Porsche 911 vs Ferrari 458 Italia Compare price, expert/user reviews, mpg, engines, safety, cargo capacity and other specs at a glance.

Select a car to compare

Cancel
Change

Select a car to compare

Cancel
Change

Select a car to compare

Cancel
+

Used Car Pricing Used listing price comparison and analysis.

2020 Porsche 911
Carrera 4S Cabriolet AWD
CarGurus Instant Market Value
$157,475
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
Coupe RWD
CarGurus Instant Market Value
$212,249
6 listings nationwide

Shop

Expert Reviews Reviews from CarGurus experts.

2020 Porsche 911
Carrera 4S Cabriolet AWD
Andrew Newton Preview:

The highly anticipated eighth-generation version of the Porsche 911, known as the 992, debuts for 2020. The 911, available as a coupe or a cabriolet, comes in rear-wheel drive (RWD) Ca...

2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
Coupe RWD
John Goreham Preview:

How would you imagine your dream Ferrari to be laid out? If a 2-seat, mid/rear-engine platform with a high-revving V8 engine is your fantasy, the 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia is your car. I...

User Reviews Reviews from CarGurus users who have driven or owned the car.

2020 Porsche 911
Carrera 4S Cabriolet AWD
No User Reviews
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
Coupe RWD
writes:
Power Ranked 2018 Lamborghini Huracan LP 640-4 Performante Spyder Convertible AWD better.
"sport mode to sport mode driving comparison will be best way to evaluate this."
Handling Ranked 2018 Lamborghini Huracan LP 640-4 Performante Spyder Convertible AWD better.
"AWD vs RWD as well as steering options"
Looks/Style Ranked 2018 Lamborghini Huracan LP 640-4 Performante Spyder Convertible AWD better.
"Subjective as to what appeals most to each individual....Performante more aggressive, 458(488) more subtle."
Front Seats Ranked 2018 Lamborghini Huracan LP 640-4 Performante Spyder Convertible AWD better.
"Much more comfortable (with comfort seat option) and better looking"
Back Seats Ranked 2018 Lamborghini Huracan LP 640-4 Performante Spyder Convertible AWD better.
"this is a N/a...no back seat"
Cargo Capacity Ranked 2018 Lamborghini Huracan LP 640-4 Performante Spyder Convertible AWD worse.
"This is an N/A....neither car can hold much."
Family Car Ranked 2018 Lamborghini Huracan LP 640-4 Performante Spyder Convertible AWD better.
"This is an N/A...not a family car"
Value Ranked 2018 Lamborghini Huracan LP 640-4 Performante Spyder Convertible AWD better.
"more options and features for the same price point as a 458 (488)."
Would Buy Ranked 2018 Lamborghini Huracan LP 640-4 Performante Spyder Convertible AWD better.
"Everything about the car surpasses the 458 except the nameplate...."
writes:
Looks/Style Ranked 2008 Scion xB 5-Door better.
"big man dont ask questions or ill bang u out"
Cargo Capacity Ranked 2008 Scion xB 5-Door better.
"literally a box"

Specs

2020 Porsche 911
Carrera 4S Cabriolet AWD
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
Coupe RWD
Powertrain 8-Speed Dual Clutch 7-Speed Automatic
Drivetrain
AWD
RWD
Fuel Economy, City
--
13 MPG
Fuel Economy, Highway
--
17 MPG
Fuel Tank Volume 17.6 gal 22.7 gal
Engine
Fuel Type
Gasoline
Gasoline
Power
443 hp @ 6,500 RPM
562 hp @ 9,000 RPM
Torque
390 lb-ft @ 2,300 RPM
398 lb-ft @ 6,000 RPM
Cylinders
6 cylinders
8 cylinders
Compression Ratio
10.2:1
12.5:1
Displacement
3,000 cc
4,500 cc
Bore x Stroke
3.58 in x 3.01 in
3.7 in x 3.18 in
Safety
ABS Brakes Standard Standard
Driver Airbag Standard Standard
Passenger Airbag Standard Standard
Front Side Airbags -- Standard
Curtain Airbags Standard --
Comfort and Convenience
Leather Seats -- Standard
Air Conditioning Standard Standard
CD Player Standard Standard
CD Changer -- Standard
Radio Standard Standard
Power Windows Standard Standard
Power Door Locks Standard Standard
Driver Power Seats Standard --
Passenger Power Seats Standard Standard
Interior
Maximum Seating 4 seats 2 seats
Front Legroom -- 45 in
Back Legroom -- --
Payload and Towing
Cargo Volume 4.6 cu ft 8 cu ft
Maximum Payload 912 lbs --
Exterior
Length 177.9 in 178.2 in
Width 79.7 in 76.3 in
Height 51.2 in 47.8 in
Wheelbase 96.5 in 104.3 in

Available Options

2020 Porsche 911
Carrera 4S Cabriolet AWD

Exterior Colors

  • Agate Grey Metallic
  • Aventurine Green Metallic
  • Black
  • Carmine Red
  • Carrara White Metallic
  • Chalk
  • Custom Color
  • Dolomite Silver Metallic
  • GT Silver Metallic
  • Gentian Blue Metallic
  • Guards Red
  • Jet Black Metallic
  • Lava Orange
  • Lizard Green
  • Miami Blue
  • Night Blue Metallic
  • Racing Yellow
  • White

Option Packages

  • Bose Surround Sound System
  • Porsche Active Suspension Management (PASM)
  • Illuminated Door-Sill Guards in Brushed Aluminum
  • Illuminated Door-Sill Guards in Carbon Fiber
  • SportDesign Side Skirts
  • Seat Belts in Bordeaux Red
  • Seat Belts in Chalk
  • Interior Trim in Carbon Fiber
  • Adaptive Cruise Control (Acc)
  • BURMESTER High-End Surround Sound-System
  • Brake Calipers In High Gloss Black
  • Comfort Access
  • Front & Rear PARKASSIST W/Surround View
  • Front Axle Lift System
  • Heated Multifunction GT Sport Steering Wheel
  • ILLUM. Personalized Door-Sill Guards In Carbon Fiber
  • Illuminated Personalized Door-Sill Guards
  • Interior Trim In Brushed Aluminum
  • Interior Trim In Leather
  • Interior Trim In Light Silver DIAMAR
  • Interior Trim In PALDAO
  • Interior Trim Painted In Exterior Color
  • Lane Change Assist (LCA)
  • Lane Keep Assist (LKA) W/Traffic Sign Recognition
  • Led-Matrix Headlights
  • Light Design Package
  • Multifunction GT Sport Steering Wheel In Alcantara
  • Night Vision Assist
  • Porsche Ceramic Composite Brakes (PCCB)
  • Porsche Ceramic Composite Brakes (PCCB) In Black
  • Porsche Dynamic Chassis Control (PDCC)
  • Porsche Dynamic Light System Plus (PDLS+)
  • Premium Package
  • Protection Film - Front
  • Rear Axle Steering
  • Seat Belts In Agave Green
  • Seat Belts In Guards Red
  • Seat Belts In Lizard Green
  • Seat Belts In Racing Yellow
  • Seat Belts In Silver Grey
  • Seat Belts In Truffle Brown
  • Seat Ventilation
  • Sport CHRONO Package
  • Sport Exhaust System W/Tailpipes In Black
  • Sport Exhaust System W/Tailpipes In Silver
  • Sport Package
  • Sportdesign Front Fascia
  • Sportdesign Package
  • Vehicle Key In Leather W/Key Pouch
  • Vehicle Key Painted W/Key Pouch In Alcantara
  • Vehicle Keys Painted W/1 Key Pouch In Leather
  • Wheels Painted In Exterior Color
  • Wheels Painted In High Gloss Black
  • Wheels Painted In Jet Black Metallic
  • Wheels Painted In Satin Aurum
  • Wheels Painted In Satin Black
  • Wheels Painted In Satin Platinum
  • Agave Green, Club Leather Seat Trim
  • Agave Green, Club Leather Seat Trim W/Chalk Stitching
  • Black, LTHR Seat Trim W/Leather Interior & Chalk Stitching
  • Black, LTHR Seat Trim W/Sport-Tex Centers & Chalk Stitching
  • Black, Leather Seat Trim W/Leather Interior
  • Black, Leather Seat Trim W/Sport-Tex Centers
  • Bordeaux Red, LTHR Seat Trim W/Leather Interior & Chalk Stitching
  • Bordeaux Red, Leather Seat Trim W/Leather Interior
  • Bordeaux Red/Black, Leather Seat Trim W/Two-Tone Leather Interior
  • Chalk/Slate Grey, Leather Seat Trim W/Two-Tone Leather Interior
  • Graphite Blue, LTHR Seat Trim W/Leather Interior & Chalk Stitching
  • Graphite Blue, Leather Seat Trim W/Leather Interior
  • Island Green/Black, Leather Seat Trim W/Two-Tone Leather Interior
  • Mojave Beige/Black, Leather Seat Trim W/Two-Tone Leather Interior
  • Slate Grey, LTHR Seat Trim W/Leather Interior & Chalk Stitching
  • Slate Grey, Leather Seat Trim W/Leather Interior
  • Truffle Brown, Club Leather Seat Trim
  • Truffle Brown, Club Leather Seat Trim W/Chalk Stitching
  • 14-Way Power Sport Seats W/Memory Package
  • 18-Way Adaptive Sport Seats Plus W/Memory Package
  • HTD Multifunction GT Sport Steering WHL In Alcantara
  • Wheels: 20" Front/21" Rear CARRERA Classic
  • Wheels: 20" Front/21" Rear CARRERA Exclusive Design
  • Wheels: 20" Front/21" Rear RS SPYDER Design
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia
Coupe RWD

Exterior Colors

  • Argento Nurburgring Metallic
  • Avorio
  • Azzurro California
  • BLU Mirabeau Metallic
  • Bianco Avus
  • Blu Abu Dhabi Metallic
  • Blu Pozzi
  • Blu Scozia
  • Blu Swaters
  • Blu Tour de France Metallic
  • Canna Di Fucile
  • GRIGIO Ingrid Metallic
  • Giallo Modena
  • Grigio Alloy Metallic
  • Grigio Ferro
  • Grigio Scuro
  • Grigio Silverstone Metallic
  • Grigio Titanio Metallizzato Metallic
  • Nero Daytona Metallic
  • Nero PASTELLO
  • Rosso Corsa
  • Rosso Dino
  • Rosso Fiorano
  • Rosso Mugello
  • Rosso Scuderia
  • Verde British

Option Packages

  • ALUTEX Dashboard Trim
  • ALUTEX Door Sill Kick
  • ALUTEX Driver Zone W/LEDS
  • ALUTEX Interior Lower Zone
  • ALUTEX Steering Wheel W/LEDS
  • ALUTEX Tunnel Console
  • Advanced Front Lighting System (AFS)
  • Alcantara Upholstery For Headliner
  • Alcantara Upholstery For Upper Zone
  • Anti Stone Chipping Protection Film
  • Brake Calipers In Aluminum Gray Color
  • Brake Calipers In CORSA Red Color
  • Brake Calipers In Gloss Black Color
  • Brake Calipers In Modena Yellow Color
  • Brake Calipers In SCUDERIA Red Color
  • Brake Calipers In SILVERSTONE Gray Color
  • Carbon Fiber Center Wheel Caps
  • Carbon Fiber Dashboard Trim
  • Carbon Fiber Driving Zone W/Led Steering Wheel
  • Carbon Fiber Engine Compartment
  • Carbon Fiber Engine Manifold
  • Carbon Fiber Filter Box Cover
  • Carbon Fiber Front Wing Spoiler
  • Carbon Fiber In Lower Zone Of Cabin
  • Carbon Fiber Outer Sill Cover
  • Carbon Fiber Rear Bumper Molding
  • Carbon Fiber Rear Diffuser
  • Carbon Fiber Sport Package
  • Carbon Fiber Steering Wheel W/Led RPM Indicator
  • Carbon Fiber Upper Tunnel
  • Carbon Trim For Central Bridge
  • Color Upon Request For Alcantara Center Door Panel
  • Color Upon Request For Alcantara Door Pocket
  • Color Upon Request For Alcantara Lower Dashboard
  • Color Upon Request For Alcantara Upper Tunnel
  • Color Upon Request For Central Tunnel
  • Color Upon Request For Front Dashboard
  • Color Upon Request For Seat Piping
  • Color Upon Request For Upper Dashboard
  • Colored Seat Belts
  • Cruise Control
  • Daytona Inserts In Alcantara
  • Daytona Inserts In Leather
  • Diamond Pattern Leather Headliner
  • Driver & Front Passenger Electric Seats
  • Dual Color Leather Interior Trim
  • Dual Color Leather Interior Trim W/Daytona Seats
  • Electric Steering Column
  • Embroidered Prancing Horse On Headrest
  • Exterior Carbon Fiber Sill Kick
  • Front & Rear Radar Parking Distance Sensors
  • Front Ipod Connection
  • Front Suspension Lift System
  • Full Electric Seats
  • HELE (High Emotion Low Emission) System
  • Headliner Upholstered In Color Upon Request
  • Heat Insulating Windscreen
  • Hi-Fi Premium Sound System
  • Inner & Outer Electrochromatic Rearview Mirrors
  • Inner Electrochromatic Rearview Mirror W/Homelink
  • Interior Color For Upper Zone
  • Internal & External Electrochromatic Mirrors
  • Internal Electrochromatic Rearview Mirror
  • Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior W/Daytona Seats
  • Leather Lower Zone Upholstery
  • Leather Upholstery For Rear Shelf
  • Luggage Compartment Carpets In Alcantara
  • Luggage Set For Rear Bench
  • Luggage Set For Trunk
  • Passenger Compartment Mats In Alcantara
  • Rear Parking Camera
  • Rear Radar Parking Distance Sensors
  • Run-Flat Tires
  • SCUDERIA Ferrari Shields On Fenders
  • Silver Dedication Plate
  • Smokers Kit
  • Space Saver 20" Wheel Kit
  • Sport Exhaust Pipes
  • Sports Sill Cover
  • Suit Holder
  • Two-Tone Exterior Paint
  • White Tachometer Display
  • BLU MEDIO, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • BLU SCURO, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • Beige, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • Bordeaux, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • CARTA DA ZUCCHERO, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • CIOCCOLATO, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • CREMA, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • CUOIO, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • Charcoal, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • GRIGIO SCURO, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • IROKO, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • Nero, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • Rosso, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • SABBIA, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • Terra BRUCIATA, Leather & Alcantara Two-Color Interior
  • Carbon Fiber Racing Style Seats
  • Diamond Style Stitching On Front Seats
  • Front & Rear Daytona Style Seat Trim
  • Wheels: Front 20" X 8.5"/Rear 20" X 10.5" Dark Gray Painted Forged Alloy
  • Wheels: Front 20" X 8.5"/Rear 20" X 10.5" Diamond Finish Forged Alloy
  • Wheels: Front 20" X 8.5"/Rear 20" X 10.5" Shadow Chrome Alloy
  • Wheels: Front 20" X 8.5"/Rear 20" X 10.5" Silver Forged Alloy

Related Comparisons