Used Ford Mustang for Sale nearEast Setauket, NY

Filters (2)

Location:

Only show listings in NY?

Include delivery listings?

1,203 vehicles found

Shop with transparent pricing.

Only show listings that include dealer fees
Year:
2011
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Convertible
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
412 hp 5L V8
Exterior color:
Black
Combined gas mileage:
21 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Charcoal Black
Transmission:
6-Speed Manual
Mileage:
69,104
Stock #:
4648
VIN:
1ZVBP8FF9B5163912
Black 2011 Ford Mustang Convertible Rear-Wheel Drive 6-Speed Manual
NY Auto Find

Sponsored by NY Auto Find

2011 Ford Mustang

GT Premium Convertible RWD

69,104 mi

Massapequa, NY
24 mi away
Fair Deal

$21,997

Year:
2024
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Coupe
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
480 hp 5L V8
Exterior color:
Race Red
Combined gas mileage:
20 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black Onyx
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
2,676
Stock #:
12002
VIN:
1FA6P8CF0R5409772
Race Red 2024 Ford Mustang Coupe Rear-Wheel Drive Automatic

Sponsored Listing

2024 Ford Mustang

GT Premium Fastback RWD

2,676 mi

Branford, CT
31 mi away
Great Deal

$45,982

Year:
2022
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Coupe
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
450 hp 5L V8
Exterior color:
Black
Combined gas mileage:
19 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
5,880
Stock #:
70153276
VIN:
1FA6P8CF2N5141401
Black 2022 Ford Mustang Coupe Rear-Wheel Drive Automatic
New arrival

 

2022 Ford Mustang

GT Fastback RWD

5,880 mi

Store transfer to East Haven, CT
Price includes $499 shipping
Fair Deal

$40,497

Year:
2024
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Coupe
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
315 hp 2.3L I4
Exterior color:
Shadow Black
Combined gas mileage:
27 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
65,310
Stock #:
2780C
VIN:
1FA6P8THXR5107665
Shadow Black 2024 Ford Mustang Coupe Rear-Wheel Drive Automatic
New arrival

 

2024 Ford Mustang

EcoBoost Premium Fastback RWD

65,310 mi

Levittown, NY
24 mi away
Great Deal

$23,524

Recommended model year:

2023 Ford Mustang

4.6

Shop 2023 Ford Mustang »
  • With 3,129 currently listed for sale and an average price of $33,194.00, 34.5% of 2023 Ford Mustangs for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.

  • Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2023 Ford Mustang 5 / 5 stars.

  • 88.1% of 2023 Mustang models on CarGurus are accident free.

Research summarized using AI

Year:
2023
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Convertible
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
310 hp 2.3L I4
Exterior color:
White
Combined gas mileage:
24 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
53,641
Stock #:
U23213
VIN:
1FATP8UH3P5104511
White 2023 Ford Mustang Convertible Rear-Wheel Drive Automatic

 

2023 Ford Mustang

EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD

53,641 mi

Riverhead, NY
21 mi away
Good Deal

$21,990

Year:
2023
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Convertible
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
310 hp 2.3L I4
Exterior color:
White
Combined gas mileage:
24 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
35,703
Stock #:
28569616
VIN:
1FATP8UH5P5111606
White 2023 Ford Mustang Convertible Rear-Wheel Drive Automatic
New arrival

 

2023 Ford Mustang

EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD

35,703 mi

Store transfer to East Haven, CT
Price includes $1,599 shipping
Fair Deal

$26,597

Year:
2024
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Convertible
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
315 hp 2.3L I4
Exterior color:
Oxford White
Combined gas mileage:
27 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
48,422
Stock #:
MVPG1938118
VIN:
1FAGP8UH7R5737767
Oxford White 2024 Ford Mustang Convertible Rear-Wheel Drive Automatic

 

2024 Ford Mustang

EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD

48,422 mi

Valley Stream, NY
36 mi away
Great Deal

$21,390

Year:
2020
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Coupe
Engine:
460 hp 5L V8
Exterior color:
Gray
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Manual
Mileage:
88,600
Stock #:
182214
VIN:
1FA6P8CF3L5182214
Gray 2020 Ford Mustang Coupe  Manual
New arrival

 

2020 Ford Mustang

88,600 mi

Home delivery from Benton, MO
Price includes $1,377 shipping
Fair Deal

$27,577

Year:
2019
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Convertible
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
460 hp 5L V8
Exterior color:
Shadow Black
Combined gas mileage:
19 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black (Ebony W/Metal Gray Stitch)
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
76,646
Stock #:
22773
VIN:
1FATP8FF1K5138581
Shadow Black 2019 Ford Mustang Convertible Rear-Wheel Drive Automatic

 

2019 Ford Mustang

GT Premium Convertible RWD

76,646 mi

Home delivery from Tampa, FL
Price includes $1,088 shipping
Good Deal

$26,080

Year:
2023
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Convertible
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
310 hp 2.3L I4
Exterior color:
Shadow Black
Combined gas mileage:
24 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
58,800
VIN:
1FATP8UH3P5111650
Shadow Black 2023 Ford Mustang Convertible Rear-Wheel Drive Automatic
Price drop

-$500

 

2023 Ford Mustang

EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD

58,800 mi

Middle Village, NY
44 mi away
Great Deal

$19,670

$19,170

Year:
2016
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Coupe
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
435 hp 5L V8
Exterior color:
Shadow Black
Combined gas mileage:
20 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black (Ebony)
Transmission:
Manual
Mileage:
74,538
Stock #:
201317S
VIN:
1FA6P8CF3G5201317
Shadow Black 2016 Ford Mustang Coupe Rear-Wheel Drive Manual

 

2016 Ford Mustang

GT Coupe RWD

74,538 mi

Home delivery from Lighthouse Point, FL
Free home delivery
Good Deal

$25,590

Year:
2020
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Coupe
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
460 hp 5L V8
Exterior color:
Black
Combined gas mileage:
20 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
42,316
Stock #:
70154174
VIN:
1FA6P8CF0L5101007
Black 2020 Ford Mustang Coupe Rear-Wheel Drive Automatic

 

2020 Ford Mustang

GT Coupe RWD

42,316 mi

Store transfer to East Haven, CT
Price includes $1,099 shipping
Fair Deal

$34,097

Year:
2014
Make:
Ford
Model:
Mustang
Body type:
Convertible
Doors:
2 doors
Drivetrain:
Rear-Wheel Drive
Engine:
420 hp 5L V8
Exterior color:
Sterling Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
21 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
6-Speed Automatic
Mileage:
100,238
Stock #:
234778W
VIN:
1ZVBP8FF8E5234778
Sterling Gray Metallic 2014 Ford Mustang Convertible Rear-Wheel Drive 6-Speed Automatic
New arrival

Sponsored Listing

2014 Ford Mustang

GT Premium Convertible RWD

100,238 mi

Naugatuck, CT
40 mi away
Fair Deal

$18,985

How much does the Ford Mustang cost in today's market?

Used Ford Mustang prices span a wide range depending on model year. Here's what the market looks like right now:

Model YearCurrent Avg. PriceYear-Round Range
2025$43,173$42,765 – $47,861
2024$38,020$35,899 – $40,150
2023$33,307$28,726 – $33,779
2022$34,194$30,465 – $34,640
2021$31,460$28,516 – $32,006
2020$27,032$25,012 – $28,000
2019$27,174$24,386 – $28,123
2018$22,181$21,233 – $23,781
2017$21,828$20,068 – $22,435
2016$19,761$18,412 – $20,602
2015$20,453$18,600 – $20,759
2014$15,854$14,281 – $15,953

The Ford Mustang's current nationwide average price is $29,004, and its year-round low is $25,612.37. That puts the model's current pricing in a fairly broad band across generations, with newer examples commanding the highest averages and older ones sitting much lower. Recently, prices have come down for the 2024 and 2025 models, making now a good time to shop recent model years.

Is the Ford Mustang a good car?

Yes — the Ford Mustang earns strong marks from owners across the lineup, and its appeal is anchored by a 4.62/5 all-generations user rating. The all-generations owner rating is 4.62/5 across every model year in the data.

Owners consistently praise the Mustang's powerful performance, fun driving experience, and iconic styling. Across the years, the recurring themes are strong acceleration, engaging handling, and the emotional appeal of the V8 sound and character.

Expert reviews rate the 2018 and 2021 models among the highest across all years.

The main tradeoffs that show up in recent expert reviews are cramped rear seating, limited cargo space, and a noisy cabin, especially in performance-focused versions.

28.3% of listings are priced as good or great deals.

Are Ford Mustang models reliable?

Owners and experts consistently praise the Mustang for its performance, driving enjoyment, and styling, and those strengths show up repeatedly across the model years in the data. The car's broad range of engines and trims also gives you plenty of ways to choose a version that fits your priorities.

  • Owners rate the Ford Mustang between 4.42 and 5.0 out of 5 stars across all model years in the data.

For used buyers, long-term ownership risk depends heavily on model year and maintenance history, so a well-documented example is the safest path.

What should I look for when buying a used Ford Mustang?

Across all model years, accident-free inventory is solid at 75.5% — always verify the vehicle history report.

Model YearAccident-Free %
202693.6%
202592%
202490.9%
202387.8%
202279.1%
202173.7%
202068.9%
201964%
201860.7%
201756.3%
201657.1%
201558.6%
201461.3%

Older model years carry meaningfully higher accident rates, so always verify the vehicle history report on pre-2022 models.

Key things to evaluate:

  • Safety package: Standard safety features for all Mustangs include frontal collision warning with automatic emergency braking, lane-keep assist, a blind-spot monitor with rear cross-traffic alert, rear parking sensors, rain-sensing wipers, and automatic high beams.
  • Infotainment: All 2024 Mustangs come with a large 13.2-inch infotainment touchscreen and a digital instrument cluster, with Sync 4 infotainment, Apple CarPlay, Android Auto, and Amazon Alexa integration.
  • Fuel efficiency: The EPA estimates the four-cylinder EcoBoost will return 22 mpg city, 33 mpg highway, and 26 mpg in combined driving. The V8-powered GT is rated at 15/24 mpg city/highway and 18 mpg combined with the automatic transmission.

Which Ford Mustang trim should I buy?

The 2024 Ford Mustang offers...

  • EcoBoost: The EcoBoost starts at $32,515 and gives you the turbocharged 2.3-liter engine, the 13.2-inch touchscreen, and the updated cabin design; it is the best-value trim if you want the Mustang experience at the lowest starting price.
  • GT: The GT starts at $44,090 and adds the 5.0-liter V8, six-speed manual, and stronger muscle-car character for buyers who want the classic V8 formula.
  • GT Convertible: The GT Convertible is available only in Premium trim and starts at $54,110, adding open-air driving to the V8 setup for shoppers who want the most premium version in the lineup.

What Ford Mustang do most buyers choose?

The Ford Mustang years with the most listings are 2024, 2025, and 2023.

Model YearTotal ListingsGood + Great Deals %
20243,72933.1%
20253,66333.3%
20233,22433.3%
20202,22629.8%
20192,06729.5%
20182,05229.9%

These higher-volume model years tend to be the most popular used picks because they combine broad availability with strong deal percentages. That gives you more inventory to compare while still keeping a healthy share of listings priced as good or great deals.

What is the Ford Mustang's resale value?

Model YearCurrent Avg. PriceYear-Over-Year Change
2025$43,173−9.82%
2024$38,020−5.3%
2018$22,181−5.25%
2016$19,761−4.07%
2019$27,174−3.24%
2020$27,032−3.15%
2017$21,828−2.17%
2021$31,460−1.66%
2015$20,453−0.18%
2022$34,194+1.6%
2014$15,854+2.65%
2023$33,307+9.49%

Most Mustang model years in the table are moving lower year over year, which creates better entry points for used buyers. A few years are still rising, so the market is not moving in one direction across the board. The sharpest declines are concentrated in the newer and mid-cycle examples, while some older and recent years are holding firmer.

The 2015 model year is holding steady, with prices close to flat year-over-year.

The 2023, 2014, and 2022 model years have held their value best, with prices flat to rising year-over-year.

Is the Ford Mustang safe?

  • 2024: 6/10
  • 2021: 9/10
  • 2020: 7/10
  • 2018: 8/10
  • 2016: 9/10
  • 2015: 9/10
  • 2014: 6/10

Standard safety features for all Mustangs include frontal collision warning with automatic emergency braking, lane-keep assist, a blind-spot monitor with rear cross-traffic alert, rear parking sensors, rain-sensing wipers, and automatic high beams.

For the safest used buy, the 2015, 2016 and 2021 models all post the highest confirmed score of 9/10.

Should I buy a used Ford Mustang now or wait for the next model?

Buy now if:

  • Price trend: The 2025 model is at −9.82% versus a year ago, and the 2024 model is at −5.3%.
  • Deal availability: The 2025 model has 33.3% good and great deals, and the 2024 model has 33.1%.
  • Sweet-spot year: The 2024 model has the most listings at a current average price of $38,020. The Ford Mustang offers iconic styling and a classic rear-wheel-drive performance character that has made it a long-running favorite.

Consider waiting if:

  • Powertrain/efficiency: The 2024 Mustang's entry-level engine is the EcoBoost 2.3-liter turbocharged four-cylinder that produces 315 horsepower and 350 pound-feet of torque.
  • Tech: All 2024 Mustangs come with a large 13.2-inch infotainment touchscreen and a digital instrument cluster.
  • Safety: Standard safety features for all Mustangs include frontal collision warning with automatic emergency braking, lane-keep assist, a blind-spot monitor with rear cross-traffic alert, rear parking sensors, rain-sensing wipers, and automatic high beams.
  • Starting price: The base 2024 Ford Mustang EcoBoost has a starting price of $32,515 (including $1,595 in destination fees).

If you're buying used today, the 2024 model year offers the best mix of value and availability. If you want the latest tech and features, it may be worth waiting for 2027 inventory to mature.

These recommendations are based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from August 21, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.

*CarGurus meticulously monitors the prices of millions of pre-owned vehicle listings, offering users precise and up-to-date market insights. Historical pricing data excludes any additional dealer fees as of May 3, 2026.

A better way to discover your best deal

Let us help you find a car you’ll love.