Used 2016 Toyota Corolla for Sale near Raritan, NJ

## Summary - With 2,135 currently listed for sale on CarGurus and an **average price of $12,119.00**, 32.4% of 2016 Toyota Corollas for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals. - **Favorably reviewed:** Owners rated the 2016 Toyota Corolla 4.31 / 5 stars. - **47.3% of 2016 Corolla models on CarGurus are accident free**. - The 2016 Toyota Corolla faces stronger competition than ever but retains its popular appeal with impressive fuel economy and cost-effectiveness, making it a compelling choice for those in the market for a reliable economy car. ## Why it stands out The 2016 Toyota Corolla distinguishes itself in the competitive compact car market by blending fuel efficiency with a comfortable ride, making it appealing for buyers seeking reliable daily transportation. This model year features a sporty design, particularly in the S trim, which includes unique alloy wheels and sporty badging that gives it an eye-catching presence. Under the hood, it is equipped with a capable 1.8-liter inline 4-cylinder engine that balances fuel economy and functional power, delivering an EPA-estimated 29 MPG city and 38 MPG highway. While it may not be the fastest option on the market, its handling is steady and pleasant to drive, thus maintaining the Corolla's reputation for dependability. Owners particularly appreciate the spacious cabin and straightforward technology, though some have noted missing features compared to competitors. Overall, its cost-effectiveness and reliability make the 2016 Toyota Corolla a strong contender in the economy car realm. ## Other model years to consider - **[2024 Toyota Corolla](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2024-Toyota-Corolla-c33099)** - Average price: $19,866.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 32.6% - User rating: 4.82 / 5 - Total listings: 9,718 - **[2023 Toyota Corolla](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2023-Toyota-Corolla-c32598)** - Average price: $19,227.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 32.8% - User rating: 4.80 / 5 - Total listings: 8,746 - **[2025 Toyota Corolla](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2025-Toyota-Corolla-c33705)** - Average price: $21,287.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 31.8% - Total listings: 8,051 This analysis is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from February 23, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.