Should I keep my 2010 Jetta TDI or let VW buy it back?

Asked by Aug 19, 2016 at 03:49 PM about the 2010 Volkswagen Jetta S

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

So I have a 2010 VW Jetta, one of the turbo diesels involved in the emissions scandal.  Yes, I have been belching fumes into the atmosphere like a boss.  The care is completely paid for and gets 35-42 mpg.  

Per their website, VW will offer me $5,100.00 in restitution.  That is a matter of a flat amount plus a percentage of the car’s value.  In terms of value, VW uses the pre-September, 2015 clean trade value.  I get this money whether I keep the car or sell it back to VW.  

VW will buy the car for about $7,200.00.  This amount is based on the same pre-September value, with deductions for mileage above the normal level.  According to cargurus.com, this is about right, +/- $500.00.

VW will fix the emissions problem for free.

Case for selling the car, taking my money and running
1. I will not have to worry about the car and its possible fix
2. I do not know what the fix will do to my mileage and/or performance
3. I’ll have about $12,300.00 to put toward another car, which should suit my needs
4. I do not know what the car will be worth in the future; would anyone want it?
5. And would a dealership take it on trade without a super gouge?
6. I paid $10,000.00 for the car in March, 2015, so I guess I’m ahead?
7. I put $2,500.00 in repairs in it in December, so that comes off the top, right?

Case for keeping the car
1. I’ll have $5,100.00, which is nice
2. I replaced the tires and battery, so those are good for a while
3. I really like the car
4. It handles and performs fine, now
5. It should have some value by the time I’m ready for something else (just don’t know what)
6. If I can drive it another 4 years or so, or to about 300K miles, I’ll have gotten my money’s worth
7. A diesel should hold up for that many miles

What would you do?  Or do you need more information?  What are my best options?

2 Answers

293,785

Take the money and buy something else.

40

I'm in the same boat with a 2010 Jetta TDI. When I filled out the online settlement form I told VW I want to keep the car, knowing I can change my mind later. I guess there is some possibility that a fix will be prohibitively expensive for VW: does this mean VW can require that you sell the car back? BTW, I called the info line and was told that if I choose to keep the car, the $5100 compensation would be bumped up to about $8600 when all is said and done. I didn't ask about that, the rep just volunteered the info. Also, for those who haven't yet completed the online form, be aware that the offers VW presents to you at the end of completing the form ($$ for selling or keeping your car) don't get saved for you, so take screen shots if you want to retain this info.

4 people found this helpful.

Your Answer:

Volkswagen Jetta Experts

  • #1
    Goodwrench707
    Reputation
    2,680
  • #2
    Deathjam4
    Reputation
    2,290
  • #3
    Tom Demyan
    Reputation
    1,670
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used Volkswagen Passat
351 Great Deals out of 24,634 listings starting at $1,000
Used Honda Civic
414 Great Deals out of 49,826 listings starting at $1,495
Used Volkswagen GTI
80 Great Deals out of 6,070 listings starting at $2,395
Used Honda Accord
585 Great Deals out of 104,730 listings starting at $1,225
Used Volkswagen Golf
80 Great Deals out of 5,095 listings starting at $500
Used Toyota Camry
772 Great Deals out of 74,279 listings starting at $1,250
Used Toyota Corolla
625 Great Deals out of 67,264 listings starting at $1,460
Used BMW 3 Series
920 Great Deals out of 31,690 listings starting at $1,599
Used Audi A4
229 Great Deals out of 10,917 listings starting at $1,000
Used Nissan Altima
754 Great Deals out of 67,300 listings starting at $1,495
Used Mazda MAZDA3
263 Great Deals out of 25,352 listings starting at $1,200
Used Chevrolet Cruze
501 Great Deals out of 62,688 listings starting at $2,467
Used Volkswagen CC
51 Great Deals out of 2,107 listings starting at $4,300
Used Ford Focus
393 Great Deals out of 80,941 listings starting at $1,295
Used Volkswagen Tiguan
219 Great Deals out of 21,299 listings starting at $2,999

Used Cars For Sale

2015 Volkswagen Jetta S For Sale
25 Great Deals out of 1,148 listings starting at $5,940

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use.