$$$ to repair 2010 head gasket

Asked by Mellerkeller Oct 20, 2016 at 07:51 PM about the 2010 Subaru Forester 2.5 X Limited

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

I bought a 2010 Subaru Forester with
180,000 mi on it. Found out today I need to
fix the axle and head gasket. It's leaking a
small amount of oil, and I've pretty much
decided to suck it up and fix it rather than
take on a car payment. My real delimma is
that the dealership says if I don't use
factory head gaskets and axle that I may
end up with the car shaking/vibrating when
driving. I have a repair shop that I trust but
should I discuss these concerns with them
prior to the repairs and how do I insure
they don't put the same older type of head
gasket into the car, rather than the steel
one? Should I go to the dealer for repair
and pay waaay more money or should I go
with my trusty repair shop or worst case
scenario buy another vehicle???

10 Answers

48,070

Don't take their fear-mongering too seriously. Almoist everyone resealing Subaru heads now knows to use the newer three-ply HGs. (It's not about original vs steel...they're BOTH steel.) Half-shafts (cv axles) are available online for a song. Only a smallish (but significant) percentage of them are sufficiently unsmooth enough to shake or rattle at speed. Worst case you eat the second one-hour labor charge, so don't sweat it. However, I WOULD use a shop experienced with Subie HG jobs, AND will send your heads out for measuring and pressure-testing at a reputable machine shop. You do NOT want to reinstall a warped nor cracked head and have to repeat a 10 hr job. This is a perfect time to replace the removed t-belt and inspect its pulleys too; however the water pumps are golden, so don't go overboard. Ask your wrench if he has experience carefully torquing the heads, as that's important too. This is about a $1300 wholesale job in New England, growing to $1500-1700 retail. Add the axle in for only $200 total. Given that you like your Forester (not my taste), a 2010 isn't so old as to not spend up to $2k on it, unless perhaps you need all brakes, tires, and maybe a cat conv at the same time, as $3.5 to $4k total would give me pause. OTOH if the oil leak is minor, and only on the left (passenger side), you MAY be able to stave off HG replacement quite awhile by increasing oil viscosity to 10w30-40...or preferably even 15w40.... You may see the leak diminish sufficiently to not coat and odoriferously cook off the cat-pipe beneath it. That said, keep an eye on coolant level, as you may also be leaking coolant from the DRIVER's side rear (#4) cylinder corner. Once both sides are leaking you should bite the bullet. (This dual- leak both-sides scenario is sufficient reason to NEVER just replace one side head gasket for a discount (usually 2/3 the labor cost), as the opposite side is needed eventually...and indeed soon after!

23 people found this helpful.

Use a top quality multi layer head gasket such as 5 star. The factory head gaskets are a major reason why they fail. If the oil leak is small I would live with it.

4 people found this helpful.
80

I'm surprised you managed to get 180k miles on it. I started having this issue at about 90k miles on it. It started with rough idling. I am still debating if I should sell my Subi and get a newer forester say 2014 and newer because I believe Subaru fixed the issue (correct me if I'm wrong).

4 people found this helpful.
48,070

You'll be disappointed with the Forester's handling. Subaru started using the better HG on the old SPHC 2.5i in 2010. The newer, better 2.5 DOHC has no HG issues.

1 people found this helpful.
20

I have a 2014 forester under 67Km. Head gasket was found leaking recently when I went to dealership for maintenance. Considering to sell it as I no longer trust Subaru. Dealer quoted $3000on this.

2 people found this helpful.
20

I have a 2010 Forester at 128,000 KM and the head gasket is leaking. Ridiculous that the head gasket is going already! Should last twice as long as this....I thought Subaru's were good cars? Is it worth spending 3K to replace this and the timing belt?

2 people found this helpful.
48,070

No, but it's worth $1.6k to do it, including outside machine shop vetting of the integrity of the heads. The OE gaskets probably aged out (11 winters), rather than mileage correlated.

Your Answer:

Forester

Looking for a Used Forester in your area?

CarGurus has 25,510 nationwide Forester listings starting at $1,200.

ZIP:

Own this car?

Share your experience with others.

2010 Subaru Forester

Review another car

CarGurus Experts

  • #1
    Chris W
    Reputation
    11,400
  • #2
    TheSubaruGuruBoston
    Reputation
    9,780
  • #3
    Nick Eidemiller
    Reputation
    6,220
View All

Know more, shop wisely

Search

Related Models For Sale

Used Subaru Outback
1,286 Great Deals out of 38,999 listings starting at $1,000
Used Toyota RAV4
1,946 Great Deals out of 28,631 listings starting at $1,500
Used Honda CR-V
1,905 Great Deals out of 41,328 listings starting at $1,050
Used Toyota 4Runner
1,147 Great Deals out of 18,239 listings starting at $1,550
Used Subaru Impreza
357 Great Deals out of 7,465 listings starting at $800
Used Toyota Highlander
1,339 Great Deals out of 18,494 listings starting at $500
Used Subaru Legacy
336 Great Deals out of 6,979 listings starting at $499
Used Toyota Tacoma
1,917 Great Deals out of 32,451 listings starting at $2,990
Used Nissan Rogue
2,014 Great Deals out of 54,685 listings starting at $675
Used Toyota Camry
1,972 Great Deals out of 34,551 listings starting at $500
Used Honda Pilot
951 Great Deals out of 29,227 listings starting at $711

Used Cars for Sale

2024 Subaru Forester For Sale
48 Great Deals out of 12,706 listings starting at $25,203
2023 Subaru Forester For Sale
69 Great Deals out of 1,238 listings starting at $24,200
2022 Subaru Forester For Sale
72 Great Deals out of 790 listings starting at $16,995
2021 Subaru Forester For Sale
207 Great Deals out of 2,974 listings starting at $13,499
2020 Subaru Forester For Sale
105 Great Deals out of 1,258 listings starting at $10,950

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use. Content will be removed if CarGurus becomes aware that it violates our policies.