2008 Audi S5 User Reviews

Have you driven a 2008 Audi S5?  
Rank This Car

User Reviews

View reviews where users commented on categories.

Clear selections

Displaying 11 - 14 of 14 2008 Audi S5 reviews.

2008 Audi S5Review

Great Power Delivery But Nonintuitive Interior Controls. —

My father and I went to test drive this car as soon as we saw that the local Audi dealership had one on the lot. I was really impressed with how smooth the engine was on this car, but the clutch took a lot of getting used to as it engages about a micron off the floor but this was soon forgiven once you got out of first gear, but there is no feathering the clutch when trying to start this car moving! This leads to my first real complaint, when trying to start moving again after being stopped at a red light right outside of the dealership, I accidentally brought the clutch out a bit too far (1.5 microns instead of 1) and ended up killing the engine in the middle of Main Street. Not to worry I thought and touched the large "Engine Start" button. Nothing happened, I tried again, same result, I tried putting the car in neutral and hitting the button, nothing, put on the parking brake, nothing. Now I was a bit nervous, I started fiddling with the myriad of controls on the dash of the car, all while keeping my feet firmly on the clutch and brakes when i somehow managed to bump the key flob that was securely in its place in the dash, and lo and behold, the engine purred to life. For some reason, Audi in their infinite genius decided that if the key was in its spot that you had to press the key flob in to start the car, but if you left the key out of that spot, you had to push the "Engine Start" button, why they did this, who knows, but this wasn't the only thing confusing about the interior. When you sit down in this car, you are confronted with more switches and buttons than are equipped on the USS Enterprise and the dual screens (one in the instrument cluster and one in the normal sat-nav position in the dash) each with their own roller selector on the steering wheel, make even changing the radio a chore at first. Don't get me wrong, from a purely driving stand point, I loved this car, the seats were comfortable but supportive and communicative, the shifting was short and crisp and the ride quality was superb, however compared to the interior of a comparable BMW with their iDrive system, the Audi's extra switchery felt awkward and cluttered to the first time user. I am sure once one is used to this system, it would probably feel very natural but the overall first impression left me wanting something with a more minimalist control scheme. About the only other thing that I was disappointed with was how tall first gear was. With how the clutch on this car was, I expected first gear to be a little bit more forgiving, but even with this car's great engine, the all wheel drive system made sure that if you weren't within that small acceptable range on the clutch and the throttle, you either killed the engine or jerked off the line. With these few things aside though, I really enjoyed my test drive of Audi's new S5 and am looking forward to trying out next years model.

Pros: Good looking car, great smooth power delivery, short, crisp shifting, smooth yet
communicative ride quality and lots of extra fun gadgets inside to keep all but the craziest
of technophiles happy.

Cons: Weird "fairy lamps" around the headlights, the interior control scheme is not intuitive,
nonintuitive starting routine if the key is in its slot and really tall first gear.

3 of 3 people found this review helpful.
Is this helpful? Yes | No
2008 Audi S5 4.2 quattro Coupe AWDReview

A Great All-round Car For A Lazy Driver — I very much enjoy driving it, even though I've got a manual transmission and have to shift it abt a 1000 times in traffic jams

Pros: Easy to handle, not demanding, looks great

Cons: Could perform better for a v8,

Is this review helpful? Yes | No
2008 Audi S5 4.2 quattro Coupe AWDReview

2008 Audi S5 — not totally fun to drive, performance is similar to 3.35i but the looks, its awesome

Pros: design

Cons: not fun to drive

Is this review helpful? Yes | No
2008 Audi S5 4.2 quattro Coupe AWD Review
Feel heavy despite with the 4.2L. Its decent but definitely not as fun as the E60 M5 with a V10 engine under the hood.
vs2008 BMW M5 RWD
2008 Audi S5 4.2 quattro Coupe AWD winning categories:
  • Power
  • Handling
  • Looks/Style
  • Front Seats
  • Back Seats
  • Cargo Capacity
  • Family Car
  • Value
  • Would Buy
Looks/Style Ranked 2008 BMW M5 RWD better.
"I think they are pretty much the same except that the BMW E60 M5 has a very unique overall aggressive stance in a Sedan vs. a Coupe. "
Back Seats Ranked 2008 BMW M5 RWD better.
"M5 is a 4-door sedan with ample amount of leg room and convenience for rear passengers getting in and out of the vehicle."
Is this review helpful? Yes | No

Displaying 11 - 14 of 14 2008 Audi S5 reviews.

Reviews From Other Years

2014 Audi S5 Reviews

Amazing Experience! By AlbyC

The drive is amazing! I've had so much fun on the road! Hugging corners and speeding past cars is such a thrill! I feel safe in this car, even though it's a soft top. I've purposely attempted to lose ... Read More

I Love It!!! By brandonzora

i like my car greatly because of the looks, the power, the drive, the sound system is great, and it is very comfortable compared to other sports cars of its class including the BMW 435i which I was su... Read More

2013 Audi S5 Reviews

Amazing Ride! By Mohamed_Hany

This is my first Audi I had and I really amazed of how German Audi engineers design their cars it's luxuries and sporty with reliable technology for the 20th century! I would recommend this car to an... Read More

2011 Audi S5 Reviews

Incredible Car By Keith

This is the best car that I have ever owned. It is exciting and fun to drive. I have owned nearly every make of car on the road including: Chevy, Ford, Lexus, BMW, Mercedes and more. Audi tops them... Read More

2010 Audi S5 Reviews

Dream Car By igorlebed

this car is all wheel drive which made it faster then most cars and I loved the way this coupe looked. didn't like how the fuel wasn't so good and not so much room in the back seats, overall would giv... Read More

Now I Own Two Audis. By Madmanmoon61571

Comparing this car to others solely based upon it's 0-60 time ( less than 5 seconds is plenty fast) misses the point. Mechanically it's a masterpiece for sure...aluminum V8, herculean brakes, torque v... Read More

2009 Audi S5 Reviews

Excellent Vehicle By CPR323

Car has great power and torque with impressive handling (AWD) in all weather. Braking and other safety features (back-up camera and side assist) make you feel at ease driving the car. Not designed for... Read More

The Perfect North Eastern All Year Sports Car By yaqub0r

One day I decided that our family minivan was just too slow for me. I wanted a sports car. We get quite a bit of snow so it had to be AWD. I would have taken a small 4-door, but I really wanted a coup... Read More

Cars compared to 2008 Audi S5People researching a 2008 Audi S5 contacted a dealer about


Looking for a Used S5 in your area?

CarGurus has 1,976 nationwide S5 listings starting at $11,000.

Have you driven a 2008 Audi S5?  
Rank Your Car →