Porsche 911 vs Porsche Cayman

Compare price, expert/user reviews, mpg, engines, safety, cargo capacity and other specs at a glance.

Select a car to compare

Select a car to compare

Select a car to compare

New Car Pricing

New listing price comparison and analysis.

2018 Porsche 911
Carrera
MSRP
$91,100
Invoice
N/A
Average Price Paid
$87,226
85 listings nationwide

Shop

2016 Porsche Cayman
Base
No Data Available
Incentives Find if there are incentives in your area. Enter your zip code
2018 Porsche 911
Carrera

Price Analysis

Fair Price : $89,838
Good Price : $86,747
Great Price : $84,980
2016 Porsche Cayman
Base
No Data Available

Used Car Pricing

Used listing price comparison and analysis.

Showing nationwide pricing. Enter your zip code to view local pricing.

Enter your ZIP code

2018 Porsche 911
Carrera
CarGurus Instant Market Value
$109,424
1 listings nationwide

Shop

2016 Porsche Cayman
Base
CarGurus Instant Market Value
$54,912
64 listings nationwide
4 GREAT deals
17 GOOD deals

Shop

Expert Reviews

Reviews from CarGurus experts.

2018 Porsche 911
Carrera
Nicole Wakelin Preview:

The Porsche 911 has been around for seven generations. Over the years, it has seen plenty of changes, including a continually evolving model lineup that ensures there’s a flavor of 911...

2016 Porsche Cayman
Base
John Goreham Preview:

2016 may be forever remembered as the year that Porsche went back to putting four-cylinder engines in its sports cars. According to reliable sources, the 2016 Porsche Cayman coupe will...

User Reviews and User Rankings

User Rankings by Category

Users ranked cars they drove/owned. Each ranking was based on 9 categories. Here is the summary of top rankings.

Winning categories:
    Winning categories:
      Based on rankings.
      2018 Porsche 911
      Carrera
      writes:
      Approximately equal power as M3 Porsche Handles much better More performance oriented
      Power Ranked 2018 BMW M3 Sedan RWD worse.
      "Little Lighter/25 more hp to crank "
      Handling Ranked 2018 BMW M3 Sedan RWD worse.
      "Because it does...it’s a coupe not a sedan "
      2016 Porsche Cayman
      Base
      20
      writes:
      el mejor deportivo motor central de porsche y puede que el mejor de Alemania también, su sucesor el 718 es me...

      Specs

      2018 Porsche 911
      Carrera
      2016 Porsche Cayman
      Base
      Powertrain
      Drivetrain
      RWD
      RWD
      RWD
      RWD
      Fuel Economy, City
      20 MPG
      22 MPG
      20 MPG
      22 MPG
      Fuel Economy, Highway
      29 MPG
      30 MPG
      30 MPG
      32 MPG
      Fuel Tank Volume 16.9 gal 16.9 gal
      Engine
      Fuel Type
      Gasoline
      Gasoline
      Gasoline
      Gasoline
      Power
      370 hp @ 6,500 RPM
      370 hp @ 6,500 RPM
      275 hp @ 7,400 RPM
      275 hp @ 7,400 RPM
      Torque
      331 lb-ft @ 1,700 RPM
      331 lb-ft @ 1,700 RPM
      213 lb-ft @ 4,500 RPM
      213 lb-ft @ 4,500 RPM
      Cylinders
      6 cylinders
      6 cylinders
      6 cylinders
      6 cylinders
      Compression Ratio
      10:1
      10:1
      12.5:1
      12.5:1
      Displacement
      3,000 cc
      3,000 cc
      2,700 cc
      2,700 cc
      Bore x Stroke
      3.58 in x 2.99 in
      3.58 in x 2.99 in
      3.5 in x 2.85 in
      3.5 in x 2.85 in
      Safety
      ABS Brakes Standard Standard
      Driver Airbag Standard Standard
      Passenger Airbag Standard Standard
      Front Side Airbags Standard Standard
      Curtain Airbags Standard Standard
      NHTSA Crash Test Results
      Comfort and Convenience
      Leather Seats -- Standard
      Air Conditioning Standard Standard
      CD Player Standard Standard
      Radio Standard Standard
      Power Windows Standard Standard
      Power Door Locks Standard Standard
      Driver Power Seats Standard Standard
      Passenger Power Seats Standard Standard
      Interior
      Maximum Seating 4 seats 2 seats
      Front Legroom 41.6 in --
      Back Legroom -- --
      Payload and Towing
      Cargo Volume 5.1 cu ft 15 cu ft
      Maximum Payload 980 lbs --
      Exterior
      Length 177.1 in 172.2 in
      Width 77.9 in 70.9 in
      Height 51 in 50.9 in
      Wheelbase 96.5 in 97.4 in

      Available Options

      2018 Porsche 911
      Carrera

      Exterior Colors

      • Agate Grey Metallic
      • Black
      • Carmine Red
      • Carrara White Metallic
      • Chalk
      • Custom Color
      • Custom Color Metallic
      • GT Silver Metallic
      • Graphite Blue Metallic
      • Guards Red
      • Jet Black Metallic
      • Lava Orange
      • Miami Blue
      • Night Blue Metallic
      • Racing Yellow
      • Rhodium Silver Metallic
      • Sapphire Blue Metallic
      • White

      Option Packages

      • Bose Surround Sound System
      • Burmester High-End Surround Sound System
      • Heated Multifunction Steering Wheel in Carbon Fiber
      • Light Design Package
      • Porsche Entry & Drive
      • Vehicle Key Painted and Key Pouch in Leather
      • Front Axle Lift System
      • Sport Exhaust System with Tailpipes in Silver
      • Sports Exhaust System with Tailpipes in Black
      • Door-Sill Guards in Carbon Fiber
      • Exterior Mirrors Lower Trim Painted in Black
      • Exterior Package Painted
      • Front Fascia Painted
      • High-Gloss Black Exterior Package
      • Illuminated Door-Sill Guards in Carbon Fiber
      • Illuminated Door-Sill Guards in Stainless Steel
      • LED Headlights in Black
      • LED Headlights with PDLS+
      • Lower Rear Fascia Painted
      • Personalized Door-Sill Guards in Carbon Fiber
      • Personalized Door-Sill Guards in Stainless Steel
      • Porsche Dynamic Light System (PDLS)
      • Porsche Logo and 911 Model Designation Painted
      • Porsche Logo and Model Designation Painted
      • Rear Lid Intake Grille Slats Painted
      • Side Mirror Lower Trim Painted
      • SportDesign Exterior Mirrors in Carbon Fiber
      • SportDesign Front Fascia
      • SportDesign Side Mirrors
      • Sports Tailpipes in Black
      • Sports Tailpipes in Silver
      • Tinted Taillights
      • Window Triangle Trims in Carbon Fiber
      • Instrument Dials in Bordeaux Red
      • Instrument Dials in Guards Red
      • Instrument Dials in Luxor Beige
      • Instrument Dials in Racing Yellow
      • Instrument Dials in White
      • Seat Belts in Bordeaux Red
      • Seat Belts in Chalk
      • Seat Belts in Guards Red
      • Seat Belts in Luxor Beige
      • Seat Belts in Miami Blue
      • Seat Belts in Racing Yellow
      • Seat Belts in Silver Grey
      • Air Vent Slats Painted
      • Air Vent Slats in Leather
      • Air Vents Painted
      • Air Vents in Leather
      • Aluminum PDK Gear Selector
      • Carbon Fiber Floor Mats with Leather Edging
      • Climate Control Panel Painted
      • Climate Control Panel in Leather
      • Contrast Stitching Interior Package
      • Customization Package Manual Gear Lever
      • Customization Package PDK Gear Selector
      • Deviated Floor Mats with Leather Edging
      • Extended Leather Interior Package Dashboard
      • Extended Leather Interior Package Door Surfaces
      • Extended Leather Interior Package Rear
      • GT Sport Steering Wheel in Alcantara
      • GT Sport Steering Wheel in Alcantara with PDK
      • Gear Lever in Carbon Fiber
      • Heated Multifunction Sport Steering Wheel in Mahogany
      • Inner Door-Sill Guards in Leather
      • Interior Package Painted
      • Interior Package Painted with Leather Interior
      • Interior Trim in Brushed Aluminum
      • Interior Trim in Brushed Aluminum with Leather Interior
      • Interior Trim in Carbon Fiber
      • Interior Trim in Carbon Fiber with Leather Interior
      • Interior Trim in Dark Mahogany
      • Interior Trim in Dark Mahogany with Leather Interior
      • Leather Interior Package
      • Leather Interior Package with Leather Interior
      • Manual Gear Lever in Mahogany
      • PDK Gear Selector in Carbon Fiber
      • PDK Gear Selector in Mahogany
      • Pedals and Footrest in Aluminum
      • Personalized Carbon Floor Mats with Leather Edging
      • Rear Center Tunnel in Leather with Decorative Stitching
      • Seat Belt Outlet Trim in Alcantara
      • Seat Belt Outlet Trim in Leather
      • Steering Column Casing in Leather
      • Sun Visors in Alcantara
      • Sun Visors in Leather
      • Transmission Tunnel in Leather
      • Extended Contrast Stitching Interior Package
      • Porsche Ceramic Composite Brake (PCCB)
      • Premium Package Plus with Adaptive Sport Seats Plus
      • Premium Package Plus with Power Sport Seats
      • Premium Package with Adaptive Sport Seats Plus
      • Premium Package with Power Sport Seats
      • Sport Chrono Package
      • SportDesign Package
      • Adaptive Cruise Control (ACC)
      • Lane-Change Assist (LCA)
      • Agate Grey, Leather Seat Trim with Leather Interior
      • Black, Leather Seat Trim with Leather Interior
      • Black/Bordeaux Red, 2-Tone Leather Seat Trim
      • Black/Dark Silver, Leather Seat Trim with Sport-Tex Seat Centers
      • Black/Luxor Beige, 2-Tone Leather Seat Trim
      • Bordeaux Red, Special Color Leather Seat Trim
      • Colour to Sample, Leather Seat Trim in Color to Sample
      • Espresso, Natural Leather Seat Trim
      • Espresso/Cognac, 2-Tone Natural Leather Seat Trim
      • Graphite Blue, Special Color Leather Seat Trim
      • Graphite Blue/Chalk, 2-Tone Leather Seat Trim
      • Graphite Blue/Chalk, Leather Seat Trim with Sport-Tex Seat Centers
      • Saddle Brown, Leather Seat Trim with Leather Interior
      • Seat Centers in Contrasting Leather
      • 14-Way Power Sport Seats
      • 18-Way Adaptive Sport Seats Plus
      • 4-Way Sport Seats Plus
      • Front Seat Heating
      • Front Seat Ventilation
      • Electric Slide/Tilt Sunroof
      • Electric Slide/Tilt Sunroof in Glass
      • Transmission: 7-Speed Porsche Doppelkupplung (PDK)
      • Wheels Painted in Exterior Color
      • Wheels Painted in High-Gloss Black
      • Wheels Painted in Jet Black Metallic
      • Wheels Painted in Satin Black
      • Wheels Painted in Satin Platinum
      • Wheels: 20" Carrera Classic
      • Wheels: 20" Carrera Sport
      • Wheels: 20" RS Spyder Design
      • Wheels: 8.5" x 20" Front/11.5" x 20" Rear Carrera S
      • Wheels: 9" x 20" Front/11.5" x 20" Rear 911 Turbo
      2016 Porsche Cayman
      Base

      Exterior Colors

      • Agate Gray Metallic
      • Black
      • Carmine Red
      • Carrera White Metallic
      • Custom Color Sample
      • Dark Blue Metallic
      • Exterior Color To Sample
      • GT Silver Metallic
      • Guards Red
      • Jet Black Metallic
      • Leather In Custom Color
      • Lime Gold Metallic
      • Mahogany Metallic
      • Racing Yellow
      • Rhodium Silver Metallic
      • Sapphire Blue Metallic
      • UPCHARGE Special Exterior Color
      • White

      Option Packages

      • 6-Disc CD Autochanger
      • Audio System CDR-Plus
      • BOSE Surround Sound System
      • CD/DVD Auto-Changer
      • Convenience Package
      • Porsche Active Suspension Management (PASM)
      • Sport Suspension (Lowered 20MM)
      • Exterior Mirror Lower Trim Painted
      • Exterior Package Painted
      • Personalized Illuminated Carbon Door-Sill Guards
      • Rear Apron Painted
      • Side Air Intakes Painted
      • Sports Tailpipe
      • Infotainment Package with BOSE Surround Sound System
      • Infotainment Package with BURMESTER Surround Sound System
      • Infotainment Package with Sound Package Plus
      • Instrument Dials in Guards Red
      • Instrument Dials in Luxor Beige
      • Instrument Dials in Racing Yellow
      • Instrument Dials in White
      • Sport CHRONO Timer Display Painted Guards Red
      • Sport CHRONO Timer Display Painted Luxor Beige
      • Sport CHRONO Timer Display Painted Racing Yellow
      • Sport CHRONO Timer Display Painted White
      • Aluminum Interior Package (EEM)
      • Aluminum Interior Package (EEN)
      • Aluminum Interior Package (EEl)
      • Carbon Center Console Trim
      • Carbon Door Entry Guards
      • Carbon Interior Package
      • Carbon Interior Package (EEG)
      • Carbon Interior Package (EEJ)
      • Carbon Interior Package (EEk)
      • Customization Package Gear Lever
      • Dashboard Trim Package In Leather
      • Gear Selector in Aluminum
      • Headliner Alcantara Black
      • Illuminated Carbon Door Entry Guards
      • Illuminated Door Entry Guards In Stainless Steel
      • Illuminated Stainless Steel Door Entry Guards
      • Inner Door-Sill Guards in Leather
      • Interior Mahogany Package (EEB)
      • Interior Mahogany Package (EEC)
      • Leather Air Vent Slats
      • Leather Door Trim Package
      • Leather Interior Package
      • Leather Interior Package (EES)
      • Leather PCM Package
      • Leather Rear View Mirror
      • Mahogany Center Console Trim
      • Mahogany Interior Package with PDK
      • PCM Package Painted
      • Painted Interior Package
      • Platinum Gray Full Leather Seat/Interior Trim
      • Sports Style Footrest In Aluminum
      • Standard Carpeting in Deviating Color
      • Steering Wheel Rim with Deviating Stitching
      • Sun Visors in Alcantara
      • Sun Visors in Leather
      • Extended Interior Package Plus
      • Mahogany Interior Package with Leather Interior/PDK
      • Premium Package Plus with Adaptive Sport Seats
      • Premium Package Plus with Sport Seats
      • Premium Package with Adaptive Sport Seats
      • Sport Chrono Package
      • Sport Chrono Package (640)
      • SportDesign Package
      • Adaptive Cruise Control
      • Aluminum Interior Package (EEP)
      • Automatically Dimming Interior & Exterior Mirrors
      • Bi-Xenon Headlights with High Beam Assist
      • Bi-Xenon Headlights with PDLS
      • Carbon Multifunction Heated Steering Wheel
      • Cordless Receiver For Telephone Module
      • Customization Package PDX Gear Selector
      • Electronic Logbook
      • Mahogany Multifunction Heated Steering Wheel
      • Multifunction Steering Wheel
      • PARKASSIST Front & Rear
      • PARKASSIST Front & Rear with Reversing Camera
      • PARKASSIST Rear
      • Porsche Ceramic Composite Brakes (PCCB)
      • Porsche Torque Vectoring (PTV)
      • Premium Package with Sport Seats
      • Seat Inlays In Leather Color To Sample
      • Sports Exhaust System with Sports Tailpipe
      • Tinted Taillights
      • Voice Control
      • Wheels Painted In Black
      • Wheels Painted In Black Satin
      • Wheels Painted In Platinum (Silk Gloss)
      • Agate Gray Special Leather Seat/Interior Trim
      • Agate Gray/Amber Orange Two-Tone Leather Seat Trim
      • Agate Gray/Amber Orange Two-Tone Partial Leather Seat Trim
      • Agate Gray/Lime Gold Two-Tone Leather Seat Trim
      • Agate Gray/Lime Gold Two-Tone Partial Leather Seat Trim
      • Agate Gray/Pebble Gray Two-Tone Leather Seat Trim
      • Agate Gray/Pebble Gray Two-Tone Partial Leather Seat Trim
      • Black Full Leather Seat/Interior Trim
      • Black Partial Leather Seat Trim with Leather Package
      • Espresso Natural Leather Seat Trim
      • Garnet Red Natural Leather Seat Trim
      • Leather Seat Inlays In Deviating Color
      • Leather Sports Seat Backrests
      • Luxor Beige Full Leather Seat/Interior Trim
      • Luxor Beige Partial Leather Seat Trim with Leather Package
      • Luxor Beige/Black Two-Tone Leather Seat Trim
      • Platinum Gray Partial Leather Seat Trim with Leather Package
      • Seat Stitching in Deviating Thread
      • Yachting Blue Full Leather Seat/Interior Trim
      • Yachting Blue Partial Leather Seat Trim with Leather Package
      • 14-Way Electric Sport Seats with Memory Package
      • 18-Way Adaptive Sport Seats with Memory Package
      • 2-Way Electric Sport Seats Plus
      • Seat Ventilation
      • Transmission: 7-Speed Porsche DOPPELKUPPLUNG (PDK)
      • Wheels Painted in Black (High-Gloss)
      • Wheels Painted in Exterior Color
      • Wheels: 20" 911 Turbo
      • Wheels: 8.5J X 20" Front & 10J X 20" Rear SportTechno
      • Wheels: 8J X 19" Front & 9.5J X 19" Rear Boxster S Alloy
      • Wheels: 8J X 19" Front & 9.5J X 19" Rear Cayman S Alloy
      • Wheels: 8J X 20" FR & 9.5J X 20" RR Carrera Classic
      • Wheels: 8J X 20" Front & 9.5J X 20" Rear Carrera S Alloy

      Related Comparisons