German cars? Which

Asked by Aug 25, 2008 at 11:48 AM

Question type: General

What is better BMW, Mercedes, Volkswagen, Audi or Porsche?

8 Answers


My bias is toward BMW, but my experience is that they are all very good cars.


Im also BMW liker ;-) What can be said is that Mercedes is around 10% more expensive than the other Premium Brands like Audi and BMW... Volkswagen is the cheapest of them all, also it has got a completely different Model-Range as do Porsche which makes exclusively Sportscars and Sports SUV's... Porsche is probably the best brand in the world right now.. Considering Quality and Price-Stability... Audi / Volkswagen are pretty similar in some cases because they are actually the same company... BMW is a sporty oriented premium car brand... For me the sportiest of the all.... Thats why i love them :-)

I agree with this also in some cases, but i would much rather have a BMW thn a porsche. VW, Porsche and Audi are the same company. Mercedes also own a few other companies and so do Volkswagen but they don't make it known as much as Audi and Porsche. Thank you for replying though. It's good to know what other people think about the best few car manufacturers that exsist in the world at the moment.


Porche is the best if you're looking for a Sport Car... I guess I'll take VW cause Audi is expensive... BMW's Hatchback's are better C-Class is more comfortble than 3 Series 5 Series is better than E-Class S-Class and 7 Series needs a detailed research to make compare... But the cheap one is better... SUV X Series are better the GL and ML Results: The best Hatchback Golf(VW) The best sport car is Porche F*** all of'em is good


They're all great brands, but i have to say i like Porsche and Merc the best


Mercedes tends to be more expensive, and BMW is better value. Porsche is on it own because its just sports cars, and VW as a cheap Audi. A 3.2 Audi A4 is a great car, but then so is a GTI, a M3, and a Carrera... For speed its Porsche, everthing else it would be Audi for me. Then again i'm a Brit, so it would have to be Jaguar if i was honest


it would be BMW, Porsche then Mercedes i wouldn't even consider owning a VW or its overpriced father Audi lol Personally i think VW and Audi are horrible cars compared to the rest in the world

i have to say i have quite a bit of experience with german cars as me or someone in my family has had bmw, vw, mercedes, porsche and audi. my advice is to say if youre going for a first car vw is your best bet because they are super safe and are also nice cars that you can have a little fun with and they are def the most reasonable prices. now if you want something with a ton of power and you are considering maybe an m5, my opinion is that you get just as much car in the audi rs4 for less money. rs4 is amazing if thats your choice you wont be disappointed :) bmw is my fav and in my opinion all german cars are great. i think they give you the most for your money. the 335 and 135 are fabulous cars although the 135 is slightly faster but i prefer both in manual-its more fun! theyre very fast for a 3.0 liter inline 6 german cars are awesome-any of the makes are a great choice!

Your Answer:


General Experts

  • #1
    Tom Demyan
  • #2
  • #3
View All

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use.