Used 2017 Ford Mustang for Sale nearPittsburgh, PA
Shop with transparent pricing.
Only show listings that include dealer fees- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- White
- Combined gas mileage:
- 26 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 108,712
- Stock #:
- 37P0214A
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8TH3G5281493

2016 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Premium Coupe RWD
108,712 mi
$14,860
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 460 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Gray
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Brown (Beige/Black)
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 109,935
- Stock #:
- 120391
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CF5J5120391

2018 Ford Mustang
GT Coupe RWD
109,935 mi
$24,320
- Year:
- 2017
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 435 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Red
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Transmission:
- 6-Speed Manual
- Mileage:
- 61,985
- Stock #:
- 339080
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CF6H5339080

2017 Ford Mustang
GT Premium Coupe RWD
61,985 mi
$32,217
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Convertible
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- Gray
- Combined gas mileage:
- 24 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 94,775
- Stock #:
- 124165
- VIN:
- 1FATP8UH1J5124165

2018 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD
94,775 mi
$17,654
- Year:
- 2017
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 435 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Shadow Black
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- 6-Speed Manual
- Mileage:
- 78,674
- Stock #:
- R0778A
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CF3H5240684

2017 Ford Mustang
GT Premium Coupe RWD
78,674 mi
$29,145
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 435 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Black
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 81,007
- Stock #:
- CVLC04960
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CFXG5204960

2016 Ford Mustang
GT Coupe RWD
81,007 mi
$24,242
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Convertible
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- White
- Combined gas mileage:
- 24 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 54,508
- Stock #:
- 22112
- VIN:
- 1FATP8UH9G5222112

2016 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD
54,508 mi
$15,756
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 460 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Blue,Dark
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Manual
- Mileage:
- 66,769
- Stock #:
- 4657
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CF5J5120472

2018 Ford Mustang
GT Coupe RWD
66,769 mi
$29,936
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 460 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Black
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Mileage:
- 86,467
- Stock #:
- EAC2963
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CF5J5120486

2018 Ford Mustang
GT Coupe RWD
86,467 mi
$27,759
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Convertible
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 300 hp 3.7L V6
- Exterior color:
- Yellow
- Combined gas mileage:
- 23 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- 6-Speed Automatic
- Mileage:
- 90,311
- Stock #:
- 4087
- VIN:
- 1FATP8EM5G5281234

2016 Ford Mustang
V6 Convertible RWD
90,311 mi
$16,880
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- Red (Burgundy)
- Combined gas mileage:
- 26 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 72,780
- Stock #:
- MAS-102266
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8TH9J5102266

2018 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Premium Coupe RWD
72,780 mi
$18,388
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 435 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Shadow Black
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- Manual
- Mileage:
- 68,130
- Stock #:
- 10332A
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CFXG5236369

2016 Ford Mustang
GT Premium Coupe RWD
68,130 mi
$27,275
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- Ingot Silver
- Combined gas mileage:
- 26 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- 6-Speed Automatic
- Mileage:
- 128,558
- Stock #:
- LT1029
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8TH5G5221988

2016 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Premium Coupe RWD
128,558 mi
$12,297
CarGurus Analysis:
2017 Ford Mustang
With 242 currently listed for sale near Pittsburgh, PA and an average price of $14,498.00, 21.5% of 2017 Ford Mustangs for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2017 Ford Mustang 4.42 / 5 stars.
61.2% of 2017 Mustang models on CarGurus are accident free.
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- Oxford White
- Combined gas mileage:
- 26 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 61,002
- Stock #:
- 162950
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8TH3J5162950

2018 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Coupe RWD
61,002 mi
$20,264
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 460 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Triple Yellow Tri-Coat
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 48,634
- Stock #:
- 131976
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CF0J5131976

-$1,000
2018 Ford Mustang
GT Premium Coupe RWD
48,634 mi
$31,198
$30,198
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Convertible
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- Shadow Black
- Combined gas mileage:
- 24 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- 6-Speed Automatic
- Mileage:
- 89,547
- Stock #:
- M7001
- VIN:
- 1FATP8UH6G5257576

-$678
2016 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD
89,547 mi
$16,236
$15,558
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 435 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Gray
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Manual
- Mileage:
- 57,256
- Stock #:
- 73180
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CFXG5273180

2016 Ford Mustang
GT Premium Coupe RWD
57,256 mi
$29,937
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 435 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Shadow Black
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- Manual
- Mileage:
- 74,538
- Stock #:
- 201317S
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CF3G5201317

2016 Ford Mustang
GT Coupe RWD
74,538 mi
$25,590
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- Ruby Red Metallic Tinted Clearcoat
- Combined gas mileage:
- 26 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- 6-Speed Automatic
- Mileage:
- 73,228
- Stock #:
- G5336535P
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8TH6G5336535

2016 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Coupe RWD
73,228 mi
$17,296
- Year:
- 2016
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- Triple Yellow Tri-Coat
- Combined gas mileage:
- 26 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 73,701
- Stock #:
- 144471P
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8TH5G5265053

2016 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Coupe RWD
73,701 mi
$15,296
- Year:
- 2017
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 300 hp 3.7L V6
- Exterior color:
- Lightning Blue Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 22 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- 6-Speed Manual
- Mileage:
- 107,438
- Stock #:
- 11360
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8AM8H5259829

2017 Ford Mustang
V6 Coupe RWD
107,438 mi
$15,754
- Year:
- 2018
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 460 hp 5L V8
- Exterior color:
- Lightning Blue Metallic
- Combined gas mileage:
- 20 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black (Ebony)
- Transmission:
- Manual
- Mileage:
- 111,405
- Stock #:
- MZ260167A
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8CF2J5184632

2018 Ford Mustang
GT Premium Coupe RWD
111,405 mi
$24,433
- Year:
- 2017
- Make:
- Ford
- Model:
- Mustang
- Body type:
- Coupe
- Doors:
- 2 doors
- Drivetrain:
- Rear-Wheel Drive
- Engine:
- 310 hp 2.3L I4
- Exterior color:
- White
- Combined gas mileage:
- 25 MPG
- Fuel type:
- Gasoline
- Interior color:
- Black
- Transmission:
- Automatic
- Mileage:
- 74,304
- Stock #:
- GFN303954
- VIN:
- 1FA6P8TH2H5303954

2017 Ford Mustang
EcoBoost Coupe RWD
74,304 mi
$18,687
CarGurus Analysis: 2017 Ford Mustang
overall

Summary
With 242 currently listed for sale near Pittsburgh, PA and an average price of $14,498.00, 21.5% of 2017 Ford Mustangs for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2017 Ford Mustang 4.42 / 5 stars.
61.2% of 2017 Mustang models on CarGurus are accident free.
Why it stands out
The 2017 Ford Mustang stands out as a classic rear-wheel-drive pony car that still offers coupe and convertible body styles, giving buyers a familiar formula with broad appeal. It sits within the sixth generation, which was introduced for the 2015 model year and brought a sleeker, smoother design, a new independent rear suspension, and Ford’s EcoBoost engine lineup. That combination helps explain why the Mustang remains such a distinctive choice: it blends heritage, everyday usability, and a more modern chassis than earlier versions.
For 2017, the Mustang’s appeal comes from its range of engines and transmissions. The EcoBoost turbocharged 2.3-liter inline four-cylinder powers base Mustangs, while other available engines include a 3.7-liter V6, the 5.0-liter Coyote V8, and two versions of the 5.2-liter V8. Depending on the engine, buyers could choose from two six-speed manuals, six- and 10-speed automatics, and a seven-speed dual-clutch automatic. That breadth makes the car easy to tailor to different priorities, whether the goal is accessible performance or a more serious muscle-car experience.
There are also a few cautions to keep in mind. Models with the EcoBoost engine are known for problems with oil consumption and potential head gasket failure, and the transmission may be prone to slippage. Even so, the 2017 Mustang remains attractive because it delivers the Mustang formula in a relatively modern package, with strong performance potential and enough variety to suit a wide range of shoppers.
Other model years to consider
- Average price: $27,860.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 25.4%
- User rating: 4.73 / 5
- Total listings: 268
- Average price: $62,460.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 23.6%
- User rating: 5 / 5
- Total listings: 263
- Average price: $31,543.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 24.5%
- User rating: 4.71 / 5
- Total listings: 249
This analysis is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from August 25, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.
*CarGurus meticulously monitors the prices of millions of pre-owned vehicle listings, offering users precise and up-to-date market insights. Historical pricing data excludes any additional dealer fees as of May 3, 2026.
4.5 Overall rating
Filter by rating
William N
Reviewed a 2017 Ford Mustang on Jun 25, 2025
Car not worth 30k it worth 26500 just because it has the after market part doesn’t mean it has to be 30k
Josh M
Reviewed a 2017 Ford Mustang on Oct 9, 2025
Car had nice features and low mileage. The color and wheels weren't my favorite, but that's a personal preference. The price seemed a bit high (I see now they just increased it!), but a nice car overall.
Emilio C
Reviewed a 2017 Ford Mustang on Nov 26, 2025
The blower motor needs replacing. The check engine light was on. Felt like it was misfiring when you punch it. Last oil change sticker read last year. Afraid of deeper engine issues.
Brian S
Reviewed a 2017 Ford Mustang on Jul 18, 2023
Sounds great, handles very well. Very comfortable to drive. And oh the power.
2017 Ford Mustang Trims
| Trim type | MSRP |
|---|---|
| GT Premium Convertible RWD | $42,695 |
| V6 Coupe RWD | $25,185 |
| EcoBoost Premium Coupe RWD | $30,195 |
| EcoBoost Premium Convertible RWD | $35,695 |
| GT Coupe RWD | $33,195 |
| GT Premium Coupe RWD | $37,195 |
| EcoBoost Coupe RWD | $26,195 |
| V6 Convertible RWD | $30,685 |
*CarGurus meticulously monitors the prices of millions of pre-owned vehicle listings, offering users precise and up-to-date market insights. Historical pricing data excludes any additional dealer fees as of May 3, 2026.
2017 Ford Mustang Price Trends
CarGurus tracks the prices of millions of used car listings every year. See how the average price of 2017 Ford Mustang prices has changed over time.
See more price trends2017 Ford Mustang Pricing Analysis: Pittsburgh, PA Market Report
Pricing by Nearby Locations
Market Area: Pittsburgh, PA
Key Insights
- Lowest Prices in Boyers and Youngstown: Both cities offer the lowest average price at $16,589, indicating a potential oversupply or lower demand in these areas.
- Highest Prices in Greensburg and Johnstown: These cities have the highest average price at $29,491, suggesting stronger demand or limited inventory.
- Inventory Variation: The number of listings varies significantly, with Greensburg (248 listings) and Cumberland (249 listings) showing higher inventory, which may contribute to more stable pricing.
City-Level Pricing
| City | Total Listings | Avg Price |
|---|---|---|
| Greensburg, PA | 248 | $29,491 |
| Johnstown, PA | 231 | $29,491 |
| Altoona, PA | 226 | $29,491 |
| Cumberland, MD | 249 | $29,491 |
| Warren, PA | 220 | $27,080 |
| Akron, OH | 237 | $20,956 |
| Boyers, PA | 225 | $16,589 |
| Youngstown, OH | 240 | $16,589 |
Pricing Analysis by Model Year
Key Insights
- Significant Premium for New Models: The 2025 Ford Mustang is priced at $62,460, which is 95.8% above MSRP, indicating high demand for the latest model.
- Depreciation Trends: The 2019 model shows a notable price drop of +55.1% compared to its original MSRP, reflecting typical depreciation patterns for older vehicles.
- Best Value in Recent Models: The 2022 Ford Mustang is priced at $32,728, only +19.9% above its original MSRP, making it a strong candidate for buyers seeking value.
Model Year Pricing
| Model Year | Original MSRP | Avg Price | Price vs MSRP |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | $31,920 | $62,460 | +95.8% |
| 2024 | $30,920 | $44,287 | +43.2% |
| 2022 | $27,470 | $32,728 | +19.9% |
| 2021 | $27,205 | $31,021 | +14.0% |
| 2020 | $26,670 | $27,860 | +4.4% |
| 2019 | $26,395 | $40,995 | +55.1% |
| 2018 | $25,680 | $26,656 | +3.8% |
| 2016 | $24,145 | $26,447 | +9.5% |
| 2015 | $23,800 | $23,658 | -0.6% |
| 2014 | $22,510 | $26,977 | +19.7% |
These recommendations are based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from August 27, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.
*CarGurus meticulously monitors the prices of millions of pre-owned vehicle listings, offering users precise and up-to-date market insights. Historical pricing data excludes any additional dealer fees as of May 3, 2026.
How much does the 2017 Ford Mustang cost?
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Current Average Price | $21,633 |
| Year-Round Low | $20,065.15 |
| Year-Round High | $22,438.12 |
| Average Price a Year Ago | $22,266 |
| Change vs. Last Year | −2.84% |
Prices have softened 2.84% compared to this time last year, making it a favorable time to shop this model year.
There are 1,838 listings available, which suggests you have room to compare prices and condition.
If you find a listing below $20,065.15, that's toward the low end of the year-round range and worth acting on quickly.
Is the 2017 Ford Mustang a good car?
Generally — the 4.42/5 user rating points to strong owner satisfaction. Owners consistently praise the Mustang’s powerful performance, fun driving experience, and stylish design, and many also like the range of engine choices that lets you tailor the car to your priorities. The 2017 model also fits a familiar coupe-or-convertible formula, so you get a sporty package with broad appeal and everyday usability. With 26.9% of listings marked as good or great deals, you have a meaningful chance to find a competitive offer if you shop carefully.
Is the 2017 Ford Mustang reliable?
Owners rate it 4.42/5, a solid signal of long-term satisfaction.
The owner feedback also points to a car that many drivers enjoy living with over time, especially when it comes to performance and overall driving enjoyment. That said, reliability-minded shoppers should pay close attention to maintenance history and how the car has been used, since long-term ownership risk can rise quickly if prior care was inconsistent.
What should I look for when buying a used 2017 Ford Mustang?
At 57.1% accident-free, a meaningful share of listings has prior incidents — history verification is especially important.
You should run a vehicle history report before you commit, then prioritize a pre-purchase inspection from a trusted mechanic. Focus on body condition, signs of prior repair, and whether the car has been maintained consistently, since those details matter more when a sizable portion of the market has accident history.
Is now a good time to buy a used 2017 Ford Mustang?
This looks like a moderate, selective buyer’s market, so you can shop with some leverage if you stay disciplined.
- Deal availability: 26.9% of listings are priced as good or great deals.
- Inventory: There are 1,838 listings available.
- Price trend: Prices have softened 2.84% compared with last year.
- Clean inventory: 57.1% of listings are accident-free.
If you find a listing below $20,065.15, that's toward the low end of the year-round range and worth acting on quickly.
What is the 2017 Ford Mustang's resale value?
The current average of $21,633 sits slightly below last year's $22,266.
That softer pricing can help you buy more carefully now, but it also means future resale gains may be more limited unless you choose a well-kept example. A clean history, strong condition, and desirable configuration should matter more if you want to protect value later. Vehicles with solid owner satisfaction ratings, like this model year's 4.42/5, tend to retain buyer demand, which supports resale value over time.
Should I buy a 2017 Ford Mustang or consider a different year?
If you're weighing the 2017 against nearby model years, here's how to think about it:
Choose the 2017 if:
- 26.9% of listings are priced as good or great deals.
- At 57.1% accident-free, a meaningful share of listings has prior incidents — history verification is especially important.
- Price trend: Prices have softened 2.84% compared with last year.
- Owners rate it 4.42/5 — a solid satisfaction signal.
Consider the 2016 if:
- At $19,792, the 2016 costs less than the current year's $21,633 average.
- It blends heritage touches with fresh packages and a more special-feeling lineup.
Consider the 2018 if:
- At $22,439, the 2018 costs more than the current year's $21,633 average.
- It feels more polished and capable, with stronger performance and a more refined overall package.
The bottom line: If you want the best balance of price, owner satisfaction, and market availability, the 2017 is the primary path to consider. If your budget is tighter, the 2016 is the better secondary path because it undercuts the current-year average while still delivering the Mustang formula.
These recommendations are based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from August 28, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.
*CarGurus meticulously monitors the prices of millions of pre-owned vehicle listings, offering users precise and up-to-date market insights. Historical pricing data excludes any additional dealer fees as of May 3, 2026.
Relevant articles

The Best Cheap Fast Cars of 2026
You don’t need to spend a lot to get a fast car. Surprisingly, some of the more budget-friendly options also happen to provide the most enjoyable driving experiences. Here are our top new car picks.

The Best Track Cars of 2026
The best track day cars can handle a hard day of racing and then head back home to serve as a daily driver. Here are our picks for the very best track car choices in 2025.

The Best Vehicles for Road Trips in 2026
Planning a road trip? While any car can do the job, certain vehicles are simply better for an adventure. Check out our top 10 recommendations based on your specific needs.