CarGurus Logo Homepage Link
  • Buy
    • Used cars
    • New cars
    • Certified pre-owned
    • Start your purchase online
    • Dealerships near me
  • Sell
    • Sell my car
    • Car values
    • Sell my car FAQs
  • Finance
    • Prequalify for financing
    • How does it work?
    • Financing FAQs
  • Research
    • Test drive reviews
    • Price trends
    • Tips & advice
    • Electric cars
    • Compare cars
  • Discover
    The latest way to shop:
    smarter research, better
    listings.
  • Saved cars & searches
  • Sign in / Register
    • My account
    • Saved searches
    • Saved cars
    • Recommended cars
    • Browsing history
    • Financing dashboard
      • United States (EN)
      • Estados Unidos (ES)
      • Canada (EN)
      • Canada (FR)
      • United Kingdom

Used Subaru Legacy for Sale near Cayuta, NY

312 results
Cayuta, NY
2016 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited AWD Ryan Phelps Auto Sales LLC

2016 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Limited AWD

114,338 miles

$11,995

Fair Deal
Auburn, NY
57 mi away
Year:
2016
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
White
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
114,338
Stock number:
016185
VIN:
4S3BNAL65G3016185

Sponsored

2023 Subaru Legacy Premium AWD

2023 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

75,553 miles

$19,995

Good Deal
Farmington, NY
59 mi away
Year:
2023
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Cosmic Blue Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Titanium Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
75,553
Stock number:
C9820
VIN:
4S3BWAF62P3005816

Sponsored

2024 Subaru Legacy Premium AWD

2024 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

22,645 miles

$20,791

Great Deal
Sunbury, PA
97 mi away
Year:
2024
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Crimson Red Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
22,645
Stock number:
W0127A
VIN:
4S3BWAC62R3019402

Sponsored

2021 Subaru Legacy Touring XT AWD

2021 Subaru Legacy

Touring XT AWD

75,744 miles

$21,467

Good Deal
Scranton, PA
78 mi away
Year:
2021
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
260 hp 2.4L H4
Exterior color:
Magnetite Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
28 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Brown (Tan)
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
75,744
Stock number:
DC25419A
VIN:
4S3BWGP67M3018008

2024 Subaru Legacy Premium AWD

2024 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

35,510 miles

$21,250

Great Deal
Certified Pre-Owned
Wilkes Barre, PA
83 mi away
Year:
2024
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Magnetite Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
35,510
Stock number:
S83496A
VIN:
4S3BWAF69R3004195

2023 Subaru Legacy Premium AWD

2023 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

21,961 miles

$23,399

Fair Deal
Hazleton, PA
95 mi away
Year:
2023
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Ice Silver Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
21,961
Stock number:
7134A
VIN:
4S3BWAF64P3010936

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2017 Subaru Legacy

3.6R Limited AWD

70,797 miles

$15,900

Fair Deal
Moosic, PA
80 mi away
Year:
2017
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
256 hp 3.6L H6
Exterior color:
Ice Silver Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
24 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Slate Black
Transmission:
6-Speed CVT
Mileage:
70,797
Stock number:
U17482
VIN:
4S3BNEK64H3011537

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

24,561 miles

$23,923

Good Deal
Rochester, NY
85 mi away
Year:
2024
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Crystal White Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Titanium Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
24,561
Stock number:
SB26L022
VIN:
4S3BWAF65R3008261

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

22,645 miles

$20,791

Great Deal
Sunbury, PA
97 mi away
Year:
2024
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Crimson Red Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
22,645
Stock number:
W0127A
VIN:
4S3BWAC62R3019402

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2010 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Limited AWD

106,400 miles

$7,595

Good Deal
Towanda, PA
39 mi away
Year:
2010
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Bue
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Transmission:
5-Speed Automatic
Mileage:
106,400
Stock number:
243278
VIN:
4S3BMBK65A3243278

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

834 miles

$26,389

Good Deal
Hamilton, NY
70 mi away
Year:
2025
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Crimson Red Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Slate Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
834
Stock number:
P115B
VIN:
4S3BWAD60S3025137

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

16,058 miles

$25,000

Good Deal
Certified Pre-Owned
Muncy, PA
71 mi away
Year:
2025
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Silver
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
16,058
Stock number:
SU6308
VIN:
4S3BWAC65S3025376

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

8,903 miles

$25,985

Good Deal
Central Square, NY
75 mi away
Year:
2025
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Cosmic Blue Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
8,903
Stock number:
P5202
VIN:
4S3BWAD66S3018225

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2017 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

116,049 miles

$11,995

Fair Deal
Spencerport, NY
88 mi away
Year:
2017
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Gray (Tungsten Metallic)
Combined gas mileage:
29 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
White (Warm Ivory)
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
116,049
Stock number:
RV015023
VIN:
4S3BNAD67H3015023

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2023 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

34,040 miles

$21,999

Good Deal
Elmira, NY
13 mi away
Year:
2023
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Blue
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
34,040
Stock number:
1-78572
VIN:
4S3BWAF62P3007971

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Subaru Legacy

Premium AWD

3,878 miles

$26,500

Good Deal
Certified Pre-Owned
Muncy, PA
71 mi away
Year:
2025
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
White
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
3,878
Stock number:
SU6324
VIN:
4S3BWAD69S3025041

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2016 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Limited AWD

114,338 miles

$11,995

Fair Deal
Auburn, NY
57 mi away
Year:
2016
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
White
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
114,338
Stock number:
016185
VIN:
4S3BNAL65G3016185

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 Subaru Legacy

Limited AWD

56,213 miles

$20,000

Good Deal
Muncy, PA
78 mi away
Year:
2021
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
White
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
SLATE BLACK
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
56,213
Stock number:
BA13130A
VIN:
4S3BWAN69M3006782

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2016 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

139,499 miles

$9,995

Fair Deal
Ontario, NY
74 mi away
Year:
2016
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Silver
Combined gas mileage:
31 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black (Charcoal)
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
139,499
Stock number:
53717
VIN:
4S3BNAD61G3053717

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2020 Subaru Legacy

Touring XT AWD

37,082 miles

$24,983

Fair Deal
Northumberland, PA
94 mi away
Year:
2020
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
260 hp 2.4L H4
Exterior color:
Crimson Red Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
28 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Brown (Tan)
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
37,082
Stock number:
30018A
VIN:
4S3BWGP69L3014279

Sponsored

  1. Home
  2. / Used Cars
  3. / Subaru Legacy
  4. / New York
  5. / Cayuta
Overview
Reviews
FAQs

CarGurus recommends the 2021 Subaru Legacy

Picture of Subaru Legacy ## Summary - With 641 currently listed for sale on CarGurus and an **average price of $19,950.00**, 32.8% of 2021 Subaru Legacys for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals. - **Favorably reviewed:** Owners rated the 2021 Subaru Legacy 4.83 / 5 stars. - **80.0% of 2021 Legacy models on CarGurus are accident free**. - The 2021 Subaru Legacy delivers standard all-wheel drive and budget-friendly pricing, making it a prime option in the midsize sedan class. ## Why it stands out The 2021 Subaru Legacy stands out due to its unique combination of standard all-wheel drive, fuel efficiency, and advanced safety features, making it especially appealing to buyers in regions with challenging weather conditions. This model is designed to accommodate both comfort and practicality, ensuring a smooth driving experience while also providing ample interior space. Additionally, it ranks as one of the safest vehicles, further solidifying its reputation among dependable midsize sedans. ## Other model years to consider - **[2024 Subaru Legacy](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2024-Subaru-Legacy-c32851)** - Average price: $24,082.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 27.6% - User rating: 4.75 / 5 - Total listings: 1,255 - **[2019 Subaru Legacy](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2019-Subaru-Legacy-c28434)** - Average price: $16,183.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 35.4% - User rating: 5 / 5 - Total listings: 672 - **[2018 Subaru Legacy](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2018-Subaru-Legacy-c26645)** - Average price: $14,002.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 32.8% - User rating: 5 / 5 - Total listings: 635 These recommendations are based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from March 9, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.

4.5 Overall rating

(658 reviews)

Customers say

The Subaru Legacy has consistently impressed owners across many model years with its strong all-wheel drive capability, comfortable interiors, and commendable fuel efficiency. Drivers appreciate the reliability and safety features, which make it an excellent choice for winter driving conditions. However, some complaints frequently arise regarding the vehicle's acceleration and power, with many wishing for a bit more performance, especially in the sportier models. Overall, the Legacy is regarded as a dependable, practical sedan that balances comfort and driving enjoyment.

AI generated from the text of customer reviews.

What people say

AWD fuel economy interior performance safety
Anonymous
5.0
Reviewed a 2008 Subaru Legacy on Jun 12, 2024

The 2008 Subaru Legacy is a standout mid-size sedan, combining elegance, performance, and all-weather capability with its standard all-wheel-drive system. Its sleek design, comfortable and high-quality interior, and precise handling make for an enjoyable driving experience. Safety features are top-notch, and the range of engines, including a turbocharged option, provides excellent performance. With its reliability and solid build, the 2008 Legacy is an excellent choice for those seeking a practical yet spirited ride.

Meredith W
5.0
Reviewed a 2018 Subaru Legacy on Mar 30, 2024

The car ride smooth and is quite. It has good visibility and gas mileage.

Christi W
5.0
Reviewed a 2018 Subaru Legacy on Jun 30, 2024

Super great car! So roomy and so safe! I love it

Chase R
5.0
Reviewed a 2015 Subaru 2.5i Limited AWD on Jun 04, 2024

This car can take the abuse. Other than oil changes, tires and brakes. I’ve never done maintenance on this car 175k miles and still going. Oil changes every 12k miles. Good gas mileage around 35-40mpg if ya baby it. But this cars caveat is it has 0 Getty up.

Serge K
3.0
Reviewed a 1997 Subaru Outback Wagon AWD on Sep 12, 2008

My first car purchase ever. I was just finishing up my freshman year of college and I told myself that if I made enough money I could spend half of it on a car purchase. My parents always told me that I had to earn things and throughout high school I would just borrow my dad's car but I never felt like it was my own. So as soon as I had the money I wanted to buy a car that fit my lifestyle at the time. Well I was shopping for a car for a few months and I finally came across an ad for a Subaru Outback for only $3600. I immediately thought of all the cool stuff I could transport in it: my bikes and sports equipment, computers and hardware for my job, DJ equipment on the weekends, suitcases and bags for road trips with my friends... What I didn't even think of was how cool it was to rally race the legacy after I put rally shock absorbers and tweaked the transmission. The 5 speed manual was able to reach 60 in 7.9 seconds but thanks to a flywheel and intercooler addition I was able to get a station wagon up to 60 in 6.8 seconds and half the time I was doing it in knee deep mud. Towing capacity was great on the Outback and at one point I had 9 bikes folded up inside the car with the seats flat, 2 more on the roof and 3 hanging from the trunk, truly an amazing car. During move in and move out days I was the only non SUV that was able to move their entire dorm in one trip. Speaking of SUVs, the Legacy handled perfectly, with the AWD and the Goodyear extra grip tires I was able to hold 45 on a tight turn before hitting a puddle and losing grip on one wheel at 50 mph. Took the cheapest gas I could find and got pretty good fuel economy for an AWD 160 hp car. Appearance was a tough call, I myself love the look of a wagon, and when you compare the 98 Legacy Wagon with other 98 wagons it looks much better than the Volvo V70, Ford Taurus and a lot of SUVs. The Audi, Mercedes and BMW wagons might look a little better but they cost twice if not three times as much and not all of them have AWD. It was a really really really fun car, took everything I threw at it.

Subaru Legacy FAQs

How much does the Subaru Legacy cost in Cayuta, NY?

The average Subaru Legacy costs about $18,394.84. The average price has decreased by -0.8% since last year. The 246 for sale near Cayuta, NY on CarGurus, range from $2,094 to $31,583 in price.

How many Subaru Legacy vehicles in Cayuta, NY have no reported accidents or damage?

184 out of 246 for sale near Cayuta, NY have no reported accidents or damage.

What fuel types are available?

Gasoline engines are available.

  • 2025 Subaru Legacy in Cayuta NY

  • 2024 Subaru Legacy

  • 2023 Subaru Legacy

  • 2022 Subaru Legacy

  • 2021 Subaru Legacy

  • 2020 Subaru Legacy

  • Used Subaru Legacy for Sale Under $10,000 Near Cayuta

  • Used Subaru Legacy for Sale Under $15,000 Near Cayuta

  • Used Subaru Legacy for Sale Under $20,000 Near Cayuta

  • Used Subaru Legacy for Sale Under $25,000 Near Cayuta

  • Used Subaru Legacy for Sale Under $30,000 Near Cayuta

  • Used Subaru Legacy for Sale Under $40,000 Near Cayuta

  • Used White Subaru Legacy for Sale in Cayuta

  • Used Blue Subaru Legacy for Sale in Cayuta

  • Used Red Subaru Legacy for Sale in Cayuta

  • Used Black Subaru Legacy for Sale in Cayuta

  • Used Silver Subaru Legacy for Sale in Cayuta

  • Used Gray Subaru Legacy for Sale in Cayuta

  • Subaru Legacy Premium AWD

  • Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium AWD

  • Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited AWD

  • Subaru Legacy Limited AWD

  • Subaru Legacy 2.5i AWD

  • Subaru Legacy 3.6R Limited AWD

  • Subaru Legacy Touring XT AWD

  • Subaru Legacy Sport AWD

  • Subaru Legacy 2.5i Sport AWD

  • Subaru Legacy AWD

  • Used Subaru Electric Cars for Sale

  • Reliable Cars for Sale in Cayuta NY

  • Reliable Cheap Cars For Sale in Cayuta NY

  • Used Subaru Legacy for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Used Sedans for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • New Subaru Legacy in Cayuta NY

  • Certified Used Subaru Legacy in Cayuta NY

  • Honda Accord in Cayuta NY

  • Kia Optima in Cayuta NY

  • Chevrolet Malibu in Cayuta NY

  • Subaru Legacy in Elmira NY

  • Subaru Legacy in Ithaca NY

  • Subaru Legacy in Binghamton NY

  • Subaru Legacy in Syracuse NY

  • Subaru Legacy in Williamsport PA

  • Subaru Legacy in Rochester NY

  • Subaru Legacy in Wilkes Barre PA

  • Subaru Legacy in Utica NY

  • Subaru Legacy in Buffalo NY

  • All Used Cars

  • Manual Transmission Cars

  • Luxury Cars

  • Cars with Red Interior

  • Cheap Manual Cars

  • Hybrid Cars

  • Sports Cars

  • Electric SUVs

  • Cheap Trucks

  • Small Cars

  • Third Row SUVs

  • Three Quarter Ton Trucks

  • Lifted Trucks

  • Manual Transmission Trucks

  • Diesel Trucks

  • Hybrid SUVs

  • Dually Trucks

  • One Ton Trucks

  • Cheap SUVs

  • Lifted Ford Trucks

  • 4x4 Trucks

  • Work Trucks

  • AWD SUVs

  • Ford Trucks

  • Chevrolet Trucks

  • Toyota Trucks

  • Trucks Under $10,000

  • Cars Under $15,000

  • Sports Cars Under $20,000

  • Trucks Under $20,000

  • Used Sedans for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Used SUVs / Crossovers for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Used Hatchbacks for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Used Convertibles for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Used Vans for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Used Minivans for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Used Pickup Trucks for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Used Coupes for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Used Wagons for Sale with Low Mileage in Cayuta

  • Maguire Hyundai Subaru

  • Williams Subaru of Sayre

Connect with us
Download our app
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play
  • Company
  • About CarGurus
  • Our team
  • Press
  • Investor relations
  • Price trends
  • Careers
  • Advertise with CarGurus
  • For dealers
  • Dealer signup
  • Dealer resources
  • Terms
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy policy
  • Interest-based ads
  • Security
  • Help
  • Help center
  • Contact us
Click for the BBB Business Review of this Auto Listing Service in Cambridge MA
    • United States (EN)
    • Estados Unidos (ES)
    • Canada (EN)
    • Canada (FR)
    • United Kingdom

© 2026 CarGurus, Inc., All Rights Reserved.