Used Convertibles for Sale Under $40,000 in Fillmore, IN

63 results

Sort by:

2021 BMW 4 Series

430i Convertible RWD

42,694 miles

$32,400

Year:: 2021
Make:: BMW
Model:: 4 Series
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 255 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Black Sapphire Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 28 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Mocha W/Contrast Stitch
Transmission:: 8-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 42,694
Stock #:: STKG97337
VIN:: WBA23AT02MCG97337

Sponsored by Unlimited Motors - Westfield

2021 BMW 4 Series

430i Convertible RWD

30,256 miles

$36,750

Year:: 2021
Make:: BMW
Model:: 4 Series
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 255 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Blue Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 28 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black W/Oyster Stitching
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 30,256
Stock #:: STKG17555
VIN:: WBA23AT08MCG17555

2021 Mercedes-Benz C-Class

C 300 Cabriolet 4MATIC

41,746 miles

$34,990

Year:: 2021
Make:: Mercedes-Benz
Model:: C-Class
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 255 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Iridium Silver Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 26 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: 9-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 41,746
Stock #:: STK100115
VIN:: W1KWK8EB0MG100115

2025 Mazda MX-5 Miata

RF Club RWD

4,826 miles

$37,322

Year:: 2025
Make:: Mazda
Model:: MX-5 Miata
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 181 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Deep Crystal Blue Mica
Combined gas mileage:: 30 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: 6-Speed Manual
Mileage:: 4,826
Stock #:: M25759A
VIN:: JM1NDAL71S0656316

2021 Ford Mustang

EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD

86,783 miles

$18,490

Year:: 2021
Make:: Ford
Model:: Mustang
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 310 hp 2.3L I4
Exterior color:: Oxford White
Combined gas mileage:: 24 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black (Ebony)
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 86,783
Stock #:: MM13193B
VIN:: 1FATP8UH2M5100347

2023 Ford Mustang

EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD

42,158 miles

$24,256

Year:: 2023
Make:: Ford
Model:: Mustang
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 310 hp 2.3L I4
Exterior color:: Dark Matter Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 24 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black (Ebony)
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 42,158
Stock #:: P13950
VIN:: 1FATP8UH5P5103991

2021 Chevrolet Camaro

2LT Convertible RWD

33,845 miles

$31,592

Year:: 2021
Make:: Chevrolet
Model:: Camaro
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 335 hp 3.6L V6
Exterior color:: Blue Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 23 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Jet Black
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 33,845
Stock #:: Z6485
VIN:: 1G1FD3DS0M0111500

2021 BMW 4 Series

M440i Convertible RWD

66,553 miles

$35,550

Year:: 2021
Make:: BMW
Model:: 4 Series
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 382 hp 3L I6
Exterior color:: Dravit Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 27 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black W/Oyster Stitching
Transmission:: 8-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 66,553
Stock #:: WJ7073
VIN:: WBA53AT01MCH17073

2024 Ford Mustang

EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD

38,324 miles

$30,951

Fair Deal

$585/mo est.

Manufacturer certified

Plainfield, IN

21 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Ford
Model:: Mustang
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 315 hp 2.3L I4
Exterior color:: Race Red
Combined gas mileage:: 27 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black Onyx
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 38,324
Stock #:: F4685
VIN:: 1FAGP8UH4R5124576

2021 Ford Mustang

GT Premium Convertible RWD

30,929 miles

$33,994

Year:: 2021
Make:: Ford
Model:: Mustang
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 460 hp 5L V8
Exterior color:: Shadow Black
Combined gas mileage:: 19 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black (Ebony)
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 30,929
Stock #:: K140714
VIN:: 1FATP8FF0M5140714

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2020 Chevrolet Camaro

2LT Convertible RWD

41,950 miles

$26,673

Year:: 2020
Make:: Chevrolet
Model:: Camaro
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 335 hp 3.6L V6
Exterior color:: Red Hot
Combined gas mileage:: 24 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Jet Black
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 41,950
Stock #:: I2N147000
VIN:: 1G1FD3DS8L0147000

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2022 Ford Mustang

EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD

42,145 miles

$23,200

Year:: 2022
Make:: Ford
Model:: Mustang
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 310 hp 2.3L I4
Exterior color:: Oxford White
Combined gas mileage:: 24 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black (Ebony)
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 42,145
Stock #:: KB1318B
VIN:: 1FATP8UH4N5103493

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2023 MINI Cooper

John Cooper Works Convertible FWD

7,781 miles

$33,990

Great Deal

$647/mo est.

Manufacturer certified

Indianapolis, IN

38 mi away

Year:: 2023
Make:: MINI
Model:: Cooper
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 228 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Chili Red
Combined gas mileage:: 28 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Carbon Black
Transmission:: 8-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 7,781
Stock #:: MC4576P
VIN:: WMW63DL0XP3P58972

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 BMW 4 Series

430i Convertible RWD

30,256 miles

$36,750

Year:: 2021
Make:: BMW
Model:: 4 Series
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 255 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Blue Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 28 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black W/Oyster Stitching
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 30,256
Stock #:: STKG17555
VIN:: WBA23AT08MCG17555

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2022 MINI Cooper

John Cooper Works Convertible FWD

27,587 miles

$29,400

Year:: 2022
Make:: MINI
Model:: Cooper
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 228 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Chili Red
Combined gas mileage:: 28 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Carbon Black
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 27,587
Stock #:: STKN49560
VIN:: WMW63DL09N3N49560

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2020 Mercedes-Benz E-Class

E 450 Cabriolet RWD

45,468 miles

$39,920

Year:: 2020
Make:: Mercedes-Benz
Model:: E-Class
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 362 hp 3L V6
Exterior color:: Black
Combined gas mileage:: 23 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black/Classic Red
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 45,468
Stock #:: STK136012
VIN:: W1K1K6HB7LF136012

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 BMW 4 Series

430i Convertible RWD

42,694 miles

$32,400

Year:: 2021
Make:: BMW
Model:: 4 Series
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 255 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Black Sapphire Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 28 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Mocha W/Contrast Stitch
Transmission:: 8-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 42,694
Stock #:: STKG97337
VIN:: WBA23AT02MCG97337

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2020 BMW Z4

43,497 miles

$31,990

Year:: 2020
Make:: BMW
Model:: Z4
Body type:: Convertible
Engine:: 255 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Alpine White
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Cognac
Transmission:: 8-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 43,497
Stock #:: STKW68451
VIN:: WBAHF3C0XLWW68451

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 Jaguar F-TYPE

P300 Convertible RWD

53,534 miles

$33,355

Year:: 2021
Make:: Jaguar
Model:: F-TYPE
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 296 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Ligurian Black Gloss
Combined gas mileage:: 26 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black (Ebony/Light Oyster Stitch)
Transmission:: 8-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 53,534
Stock #:: NJ1290B2
VIN:: SAJDD5GX3MCK70402

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2026 MINI Cooper

S Convertible FWD

2,153 miles

$39,995

Great Deal

$747/mo est.

Manufacturer certified

Indianapolis, IN

38 mi away

Year:: 2026
Make:: MINI
Model:: Cooper
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 2L I4
Exterior color:: Chili Red
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Gray (Grey/Blue)
Transmission:: 7-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 2,153
Stock #:: M13122
VIN:: WMW23GX08T2X69012

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2022 Chevrolet Camaro

LT1 Convertible RWD

13,971 miles

$37,499

Year:: 2022
Make:: Chevrolet
Model:: Camaro
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 455 hp 6.2L V8
Exterior color:: Wild Cherry Tintcoat
Combined gas mileage:: 21 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Jet Black
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 13,971
Stock #:: GZ2226
VIN:: 1G1FF3D74N0101818

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2026 MINI Cooper

S Convertible FWD

2,671 miles

$39,995

Great Deal

$747/mo est.

Manufacturer certified

Indianapolis, IN

38 mi away

Year:: 2026
Make:: MINI
Model:: Cooper
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 2L I4
Exterior color:: Chili Red
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Brown (Beige)
Transmission:: 7-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 2,671
Stock #:: M13121
VIN:: WMW23GX01T2X69613

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 Mercedes-Benz C-Class

C 300 Cabriolet 4MATIC

41,746 miles

$34,990

Year:: 2021
Make:: Mercedes-Benz
Model:: C-Class
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 255 hp 2L I4
Exterior color:: Iridium Silver Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 26 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: 9-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 41,746
Stock #:: STK100115
VIN:: W1KWK8EB0MG100115

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2020 Chevrolet Camaro

LT1 Convertible RWD

94,733 miles

$25,980

Year:: 2020
Make:: Chevrolet
Model:: Camaro
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 455 hp 6.2L V8
Exterior color:: Black
Combined gas mileage:: 21 MPG
Fuel type:: Gasoline
Interior color:: Jet Black
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 94,733
Stock #:: B12100B
VIN:: 1G1FF3D78L0116061

A better way to discover your best deal

Let us help you find a car you’ll love.

Used Convertibles for Sale Under $40,000 in Fillmore, IN

2021 BMW 4 Series

$32,400

2021 BMW 4 Series

$36,750

2021 Mercedes-Benz C-Class

$34,990

2025 Mazda MX-5 Miata

$37,322

2021 Ford Mustang

$18,490

2023 Ford Mustang

$24,256

2021 Chevrolet Camaro

$31,592

2021 BMW 4 Series

$35,550

2024 Ford Mustang

$30,951

2021 Ford Mustang

$33,994

2020 Chevrolet Camaro

$26,673

2022 Ford Mustang

$23,200

2023 MINI Cooper

$33,990

2021 BMW 4 Series

$36,750

2022 MINI Cooper

$29,400

2020 Mercedes-Benz E-Class

$39,920

2021 BMW 4 Series

$32,400

2020 BMW Z4

$31,990

2021 Jaguar F-TYPE

$33,355

2026 MINI Cooper

$39,995

2022 Chevrolet Camaro

$37,499

2026 MINI Cooper

$39,995

2021 Mercedes-Benz C-Class

$34,990

2020 Chevrolet Camaro

$25,980

Broader Searches

Shop By City

Popular Searches

Used car dealers near Fillmore

A better way to discover your best deal