Diesel or Gas?

1,185

Asked by Jan 13, 2013 at 05:41 PM about the Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD

Question type: General

im looking to buy a Chevy 2500HD, i will be using it for work over the summer,  landscaping and hauling
and towing, and putting a plow on for the winter next year, and im stuck on whether or not to buy one
with a 6.0 gas or a 6.6  diesel, can someone help me out? id appreciate it!

38 Answers

102,795

I would recommend the diesel. Gobs of low end torque and better MPG's too.

5 of 5 people found this helpful.
1,185

thats what i was thinking. just wanna see what other opinions out there are for this kind of truck. big decision

3 of 3 people found this helpful.

There is more energy in a gallon of diesel than a gallon of gas, therefore usually more mpg, and the 6.0L will probably serve you well, they are just more expensive initially than a gas engine but will pay for themselves in the long haul

6 of 6 people found this helpful.
345

The diesel is definitely better at towing and hauling but they are very heavy which means with a plow on you will wear out your front end quicker.

3 of 3 people found this helpful.
1,185

Tom thats good to know. i wouldnt of thought about that, considering i plan on doing residential.commercial plowing.

3 of 3 people found this helpful.
345

I have a 2500 6.0L and a diesel so I see the pros and cons of both. The diesel gets roughly 4-5mpg better and is comfortable towing close to double the weight. That being said the 6.0L can still tow over 10000lbs which is more than enough for most jobs. Both of mine have about 200000km and have been mostly trouble free but repairs on the diesel are more expensive. It also depends how long you intend to keep the truck, the diesel engines average time before a rebuild is 600000km so if taken care of it will last for ever. Finally the diesels extra weight means a lower payload. I love both of my trucks so it would be hard to recommend one, it all depends on your personal needs and preference.

14 of 14 people found this helpful.
1,185

i like the fact that you have one of each, so you know alot. with the diesel being heavier would it then not be a good choice for a plow, which is extra weight?

345

The diesel still works for a plow and the torque comes in handy it can just ware out parts faster. Depending on how cold it gets where you live it might not start too well either. But then on the plus side the low end power is far better in the diesel and you get much better mileage.

3 of 3 people found this helpful.
1,185

not too cold in northern ohio, but i see what your sayin. im thinking a 2001 2500 hd ext cab 4x4 6.0 gas right now, but there is a diesel same year just single cab that's nice too. guess itll come down to what id rather have in the long run

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
685

If you get a 2001 diesel, like you were referring, then good luck with that. If I were you, I'd get a 2004-2007 diesel. The 2001's (with the LB7 engine) have injector problems. I'd make sure that the previous owner had the injectors replaced. As for the 2004- 2005, they dont have as big of a problem, but they like to overheat when towing. I dont know if you were planning on towing, but just thought I'd point that out. Out of the years I mentioned, id go with the 2006-2007 (Old body style). They were the strongest and most durable diesel GM has made to date. They might cost a little more, but it is well worth your time. But I love diesels, they have tons of torque, are easy to make power with, and are extremely durable. Im not much of a Duramax guy, but if it was up to me, Id get a 5.9L Cummins. They are even more durable than the Duramax (in the earlier years) and can be found for much cheaper than a Duramax. Just my opinion. Hope it helped.

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
1,185

what year dodge body style are you referring to, and dont the cummins usually have lifter problems?

1 of 1 people found this helpful.
685

Im talking about the 03-05 body style dodge. And if you have enough modifications added to them, yes. Their stock lifters cannot hold a lot of power when it is added on. You can add a chip or programmer to them and you should be fine.

1 of 1 people found this helpful.
1,185

alright, there front ends strong enough to hold up to a plow?

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
685

Yeah, the have one of the strongest front ends in the business. Chevy has suspension and tie rod problems in the Duramax

1,185

hmm, alright, one last question, how reliable are the dodge gas engines? if i dont decide to get a diesel, i wanna know if its worth getting a dodge period

685

They are reliable, but get horrible gas mileage

1 of 1 people found this helpful.
1,185

alright thanks

20

I have a 2000 dodge ram 2500 4x4 with a 360 in it. Gas mileage does suck. I'm happy when I hit 10mpg. But I have 197000 miles on it and besides basic oil changes and tune ups I've only done 2 water pumps and 1 coil on it.

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
20

Go with Diesel. Much better mileage and better resale value. Pass on the factory winterfront, it's too air restrictive, tends to suck snow from lower area's into the filter in my area. I go with a stainless grill insert, use a denser cover down below. Keeps plenty warm even at -35.

I have a 2001 Dodge 2500 4x4 Cummins.....It has only had cheap minor issues and will pull a house. I have a leveling kit with 33's and still get 20 mpg empty, 16.5 towing my 36 ft 5th wheel loaded up

180

People lie too much about how great the diesels get mpg over the 6.0. 07 6.0 4x4 4:10 crew long bed loaded with 2000# of tools and equipment w/265 gets 14.5 all day long. Empty with no toolboxs in the bed on premium got 18.2 on a 200 mile trip all highway at 68 mph. With 35" tires with tools on a test trip before I added a newer one got 14mpg all highway at 68 mph. My wife averages 12.5 I believe because of how she wastes power hard braking and taking off very fast. 9 mpg towing 10000# travel trailer with the tools in the truck. 2011 duramax crew 3:73 4x4 with 265s 17.5 highway. 12.5 towing 6100# center console. 2007 duramax 3:73 crew 4x4 with 35's 16 hwy 11 towing 8500# scissor lift and trailer. 2015 6.0 4:10 crew cab 4x4 short bed 265s 15.7 80% highway at 65mph 14.2 around town 12.4 towing the same scissor lift. 11 towing the travel trailer 68 mph. 2012 Cummins 4x4 crew 35's best 15 hwy average 12 towing 9 mpg

9 of 9 people found this helpful.
10

So which one would YOU choose? Diesel or gas 2500HD ?

1 of 1 people found this helpful.
180

You're not saving a dime with the diesel on mileage because of the price of diesel is so much higher. The 6.0 is awesome for longevity. Deisels require head gasket changes eventually 200k-300k. I have a gas with 400k and no work yet and it's still powerful . No cold weather issues. For landscaping and snowplow definitely the gas. You already have to have a dump truck if you are getting extensive with the work that can pull your real heavy equipment and keep the wear off the truck. Once it gets so heavy all you do is eat your tranny up. Tractors, skid steers, mini excavators will be easy work on the gas. Buy an older diesel for cheap and haul and have a gas for all around is another option

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
180

The six speed is the best option for towing also.

1 of 1 people found this helpful.
20

boss_hog, Idk what engine you refer to that would need a head gasket at that mileage. Those are only a repair as fail, would have 800,000 to a Million miles on it by then if a quality Diesel. Know of more issues with Gassers blowing their gaskets once near that 250-300,000 range since the rings are well worn out, due for an O.H. Had one go at 110,000 miles. Severe duty diesels used in Tractors, construction equip often end up having that gasket done around 8,000 hrs, that's in the older engines. Newer engines have not had any reported issues, so any diesel in a pickup now would most likely last longer than the rest of the pickup.

180

Referring to pickup truck engines of course that is what this is all about. Seen many Duramax with the head gaskets blown. Hard everyday worked Cummins are lucky to make it that far at all. Daily driver is a different story. Hell I have a 1950's gas Massey Ferguson tractor that has only had plugs changed. It's been in the family since new. Old as dirt diesel tractors with no problems and John Deeres that have to have new sleeves every 2000 hours

1 of 1 people found this helpful.
20

Dodges w cummins are more likely to blow their tranny's if worked hard frequently. I have yet to hear of a JD needing new sleeves in that hr range as I keep them until the 7-8,000 hr mark, have only had one head gasket go at 6100 hrs, was back in service 2 days later. That is out of 20 John Deere's since 1960. I currently don't have a tractor with less than 2000 hrs or a semi with less than 650,000 miles on it. Cummins likes to eat ECU's.

180

Yep seen a Ram lose the tyranny at 8000 miles then 24000. At 40000 the Cummins blew. Shortly after the truck was totaled. My trucks are part of a fleet that are worked every time they are cranked. I currently have 3 6.0 with 300k and one with 400k then some that are low miles. Another thought you can replace 3 6.0 for the price of 1 duramax and it has the same price difference at Original purchase. I've never had problems with the 6.0 overheating towing. Have had fan clutches go out at 150k and the motor would creep to 220 but that's a easy fix that you see coming. When we had 5.7 now they would overheat if everything wasn't right. You can turn a 6.0 at 4000 rpm for 10 minutes up a 6% grade and it won't phase it a bit. Did that with a half Ton 5.3 with 10k behind it and it would exceed 65 mph in second gear but you can tell it didn't like it and won't last long under that pressure

3 of 3 people found this helpful.
20

Dodge is easy not to choose since owned by fiat.. Fix It Again Tony. A local fertlizer dist. often gets the half ton Chevy's w 5.3 and every single one went in for tranny repair in the 50,000 to 80,000 mile range. They now say If you want a half ton and want to do towing get the Ford ecoboost since it can outpull any of the other Ford gas engines.

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
180

I never had a Chevrolet lose the transmission towing other that a 700r4 exceeding the crap out of its rating by almost double and it had 125k when it went. Had a tranny cooler crack and lose all fluid on a 4l80 with 362k that took it out. The 6 speed in the newer half tons seem strong and trouble free just didn't like turning that 5.3 like that. Only have 1 half ton left it has the 4l60 it's 2k shy of 300k left with no signs of trouble other the engine leaks a little oil it pulls a 28 enclosed mon-fri 1 quart per 1000 miles. Couldn't pay me to own anymore Fords

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
30

Can a 2015 sierra 2500hd with a 6.0 vortex V8 with 4:1 axel, 4x4, double cab pull a 122000 lb fifth wheel

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
180

If you meant 12200# without a problem it will pull it. If you indeed meant 122000# or 61 tons there is no 3/4 ton pickup that will tow that safely

30

Thank you..Yes sorry I meant 12200# we were just worried because we know the gas doesn't have as much towing capacity as the diesel. However we really want gas.

1 of 1 people found this helpful.
20

the diesel hype is severely overrated. i have a 2005 1500hd and have hauled a load that wieghed at more than 30000lbs, and i could still hit 65 in under a mile! in fact it hauls more loads than the duramax we have does. the 6.0 is a reliable workhorse of a motor. its done things that it was never intended to do without a hiccup. suspension is the most limmiting factor when it comes to towing and plowing. if you have enough of that then your tranny or rear end will give before the 6.0 runs out of grunt. gas mileage isnt the greatest but you can buy a lot of it for the cost of the dmax and the extra cost per gallon of that diesel. and on the plus side with a few bolt ons you could have a 6.0 that would smoke a dmax and still less money invested into your rig if you would have bought a bone stock dmax.

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
20

Jeremy, the transmission in the gassers are not designed for that. I wouldn't tow anything over 13,000 with any of the GM or dodge stock transmissions. That is something only for a Ford tranny or an allison.

2 of 2 people found this helpful.
875

Always but always by moe truck than you need..if no you will curse and go buy another truck

1 of 1 people found this helpful.
10

Use the right tool for the job, it's much easier work. Reading through all these posts,3 things stand out most to me. Egos, seem to get in the way of information. During the gas vs diesel debate above, none points to the extra expenses involved in working one daily. First, initial purchase cost is rather unimportant. If you're worried about the extra cost, you can't afford it. The 3 mpg you MIGHT save, will be WAY outrun in added maintenance fees. Idc WHICH brand you're loyal to, they'll blow premature as a nerd on prom night(if he's lucky) if not maintained strictly. How has no one hit on oil capacity comparisons? Arguing ten bucks dif in tank of fuel? Then filter price diffs.. & on..&. Now I've put literally, billions of miles on both. Even enjoyed,both. IMO, comes down to preference mostly, as the added price in purchase carries over to resale value for the diesel. But don't blame the truck/maker if you cheap out buying under what you need. Doubtful I'd put even a lawn care trailer on a 1/2 ton,DAILY..P.S,someone should have let Kyle above know,GM has an "Allison stock" on HD. Which, I've seen many a manual transmission fail even towing regularly so... Third & final thing I noticed,(last bn least) "Jodi" looking hot!! Lol Hopefully, someone, enjoys the long winded read.

1 of 1 people found this helpful.

I have a 2500 4x4 diesel automatic, year 2000 GMC would never trade it for a gas anything when it comes to torque, low end gears, I have hit 5 ft high walls of snow 60 - 100 foot long drifts. As long as the tires have good tread, and weight in the back, that's the truck for me. But what do I know I'm just a farm chick from Ontario. Love my truck, featured in the background.

Your Answer

Silverado 2500HD

Looking for a Used Silverado 2500HD in your area?

CarGurus has 30,618 nationwide Silverado 2500HD listings starting at $2,995.

ZIP:

Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD Experts

  • #1
    Steven Loeffler
    Reputation
    500
  • #2
    Tom Demyan
    Reputation
    320
  • #3
    piocon
    Reputation
    300
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used GMC Sierra 2500HD
110 Great Deals out of 14,233 listings starting at $2,799
Used Ford F-250 Super Duty
392 Great Deals out of 49,102 listings starting at $1,899
Used Chevrolet Silverado 1500
2,663 Great Deals out of 174,458 listings starting at $955
Used Dodge Ram 2500
160 Great Deals out of 5,469 listings starting at $2,661
Used Chevrolet Silverado 3500HD
138 Great Deals out of 11,271 listings starting at $8,750
Used Ram 2500
184 Great Deals out of 34,951 listings starting at $6,995
Used GMC Sierra 1500
1,193 Great Deals out of 64,574 listings starting at $999
Used Ford F-350 Super Duty
373 Great Deals out of 27,005 listings starting at $2,995
Used Ford F-150
3,274 Great Deals out of 221,681 listings starting at $1,200
Used GMC Sierra 3500HD
66 Great Deals out of 4,791 listings starting at $10,995
Used Chevrolet Silverado Classic 2500HD
30 Great Deals out of 403 listings starting at $5,995
Used GMC Sierra 2500HD Classic
7 Great Deals out of 182 listings starting at $5,250
Used Chevrolet Silverado 2500
10 Great Deals out of 238 listings starting at $3,995
Used Dodge Ram 3500
88 Great Deals out of 2,297 listings starting at $5,999
Used Chevrolet Silverado 1500HD
6 Great Deals out of 279 listings starting at $3,900

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use.