Used Subaru Forester for Sale near Mattituck, NY
CarGurus recommends the 2025 Subaru Forester
## Summary
- With 3,153 currently listed for sale and an **average price of $32,965.00**, 33.0% of 2025 Subaru Foresters for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
- **Favorably reviewed:** Owners rated the 2025 Subaru Forester 5 / 5 stars.
- **95.7% of 2025 Forester models on CarGurus are accident free**.
- The 2025 Subaru Forester offers an updated interior with more advanced tech, including a larger multimedia system and improved cabin noise reduction, enhancing the comfortable ride for families and adventurers alike.
## Why it stands out
The 2025 Subaru Forester retains its position as a leading compact crossover with enhancements that appeal to a broad range of buyers. Known for its reliability, spacious interiors, and exceptional all-wheel drive capabilities, the Forester has improved its already solid reputation with updates in technology and comfort. The new model is lauded for remarkable noise reduction, and it maintains a high safety rating, making it suitable for families seeking practicality. Its adept handling in diverse weather conditions and available advanced safety features further solidify its attractiveness, all while keeping a strong focus on functionality over flashy design.
## Other model years to consider
- **[2022 Subaru Forester](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2022-Subaru-Forester-c31995)**
- Average price: $25,424.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 28.1%
- User rating: 4.68 / 5
- Total listings: 3,566
- **[2019 Subaru Forester](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2019-Subaru-Forester-c27686)**
- Average price: $19,137.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 31.5%
- User rating: 4.68 / 5
- Total listings: 2,494
- **[2024 Subaru Forester](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2024-Subaru-Forester-c33190)**
- Average price: $29,920.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 30.2%
- User rating: 4.6 / 5
- Total listings: 4,124
These recommendations are based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from March 30, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.
4.4 Overall rating
(600 reviews)Customers say
Overall, drivers have consistently praised the Subaru Forester across all model years for its reliability, spacious interiors, and excellent all-wheel drive capabilities. Many appreciate the safety features and comfortable ride, making it a top choice for families and adventurous individuals alike. However, some owners have expressed concerns about performance, particularly the lack of power and sluggish acceleration, as well as the outdated styling in certain models. Despite these downsides, the Forester is viewed as a practical and dependable option that often provides great value for money.
AI generated from the text of customer reviews.
What people say
We love our new/used. Subaru Forester. We loved our Subaru Impreza, but it ha d done it’s duty. Trading it in for the Forester is wonderful. We know we can relay on Subaru’s amazing all wheel drive to easily and confidently drive in the winter. We really appreciate having a bit more cargo space for long car camping trips. Love our new Subaru!
I love my 2010 Subaru Forester! It’s the perfect size to accommodate adventures without being bulky or hard to maneuver. I used ittoday to transport a twin mattress and I never could have done that in my old car. My daughter is safe in the back seat and I can easily make adjustments inside to keep us comfortable. Highly recommend!
Im a big guy (62) and I really like the headroom. We currently own an Outback and that car would have been more practical (towing). However, I feel more upright in my Forester instead of reclined in the Outback.
Awesome car:). A must with our winters. Wouldnt buy anything else.
This car was just what I was looking for. I love the sun roof. The all wheel drive and the way the car floats down the freeway. Plenty of power. Great gas mileage. Automatic lift gate at the touch of a button.
Subaru Forester FAQs
Is Subaru discontinuing the Forester?
No, Subaru is not discontinuing the Forester. The 2025 Subaru Forester is set to continue production, with the Forester Wilderness model carrying over from the 2024 lineup. The new Forester is well-equipped with standard features like Subaru's Symmetrical All-Wheel Drive, ensuring it remains a popular choice among SUV buyers.
Which year of the Subaru Forester is reliable?
When searching for a reliable used Subaru Forester, certain model years stand out. The 2000 model from the first generation and the 2003-2005 models from the second generation are particularly noted for their dependability. These years have demonstrated strong performance and fewer issues compared to other model years, making them excellent choices for a used vehicle.
What are the downsides of a Subaru Forester?
While the Subaru Forester is generally well-regarded, it does have some common issues. Notably, some models with CVT transmissions have experienced problems, and there have been reports of excessive oil consumption in various models. Additionally, the check engine light can illuminate for multiple reasons, requiring attention. Despite these downsides, many Forester owners find the benefits outweigh these occasional issues.
How many miles does a Subaru Forester last?
The Subaru Forester is known for its longevity, with many models achieving up to 200,000 miles or more with proper maintenance. Its robust construction and reliable performance make it a durable choice for long-term ownership. Regular maintenance and timely repairs are key to ensuring the Forester remains a dependable vehicle for many years.
How much does the Subaru Forester cost in Mattituck, NY?
The average Subaru Forester costs about $21,571.23. The average price has increased by 1.3% since last year. The 282 for sale near Mattituck, NY on CarGurus, range from $4,888 to $42,034 in price.
Is the Subaru Forester a good car?
CarGurus experts gave the 2026 Subaru Forester an overall rating of 7.5/10 and Subaru Forester owners have rated the vehicle a 4.4/5 stars on average. If a vehicle has both strong expert and owner reviews, you can feel confident in its quality. If either expert reviews, owner reviews, or both are spotty, you might want to do some research to figure out where the car falls short.
How many Subaru Forester vehicles in Mattituck, NY have no reported accidents or damage?
282 out of 282 for sale near Mattituck, NY have no reported accidents or damage.
Is the Subaru Forester safe?
CarGurus experts gave the 2026 Subaru Forester a safety rating of 9/10.
What fuel types are available?
Gasoline engines are available.
-
Used Subaru Forester for Sale Under $10,000 Near Mattituck
-
Used Subaru Forester for Sale Under $15,000 Near Mattituck
-
Used Subaru Forester for Sale Under $20,000 Near Mattituck
-
Used Subaru Forester for Sale Under $25,000 Near Mattituck
-
Used Subaru Forester for Sale Under $30,000 Near Mattituck
-
Used Subaru Forester for Sale Under $40,000 Near Mattituck
-
Subaru Forester Premium Crossover AWD
-
Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium
-
Subaru Forester Limited Crossover AWD
-
Subaru Forester Sport Crossover AWD
-
Subaru Forester Wilderness Crossover AWD
-
Subaru Forester Touring Crossover AWD
-
Subaru Forester Crossover AWD
-
Subaru Forester 2.5i Limited
-
Subaru Forester 2.5i Premium AWD
-
Subaru Forester 2.5i
-
All Used Cars
-
Manual Transmission Cars
-
Luxury Cars
-
Cars with Red Interior
-
Cheap Manual Cars
-
Hybrid Cars
-
Sports Cars
-
Electric SUVs
-
Cheap Trucks
-
Small Cars
-
Third Row SUVs
-
Three Quarter Ton Trucks
-
Lifted Trucks
-
Manual Transmission Trucks
-
Diesel Trucks
-
Hybrid SUVs
-
Dually Trucks
-
One Ton Trucks
-
Cheap SUVs
-
Lifted Ford Trucks
-
4x4 Trucks
-
Work Trucks
-
AWD SUVs
-
Ford Trucks
-
Chevrolet Trucks
-
Toyota Trucks
-
Trucks Under $10,000
-
Cars Under $15,000
-
Sports Cars Under $20,000
-
Trucks Under $20,000
-
Used Sedans for Sale with Low Mileage in Mattituck
-
Used SUVs / Crossovers for Sale with Low Mileage in Mattituck
-
Used Hatchbacks for Sale with Low Mileage in Mattituck
-
Used Convertibles for Sale with Low Mileage in Mattituck
-
Used Vans for Sale with Low Mileage in Mattituck
-
Used Minivans for Sale with Low Mileage in Mattituck
-
Used Pickup Trucks for Sale with Low Mileage in Mattituck
-
Used Coupes for Sale with Low Mileage in Mattituck
-
Used Wagons for Sale with Low Mileage in Mattituck