With an EPA-rated 204 miles of maximum driving range and an acceleration time of 5.5 seconds to 60 mph, the Audi e-tron struggles to compete with the standard-bearing electric SUV in the class, the Tesla Model X. But do you really need to spend the extra ten grand to get the Tesla’s 328 miles of range and 4.4-second zero-to-60 time?
Most likely, the answer is no. Most people who buy a long-range EV like the e-tron and Model X install a 240-volt home charging solution at their residence. They plug the vehicle in each night and recharge the battery during off-peak hours when electricity rates are lower. According to Audi, 80% of EV owners wake up to maximum driving range every day.
If you drive 15,000 miles per year, you average fewer than 42 miles per day. That means the Audi e-tron’s comparatively meager 204-mile range only matters if you need to travel farther than that. In a Tesla Model X, you can access the company’s exclusive nationwide network of Superchargers to facilitate long-distance travel, and use them for free. In an Audi e-tron, you can’t. And that’s the crux of the e-tron’s problem.
Let me illustrate. On the day CarGurus shot the e-tron video review, our test car was 60 miles short of a full battery. Audi has partnered with Electrify America in an attempt to mimic Tesla Supercharger availability, but the nearest of the provider’s DC fast-charging stations are at a Target shopping center 32.9 miles away from my Southern California home. My local mall, a few miles down the road and filled with appealing stores to window shop, has EVgo DC fast chargers, so that’s where I went.
To get to the EVgo chargers, I drove past a row of Tesla Superchargers at the same mall, with half of the available slots empty. The EVgo setup has two DC fast chargers and a single 240-volt charger. When I pulled up, another Audi e-tron was already plugged in, so I took the empty space. Sure enough, the unused DC fast charger’s instruction screen was blank, the credit-card reader was blinking, and it was making a weird clicking sound. A call to customer service confirmed that this charger was in “maintenance mode” and unavailable.
Fortunately, the owner of the other e-tron came out of the mall and, after an exchange of pleasantries about the cars, I connected to the active charger for a 45-minute session. It didn’t take that long for the e-tron’s battery to top off, but when the charging station determined the battery was full, the e-tron’s trip computer showed only 181 miles of range.
Upon arrival in Malibu to shoot the video, I sought out the only nearby charging stations that were not tucked behind the gates leading into the Pepperdine University campus. ChargePoint has a couple of chargers at the Whole Foods in the Malibu Country Mart shopping district, so I headed over to top off before filming began. Again, I drove into the parking lot past a row of gleaming Tesla Superchargers and, after some effort, found two ChargePoint machines tucked toward the back of the lot. Unfortunately, they were already in use. By the time I returned to the meeting location where I’d promised to meet the videographer, I’d burned through an extra seven miles of range seeking an open charging station.
This is the primary obstacle to long-range EV ownership: simple, fast, guaranteed access to DC fast chargers when you’re away from your primary source of electricity. This is also why, unless you’re buying an EV as a second vehicle, I think plug-in hybrids are the best choice until the public infrastructure dramatically expands and improves. Lastly, this is why the Tesla Model X’s extra 124 miles of range is so compelling, and why it might be worth an extra ten grand.
With that said, I do like the Audi e-tron. From the futuristic, sci-fi movie sounds it makes at idle and at low speeds to its classic German sports wagon driving dynamics, it's mostly pleasing to drive.
Liquid-cooled front and rear electric motors effectively create a Quattro all-wheel-drive system and make a combined 402 horsepower and 414 pound-feet of torque. Activate the Dynamic driving mode or Sport mode, and you’ll have 490 lb-ft of torque at your disposal for a short period of time. With this, it delivers 60 mph in 5.5 seconds.
I didn’t use Dynamic or Sport mode much. In Dynamic mode, the adaptive air suspension feels too stiff and choppy, and Sport mode unnecessarily burns through battery charge. The e-tron is plenty quick enough in Auto or Comfort mode, and even when switched to Efficiency, which I used during our video shoot to preserve energy, this electrified Audi moves quickly when prodded. There are also Allroad and Off-Road settings, but with just 6.9 inches of ground clearance, I don’t recommend traveling too far beyond the pavement.
While the Audi e-tron is satisfying on freeways and in both cities and suburbs, it has no trouble bombing down a canyon road with smooth pavement. Undulations can throw the SUV off of its game as the suspension struggles to manage the e-tron’s 5,754 pounds, much of it battery and motor weight located low in the vehicle.
For the most part, the regenerative brakes work well, but occasional grabby stops will irritate the driver and passengers. You can use paddle shifters to increase and decrease the amount of regeneration while coasting, but the e-tron does not offer one-pedal driving—a notable omission.
As far as electricity consumption is concerned, the tested e-tron’s burn rate was slightly higher than EPA expectations of 46 kWh/100 miles.
Our testing day was sunny with temperatures in the 50s. I left home with an indicated 148 miles of range, and after 56.1 miles of driving in Auto mode at an average speed of 33 mph, the trip computer said the SUV had 83 miles of range left—65 fewer than the initial range prediction. During the test, I averaged two miles of driving for every kilowatt-hour of electricity consumed, or 50 kWh/100 miles.
My testing loop is mountainous, with about 1,200 feet of elevation change. I did use Dynamic and Sport modes at times, and I did not use Efficiency mode. I tried to remember to increase regeneration levels whenever coasting, especially down a hill. I have no doubt that an e-tron driver paying close attention to range maximization can extract greater efficiency from this Audi than I did.