2023 Jeep Compass vs 2024 Mazda CX-5

The 2023 Jeep Compass exhibited a significant departure from its traditional utilitarian roots, adopting a more sophisticated, upscale aesthetic that aligned more closely with its larger siblings within the Jeep family like the Cherokee and Grand Cherokee. This model year introduced aesthetic enhancements across its Sport and Latitude models with new 17-inch wheel designs, while the Trailhawk version featured striking gloss black wheels. Special editions such as the Compass Red added further flair with options in black or silver paint, besides the titular red.

From the exterior, the Compass Limited's test vehicle, finished in Granite Crystal with optional 19-inch wheels, presented a resemblance to a miniaturized Grand Cherokee, a nod perhaps to the brand's upscale ambitions. Inside, the cabin's two-tone black and gray color scheme with caramel accents and sophisticated digital displays delivered a refined ambiance that rarely felt low-cost. The use of metallic trim and low-gloss plastics helped in crafting an interior that, while occasionally too pricey at the as-tested $45,800, generally projected a more matured and upscale vibe than its predecessors.

Conversely, the 2024 Mazda CX-5 maintained its visual appeal with minor changes that continued to endear its design to consumers. The introduction of the Carbon Turbo trim brought fresh aesthetic elements like exclusive Terracotta leather seats and black suede inserts which, when combined with new exterior colors such as Zircon Sand and Platinum Quartz, underscored Mazda's commitment to style and modernity. The CX-5's design, although aging, had aged gracefully, ensuring it still appeared contemporary and attractive.

The Carbon Turbo, in particular, benefited from gloss-black exterior detailing, enhancing its sporty appeal. This trim level, along with the overall line-up's upgrades like wireless charging and connectivity enhancements, confirmed that the CX-5 was not just maintaining pace with design trends but subtly leading in its class for those who valued a sophisticated visual appeal in their compact crossover.

Jeep introduced a transformative update to the Compass for 2023 with a new turbocharged 2.0-liter engine that produced 200 horsepower and 221 pound-feet of torque, a setup paired with an eight-speed automatic transmission and a standard Active Drive all-wheel-drive system. This engine greatly improved the drivability of the Compass, making it more competitive by offering adequate power across a wide rev range, enhancing both city driving and off-road capabilities—especially in the Trailhawk trim, which featured enhanced off-road gear and a more robust AWD system.

Despite its improvements, the Compass's performance still left room for refinement, particularly in fuel efficiency and power delivery on challenging terrains, where it occasionally struggled without the Rock mode engaged. However, the overall enhancements significantly elevated the Compass's performance profile from previous models, making it a viable option for those seeking a small SUV capable of occasional off-road adventures.

In contrast, the Mazda CX-5's 2024 model with the turbocharged 2.5-liter engine offered a substantial 256 horsepower (227 on regular gas) and up to 320 pound-feet of torque, providing a robust performance that, while not instantaneously thrilling, delivered satisfying power over a smooth acceleration curve. Despite lacking in raw acceleration, the CX-5 excelled in ride quality and handling, thanks to a well-tuned suspension and standard all-wheel drive that made it both fun and stable on varied terrains.

The CX-5's overall driving experience was refined over the years, making it a solid performer on highways and enjoyable on winding roads, even if its fuel efficiency wasn't particularly impressive. For those prioritizing driving dynamics in a compact SUV, the CX-5's performance made it a compelling choice.

Entering the 2023 Jeep Compass, one found a cabin that balanced space and functionality well, offering ample room and comfort features like dual-zone climate control and optional leather seating, which enhanced the small SUV's appeal as a luxury-lite option. Despite its narrower frame, the Compass managed to accommodate adults comfortably in both rows, with a cargo capacity that was competitive within its segment. This blend of form and functionality made the Compass a practical choice for small families or those needing a versatile daily driver.

Mazda's 2024 CX-5 also shone in its interior execution, with thoughtful ergonomics and quality materials that elevated the driving experience. Heated seats, a range of leather upholstery options across the trims, and a well-designed cabin meant that the CX-5 felt premium, often punching above its weight class in terms of interior quality. However, it was slightly smaller in terms of passenger space compared to competitors, though it still offered enough comfort and storage solutions for most practical needs.

Both vehicles presented strong cases for those valuing interior quality and functionality, with the Compass offering a more American take on small SUV luxury, while the CX-5 leaned into a more compact, refined execution typical of Japanese automakers.

The technology offerings in the 2023 Jeep Compass were robust, featuring a 10.1-inch touchscreen with the latest U

connect system that supported a seamless user experience with wireless connectivity options and advanced tech features like Alexa Built-in, which enhanced both convenience and usability. The Compass also boasted digital instrumentation and a premium Alpine sound system, rounding out a comprehensive tech suite that was both modern and user-friendly.

Mazda's approach with the CX-5 was different, focusing on minimizing driver distraction by eschewing a touchscreen for most functions and instead employing a rotary dial and button setup inspired by luxury brands. This system, while initially against the trend of touch interfaces, offered a less distracting user experience and maintained a focus on driving. Wireless features and a premium Bose sound system added to the CX-5's appeal, ensuring that it remained competitive in infotainment while prioritizing safety and ease of use.

Jeep equipped the 2023 Compass with an array of safety features including a new standard drowsy driver detection and rear-seat reminder, alongside an extensive suite of driving assists like forward collision warning and lane-keeping assist. The addition of semi-autonomous driving capabilities in higher trims also emphasized Jeep's focus on enhancing driver safety through technology.

Similarly, Mazda loaded the CX-5 with a comprehensive set of safety technologies, maintaining its reputation for safety with features like adaptive cruise control and lane-keeping assist, which were effective without being intrusive. The addition of adaptive headlights and other advanced features in higher trims further reinforced the CX-5's commitment to safety, supported by strong safety ratings from relevant authorities.