2009 Forester XT overheating at slow speeds

Asked by DrumPharmer Oct 05, 2023 at 11:45 AM about the 2009 Subaru Forester 2.5 XT Limited

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

A little background first just in case it could be relevant. I had a catalytic
converter go bad/clog up and that did cause the engine temp light to flash
red briefly one time. Got the cat replaced and everything seemed fine for
several months. I just drove over 300 miles from OKC to Lawrence KS
without any issues at all until I arrived in Lawrence and slowed down to city
street speeds. Red temp warning lamp starts flashing. I opened the OBD
Link app on my phone and there are two different temp readings: Engine
Temp, and Coolant Temp. These appear to be different sensors because
Coolant temp reads fine at ~190F, but engine temp is ~220-230F. I stopped
the car immediately. Opened the hood, and this car has two pressurized
caps for the coolant. One on the radiator, and one on a small tank by the
turbocharger. The cap on the tank near the turbo (which has a lower
pressure rating) is burping fluid into the reserve tank (non-pressurized) which
has overflowed. I did not notice anything indicating coolant in the oil or oil in
the coolant (dipstick and under the fill cap looked fine as did the coolant in
the reserve tank). I let it cool and drove to an auto parts store, then to my
hotel for the night. The next day I put almost half a gallon of coolant in the
car. Drove a few miles around town and everything was fine. Got on the road
back to OKC and I am watching the temps like a hawk. No overheating at
highway speeds, but as soon as I pulled off for gas and a bio break, the temp
starts going up over 200F quickly, but I shut off the car before the light came
on. Got back in the car and as I accelerated on to the highway, the red
warning light blinked for about 5 sec, then stopped and temps were fine the
rest of the way home until I got off the highway again. Again, as soon as I
started slowing down, the temps quickly rose above 200F and got up to
almost 240F before I could get somewhere to stop the car and shut off the
engine. Again, the reserve tank has overflowed because the cap near the
turbo is releasing coolant. The upper radiator hose is obviously hot, but the
lower one barely feels warm at all. Could my radiator be clogged? Could the
cap by the turbo be bad and releasing coolant which causes the engine temp
to overheat while the coolant temp still appears fine? I do not THINK it is the
head gasket because there are still no indications of coolant and oil mixing in
either the engine or the radiator and overflow tank, but I do not know what
else it could be. Please help. Thank you.

2 Answers

38,975

classic blown head gasket , a compression test should be done , It may be this or it may be that but the comp. test should be done before dumping a lot of $$

155,285

Normally this kind of overheating is an airflow problem. But, because it's a Subaru I'd recommend testing for a blown head gasket first. The fact that the catalytic converter failed makes me suspicious of the head gasket as well. Unless a vehicle has a zillion miles on it a catalytic converter will fail if the engine is leaking coolant internally (blown head gasket), burning oil, or misfiring. When the engine overheats at slower speeds it's because the airflow through the front of the radiator is restricted or the cooling fan isn't working properly, or you could be missing a part of the fan shroud. Some vehicles have an air deflector that directs additional air over the radiator as well. This deflector will be on the bottom front of the vehicle and can be easily broken or ripped off by road debris. Hope that helps! Jim

Your Answer:

Own this car?

Share your experience with others.

2009 Subaru Forester

Review another car

CarGurus Experts

  • #1
    Chris W
    Reputation
    11,400
  • #2
    TheSubaruGuruBoston
    Reputation
    9,780
  • #3
    Nick Eidemiller
    Reputation
    6,220
View All

Know more, shop wisely

Search

Related Models For Sale

Used Subaru Outback
1,324 Great Deals out of 39,227 listings starting at $915
Used Toyota RAV4
1,990 Great Deals out of 28,662 listings starting at $1,200
Used Honda CR-V
1,994 Great Deals out of 41,185 listings starting at $1,100
Used Toyota 4Runner
1,177 Great Deals out of 18,225 listings starting at $1,550
Used Subaru Impreza
363 Great Deals out of 7,449 listings starting at $975
Used Toyota Highlander
1,393 Great Deals out of 18,509 listings starting at $1,100
Used Toyota Tacoma
1,981 Great Deals out of 32,524 listings starting at $2,990
Used Nissan Rogue
2,089 Great Deals out of 55,158 listings starting at $675
Used Subaru Legacy
334 Great Deals out of 6,988 listings starting at $499
Used Toyota Camry
2,027 Great Deals out of 34,342 listings starting at $500
Used Honda Pilot
1,009 Great Deals out of 29,216 listings starting at $711

Used Cars for Sale

2024 Subaru Forester For Sale
49 Great Deals out of 12,682 listings starting at $25,203
2023 Subaru Forester For Sale
76 Great Deals out of 1,253 listings starting at $24,200
2022 Subaru Forester For Sale
76 Great Deals out of 798 listings starting at $16,995
2021 Subaru Forester For Sale
210 Great Deals out of 2,986 listings starting at $13,499
2020 Subaru Forester For Sale
107 Great Deals out of 1,240 listings starting at $10,550

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use. Content will be removed if CarGurus becomes aware that it violates our policies.