Used Subaru Legacy for Sale near Poughquag, NY
CarGurus recommends the 2021 Subaru Legacy
Summary
- With 721 currently listed for sale on CarGurus and an average price of $20,812.10, 31.5% of 2021 Subaru Legacys for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
- Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2021 Subaru Legacy 4.8 / 5 stars and CarGurus experts gave it an 8.3 / 10.
- 81.7% of 2021 Legacy models on CarGurus are accident free.
- The 2021 Subaru Legacy featured standard all-wheel drive across all trims, enhancing its appeal for drivers seeking stability in various weather conditions.
Why it stands out
The Subaru Legacy is noteworthy for its unique offering of standard all-wheel drive across all trims, a feature that sets it apart in the midsize sedan segment. Its legacy of innovation includes being the first Subaru model built in America and pioneering advanced safety technologies like the EyeSight suite. Coupled with fuel efficiency and high safety ratings, the Legacy provides a compelling value proposition for those seeking reliability and comfort in their daily drive.
Other model years to consider
The 2016, 2017, and 2019 Subaru Legacy model years offer solid value due to their competitive pricing and high user ratings. With average prices ranging from approximately $11,525 to $16,385 and user ratings consistently at 5/5 for these models, they stand out as excellent choices in the used car market. Additionally, with a strong percentage of good or great deals available—37% for the 2017 model and around 35% for both the 2016 and 2018 models—buyers can find favorable purchasing opportunities that enhance their overall value proposition.
Model years to approach with caution
The Subaru Legacy model years from 2011, 2013, and 2012 face challenges related to financial aspects and quality metrics. Despite reasonable average prices ranging from $6,395 to $7,681, a significant portion of listings—between 70% to 76%—are categorized as not good or great deals, indicating limited value opportunities for buyers. Additionally, while user ratings are fairly strong (around 4.2 to 4.3 out of 5), the high percentage of listings that do not represent favorable transactions suggests potential availability constraints in the market.
These recommendations are based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from December 17, 2025, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.
4.5 Overall rating
(658 reviews)Customers say
The Subaru Legacy has consistently impressed owners across many model years with its strong all-wheel drive capability, comfortable interiors, and commendable fuel efficiency. Drivers appreciate the reliability and safety features, which make it an excellent choice for winter driving conditions. However, some complaints frequently arise regarding the vehicle's acceleration and power, with many wishing for a bit more performance, especially in the sportier models. Overall, the Legacy is regarded as a dependable, practical sedan that balances comfort and driving enjoyment.
AI generated from the text of customer reviews.
What people say
The 2008 Subaru Legacy is a standout mid-size sedan, combining elegance, performance, and all-weather capability with its standard all-wheel-drive system. Its sleek design, comfortable and high-quality interior, and precise handling make for an enjoyable driving experience. Safety features are top-notch, and the range of engines, including a turbocharged option, provides excellent performance. With its reliability and solid build, the 2008 Legacy is an excellent choice for those seeking a practical yet spirited ride.
The car ride smooth and is quite. It has good visibility and gas mileage.
This car is beautiful inside and out. The safety features are fantastic and the ride is like a luxury car. So happy
Super great car! So roomy and so safe! I love it
This car can take the abuse. Other than oil changes, tires and brakes. I’ve never done maintenance on this car 175k miles and still going. Oil changes every 12k miles. Good gas mileage around 35-40mpg if ya baby it. But this cars caveat is it has 0 Getty up.
Subaru Legacy FAQs
How much does the Subaru Legacy cost in Poughquag, NY?
The average Subaru Legacy costs about $18,379.20. The average price has increased by 1% since last year. The 191 for sale near Poughquag, NY on CarGurus, range from $3,395 to $32,899 in price.
How many Subaru Legacy vehicles in Poughquag, NY have no reported accidents or damage?
180 out of 191 for sale near Poughquag, NY have no reported accidents or damage.
What fuel types are available?
Gasoline engines are available.
-
All Used Cars
-
Manual Transmission Cars
-
Luxury Cars
-
Cars with Red Interior
-
Cheap Manual Cars
-
Hybrid Cars
-
Sports Cars
-
Electric SUVs
-
Cheap Trucks
-
Small Cars
-
Third Row SUVs
-
Three Quarter Ton Trucks
-
Lifted Trucks
-
Manual Transmission Trucks
-
Diesel Trucks
-
Hybrid SUVs
-
Dually Trucks
-
One Ton Trucks
-
Cheap SUVs
-
Lifted Ford Trucks
-
4x4 Trucks
-
Work Trucks
-
AWD SUVs
-
Ford Trucks
-
Chevrolet Trucks
-
Toyota Trucks
-
Trucks Under $10,000
-
Cars Under $15,000
-
Sports Cars Under $20,000
-
Trucks Under $20,000
-
Used Sedans for Sale with Low Mileage
-
Used SUVs / Crossovers for Sale with Low Mileage
-
Used Hatchbacks for Sale with Low Mileage
-
Used Convertibles for Sale with Low Mileage
-
Used Vans for Sale with Low Mileage
-
Used Minivans for Sale with Low Mileage
-
Used Pickup Trucks for Sale with Low Mileage
-
Used Coupes for Sale with Low Mileage
-
Used Wagons for Sale with Low Mileage