has anyone had a problem with the 2004 325 automatic transmission shifting "hard" from first to second gear?

Asked by Sep 26, 2011 at 11:00 PM about the 2004 BMW 3 Series

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

when i accelerate slowly it is fine but if i have to move fast it seems to "pop" into
second gear. how concerned should i be?

5 Answers

2,925

When was the last time you had your transmission fluid and filter changed??? That's usually a common problem with peoples transmissions. I know many manufacturers made "Life Time" transmissions with no dipstick or some even without a drain plug... but off course fluids don't last forever.

4 out of 4 people think this is helpful.
465

Another possibly superstitious school of thought here: if it ain't broke, don't fix it- Since automatics work on fluid pressure to decide when to shift, you might just have to add fluid to see if that fixes the issue before you go upsetting the balance. I have heard horror stories about people who flushed & replaced (most of) their fluid, something in the system was knocked loose/changed/etc. and they then experienced total failure. Might look at resetting the TCM as well. (maybe Fuse pull or battery disconnect)

2 out of 2 people think this is helpful.
2,925

You're kidding right? With over 15 years of experience working on vehicles, specializing in German cars, in most cases the owner or previous owners neglect changing their transmission fluid and filter at recommended intervals. I even owned a 88 325e at 280k miles the transmission started slipping and smoking very badly. After a fluid and filter change it shifted like new. So please change all your fluids, not just your oil. All lose their viscosity and tolerances to withstand everyday punishment over time. That includes brakes, power steering, differentials, transfer cases, etc... If you don't know the last time the tranny fluid/filter was changed I recommend doing it.

6 out of 6 people think this is helpful.
465

Qualified my statements as "possibly superstitious", but no, not kidding. I don't doubt your credentials, I am a firm believer in proper PM myself. Simply offering another point of view that has been reiterated to me by local (albeit some old school) mechanics, and online by many seemingly reputable sources. Not to get into a heated debate about viscosity, but some folks even send samples of their synthetic fluid out for testing before replacing fluid & filter, and just replace the filter and skip the fluid based on the lab results. (engineers are an odd bunch). I am a gearbox guy and was forced into auto transmission troubleshooting when my wife's AWD lexus took a dump. We ended up getting it rebuilt, but I spent a lot of time networking and researching the issue before we went down that (wince) $4000 path. As a matter of fact, Lexus REFUSED to *flush* my wife's transmission a few years back based on my previous statements alone, and would only drain & fill. I was inclined to call BS, so I began calling local indy's / tranny shops / online research. I would hate for someone to follow a recommendation based on information from one source only to have a bad situation turn worse. Maybe 98% of the time replacing most of the fluid and changing the filter is a move for the better. We are all here to help, and having enough information to consider all possibilities is part of making informed decisions. Cheers.

2,925

Well... shops are in the business to make money and unfortunately some are less than honest and go overboard with repair charges. I hear way too many stories from locals I do repairs for that shops do unnecessary repairs. Just recently a replaced two wheel hubs for a regular client and he was still hearing noise from the front end. He took it to a shop and they said he need new front hubs and a pinion seal. Over all cost was $800 for a $150 seal repair. He took the hub back (I installed) under warranty and there was nothing wrong with them. Another time I took one of my rides for a oil change, they had my car 5 hours and then said it was done. I check and the old oil filter was still mounted. A person got fired over that one. The same shop did a brake inspection on my sister's car. Recommending all brakes needed replacing. After buying the parts I found the rear were like new. Needless to say they have a new shop manager and the company reimburse her cost for the rear brakes pad and rotors.

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

3 Series

Looking for a Used 3 Series in your area?

CarGurus has 33,246 nationwide 3 Series listings starting at $1,000.

ZIP:

Search BMW 3 Series Questions

BMW 3 Series Experts

#1 Tom Demyan
Tom Demyan
Reputation 4,540
#2 Robert Charlson
Robert Charlson
Reputation 1,510
#3 Matt Mankinen
Matt Mankinen
Reputation 1,180
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used BMW 5 Series
487 Great Deals out of 15,051 listings starting at $2,499
Used BMW M3
38 Great Deals out of 1,711 listings starting at $4,544
Used Mercedes-Benz C-Class
468 Great Deals out of 28,410 listings starting at $1,499
Used Audi A4
190 Great Deals out of 10,723 listings starting at $700
Used Ford Mustang
365 Great Deals out of 46,760 listings starting at $1,500
Used BMW 6 Series
77 Great Deals out of 3,248 listings starting at $5,399
Used Mercedes-Benz E-Class
377 Great Deals out of 21,626 listings starting at $699
Used Honda Accord
717 Great Deals out of 86,701 listings starting at $1,250
Used BMW X5
433 Great Deals out of 16,342 listings starting at $2,000
Used BMW 7 Series
186 Great Deals out of 5,995 listings starting at $2,999
Used BMW 1 Series
40 Great Deals out of 1,209 listings starting at $6,499

Used Cars For Sale

2017 BMW 3 Series For Sale
38 Great Deals out of 8,050 listings starting at $27,996
2016 BMW 3 Series For Sale
145 Great Deals out of 3,351 listings starting at $19,995
2015 BMW 3 Series For Sale
15 Great Deals out of 930 listings starting at $15,999
2014 BMW 3 Series For Sale
189 Great Deals out of 4,263 listings starting at $11,980
2013 BMW 3 Series For Sale
105 Great Deals out of 2,903 listings starting at $11,950