Used 2010 Subaru Legacy for Sale nearNew York, NY

Filters (3)

Location:

Only show listings in NY?

Include delivery listings?

21 vehicles found

Shop with transparent pricing.

Only show listings that include dealer fees
Year:
2009
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Gray
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Taupe
Transmission:
4-Speed Automatic Overdrive
Mileage:
63,871
Stock #:
212847E
VIN:
4S3BL626897212847
Gray 2009 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 4-Speed Automatic Overdrive
Cargenic Automotive

Sponsored by Cargenic Automotive

2009 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Limited AWD

63,871 mi

Lindenhurst, NY
32 mi away
Good Deal

$8,575

Year:
2009
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Obsidian Black Pearl
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Off Black Cloth
Transmission:
4-Speed Automatic Overdrive
Mileage:
126,975
Stock #:
071604
VIN:
4S3BL616297229502
Obsidian Black Pearl 2009 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 4-Speed Automatic Overdrive
Price drop

-$200

Sponsored Listing

2009 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Special Edition AWD

126,975 mi

Brooklyn, NY
7 mi away
Good Deal

$4,190

$3,990

Year:
2010
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
256 hp 3.6L H6
Exterior color:
Graphite Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
21 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Off Black
Transmission:
5-Speed Automatic
Mileage:
41,907
Stock #:
228406
VIN:
4S3BMDK6XA2228406
Graphite Gray Metallic 2010 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 5-Speed Automatic
New arrival

Sponsored Listing

2010 Subaru Legacy

3.6R Limited AWD

41,907 mi

Mountain Lakes, NJ
26 mi away
Great Deal

$10,790

Year:
2009
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Gray
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Taupe
Transmission:
4-Speed Automatic Overdrive
Mileage:
63,871
Stock #:
212847E
VIN:
4S3BL626897212847
Gray 2009 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 4-Speed Automatic Overdrive

 

2009 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Limited AWD

63,871 mi

Lindenhurst, NY
32 mi away
Good Deal

$8,575

Year:
2009
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Obsidian Black Pearl
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Off Black Cloth
Transmission:
4-Speed Automatic Overdrive
Mileage:
126,975
Stock #:
071604
VIN:
4S3BL616297229502
Obsidian Black Pearl 2009 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 4-Speed Automatic Overdrive
Price drop

-$200

 

2009 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Special Edition AWD

126,975 mi

Brooklyn, NY
7 mi away
Good Deal

$4,190

$3,990

Year:
2011
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Gray
Combined gas mileage:
27 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
137,367
Stock #:
5264
VIN:
4S3BMBC64B3245264
Vehicle photo unavailable

 

2011 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

137,367 mi

Garfield, NJ
11 mi away
Good Deal

$4,594

Year:
2009
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Blue
Combined gas mileage:
23 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
5-Speed Manual
Mileage:
121,100
Stock #:
20346
VIN:
4S3BL616096213501
Blue 2009 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 5-Speed Manual

 

2009 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Special Edition AWD

121,100 mi

East Brunswick, NJ
32 mi away
Good Deal

$5,199

Year:
2011
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Azurite Blue Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
27 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
121,866
Stock #:
3260242
VIN:
4S3BMBG62B3260243
Azurite Blue Pearl 2011 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Automatic

 

2011 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

121,866 mi

Home delivery from Wayland, MA
Price includes $176 shipping
Fair Deal

$6,570

Year:
2009
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Diamond Gray
Combined gas mileage:
23 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Off Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
147,018
Stock #:
S-224228
VIN:
4S3BL616597224228
Diamond Gray 2009 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Automatic

 

2009 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Special Edition AWD

147,018 mi

Home delivery from Canton, MA
Price includes $270 shipping
Fair Deal

$4,855

Year:
2010
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Black
Combined gas mileage:
27 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
88,924
Stock #:
234088
VIN:
4S3BMCE68A3234088
Black 2010 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Continuously Variable Transmission

 

2010 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

88,924 mi

Home delivery from Addison, IL
Price includes $732 shipping
Fair Deal

$8,051

About 2010 Subaru Legacy
4.7 Overall rating(12 reviews)
Ali M says...
Nov 13, 2014
I bought this car with 40k miles back in 2013. The Lariche Subaru in Findley Ohio had service this car from headlights to exhaust muffler. Just regular oil change and tire rotation on this car until it reached its 60k service. I drove it along on country roads. I drove it to Canada and also drove it twice to VA. Great gas mileage at driving 75-80 mph. 33+ mpg on the highway. This is my first Subaru but I'm so glad I bought this car. Sometime calculating your budget and buying something really odd can turn out to be one of the best investments you've done. Subaru's are great cars with the bucks worthing every penny. Once you drive an AWD car, you'd never enjoy driving a FWD car. 2010 Subaru Legacy Limited 2.5i (Stock) 170hp AWD K&N air filter.
Jonathan M says...
Dec 2, 2009
I love the Legacy for the 256 horsepower 3.6 litre flat six and 5 speed SPORTSHIFT automatic transmission that provides spirited performance for a nearly 3600 pound car. The car as can be expected for one with All Wheel Drive is not the most athletic on the street but it corners without drama and goes pretty well in a straight line. The build quality is execptional. I had a WRX 5 years ago and the car nearly fell apart. The Legacy feels as solid as a brick wall. The styling is an evolution of the previous generation so it crisply done and very handsome. The only costs i have incurred over the first 3,363 miles is the cost of petrol.
Cathy P says...
Oct 27, 2009
Great looks, runs smooth, wonderful savings on gasoline, good value for the price. Love the lumbar support and the heated seats! Buy one today friends!
Anonymous says...
Jan 8, 2015
I researched many vehicles and I bought what I wanted, Its been a great car and I would buy another one. I couldn't touch any other AWD vehicle for the price of my Subaru. Granted its no truck, and I miss mine, I have mostly owed 4wd trucks, however the gas mileage plus the AWD capability was worth the down size. I drive this car every day, in all kinds of weather, snow included, and with winter tires its like a tank, and sticks to the road like glue. This car has been more then I expected, and I have got my moneys worth out of it. I will drive it to the ground. Crash safety one of the best cars I have seen, I am a volunteer fireman have been for 20yrs, and Subaru holds up; one of the best in a crash.
John W says...
Apr 29, 2013
Ride, fuel economy for AWD car. CVT transmission nice. Very roomy. Very reliable. Great in the snow, Doors shut like a Mercedes, very solid. 60/40 back seat very useful for packing, especially skis or longer items. Would buy another.
Year:
2011
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Caramel Bronze Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
27 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
White (Ivory)
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
131,997
Stock #:
P211707
VIN:
4S3BMBC67B3211707
Caramel Bronze Pearl 2011 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Continuously Variable Transmission

 

2011 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

131,997 mi

Home delivery from Portland, OR
Price includes $3,046 shipping
Uncertain

$10,031

Year:
2010
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Sky Blue Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
23 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
White (Ivory)
Transmission:
6-Speed Manual
Mileage:
167,308
Stock #:
5127TR
VIN:
4S3BMAA64A1216273
Sky Blue Metallic 2010 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 6-Speed Manual
New arrival

 

2010 Subaru Legacy

2.5i AWD

167,308 mi

Home delivery from Gladstone, OR
Price includes $2,438 shipping
Uncertain

$10,683

Year:
2011
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Graphite Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
27 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Off Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
96,132
Stock #:
B3218449
VIN:
4S3BMBC62B3218449
Graphite Gray Metallic 2011 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Continuously Variable Transmission
New arrival

 

2011 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

96,132 mi

Home delivery from San Jose, CA
Price includes $12,745 shipping
Uncertain

$21,862

Year:
2011
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Silver
Combined gas mileage:
27 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
152,615
Stock #:
100RX
VIN:
4S3BMBC66B3261885
Silver 2011 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Automatic

 

2011 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

152,615 mi

Keyport, NJ
26 mi away
High Priced

$6,375

Year:
2009
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Newport Blue Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
23 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Taupe
Transmission:
4-Speed Automatic
Mileage:
125,093
Stock #:
8469A
VIN:
4S3BL616697222794
Newport Blue Pearl 2009 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive 4-Speed Automatic
New arrival

 

2009 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Special Edition AWD

125,093 mi

Home delivery from Grand Junction, CO
Price includes $2,554 shipping
High Priced

$7,048

Year:
2011
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Legacy
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Red
Combined gas mileage:
27 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
172,611
Stock #:
23132M
VIN:
4S3BMCC66B3235101
Red 2011 Subaru Legacy Sedan All-Wheel Drive Continuously Variable Transmission

 

2011 Subaru Legacy

2.5i Premium AWD

172,611 mi

Home delivery from North Augusta, SC
Price includes $1,316 shipping
Overpriced

$6,311

Overview

Image Not Available

A twenty-year lifespan provides a lot of time for refinement, and Subaru had a heck of a fine starting point with the Legacy. Before the official unveiling at the New York International Auto Show (April 10th-19th), Subaru revealed specs and pics for the 2010 Legacy, showing us a car that's bigger, taller, and more powerful.

Let’s start with the outside specs of this all-wheel-drive four-door sport sedan. The '09 edition is 35mm longer, 90mm wider, and 80mm taller than in 2009, with an 80mm longer wheelbase as well. This means more legroom, headroom, and trunk space. The front grille and C-pillars are reminiscent of the 2009 model's, but the rest of the car has been redesigned to have a more aggressive look. Inside, Subaru attempted to create a more open space, eliminating the lever-operated parking brake in favor of a cleaner electronic option, and redesigning the instrument panel along the same lines. The three-spoke steering wheel has been redesigned and includes audio controls and paddle shifters for automatic trims. Interior storage has also been increased with a larger console box and armrest.

Perhaps the biggest news is in the engine and transmission lineup. Every engine is tweaked, revised, or remapped. Starting with the base 2.5i trim, the 2.5-liter boxer four gets a weight-saving resin-baked intake manifold that brings peak torque in at 4,000 rpm, as opposed to the previous 4,400. Subaru reports improved cooling and a revised catalytic converter have increased fuel efficiency to 19/27 mpg. The turbocharged 2.5 for the 2.5GT is revised with a modified turbo and an rpm reduction for more power and efficiency. Even with the 22-hp increase and additional 17 lb-ft of torque, fuel efficiency comes in at 18/25. Both engines now come standard with a six-speed manual transmission. An optional continuously variable transmission (CVT) is new for the 2.5i, although the automatic option for the 2.5GT is still a five-speed. The CVT is especially notable as the first longitudinally mounted CVT in an AWD car, not to mention its impressive fuel economy of 23/31.

The top-tier 3.6R gets a big upgrade in its 3.6-liter boxer six-cylinder engine, putting out an additional 11 hp and 32 lb-ft of torque over the outgoing 3.0, although the sole transmission available is a five-speed automatic, with that combo achieving 18/25. The suspension has also been revised across the model line, and all trims now include standard stability control.

*CarGurus meticulously monitors the prices of millions of pre-owned vehicle listings, offering users precise and up-to-date market insights. Historical pricing data excludes any additional dealer fees as of May 3, 2026.

A better way to discover your best deal

Let us help you find a car you’ll love.