2.5i Limited AWD | $28,840 |
| 2.5i Sport AWD | $25,995 |
| 2.5i AWD | $21,995 |
| 2.5i Touring AWD | -- |
2017 Subaru Legacy Price Trends
CarGurus tracks the prices of millions of used car listings every year. See how the average price of 2017 Subaru Legacy prices has changed over time.
See more price trends
