Best Cars Over 40 MPG for Sale in New Castle, IN

2024 BMW i5

M60 AWD

15,959 miles

$55,500

Good Deal

Indianapolis, IN

46 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: BMW
Model:: i5
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: Electric
Exterior color:: Gray
Combined gas mileage:: 91 MPG
Fuel type:: Electric
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 15,959
Stock number:: WI1079
VIN:: WBY43FK00RCN81079

Sponsored

2024 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid

Limited FWD

23,598 miles

$27,185

Good Deal

Muncie, IN

19 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Hyundai
Model:: Sonata Hybrid
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 2L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Aero Silver
Combined gas mileage:: 47 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: 6-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 23,598
Stock number:: 2P731
VIN:: KMHL54JJ3RA102053

Sponsored

2024 Porsche Taycan

4S Sedan AWD

17,602 miles

$85,650

Fair Deal

Indianapolis, IN

46 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Porsche
Model:: Taycan
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: Electric
Exterior color:: Gray
Combined gas mileage:: 82 MPG
Fuel type:: Electric
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: 2-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 17,602
Stock number:: WI5329
VIN:: WP0AB2Y16RSA35329

Sponsored

2024 Hyundai Sonata Hybrid

Limited FWD

23,598 miles

$27,185

Good Deal

Muncie, IN

19 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Hyundai
Model:: Sonata Hybrid
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 2L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Aero Silver
Combined gas mileage:: 47 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: 6-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 23,598
Stock number:: 2P731
VIN:: KMHL54JJ3RA102053

2024 Jeep Wrangler 4xe

Sport S 4WD

13,484 miles

$31,988

Great Deal

Greenwood, IN

46 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Jeep
Model:: Wrangler 4xe
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Four-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 375 hp 2L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Hydro Blue Pearlcoat
Combined gas mileage:: 49 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: 8-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 13,484
Stock number:: P5988
VIN:: 1C4RJXN66RW212230

2024 Honda Accord Hybrid

Sport FWD

42,617 miles

$24,500

Great Deal

Certified Pre-Owned

Indianapolis, IN

38 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Honda
Model:: Accord Hybrid
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 204 hp 2L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Solar Silver Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 44 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:: 42,617
Stock number:: 2P6839
VIN:: 1HGCY2F55RA058764

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Kia Niro

EX Touring FWD

9,646 miles

$24,868

Good Deal

Indianapolis, IN

38 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Kia
Model:: Niro
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 1.6L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Steel Gray
Combined gas mileage:: 49 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black (Charcoal)
Transmission:: 6-Speed Dual Clutch
Mileage:: 9,646
Stock number:: KRSL5682
VIN:: KNDCR3LE4S5233221

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Toyota Camry

LE FWD

15,636 miles

$24,500

Good Deal

Indianapolis, IN

39 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Toyota
Model:: Camry
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 2.5L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Heavy Metal
Combined gas mileage:: 52 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:: 15,636
Stock number:: TIRT3022A
VIN:: 4T1DAACK6SU073172

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Toyota Corolla Hybrid

Nightshade AWD

26,897 miles

$26,500

Fair Deal

Richmond, IN

26 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Toyota
Model:: Corolla Hybrid
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 1.8L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Ice Cap
Combined gas mileage:: 48 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:: 26,897
Stock number:: 93221
VIN:: JTDBDMHE7R3010556

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Honda Prologue

EX AWD

1,437 miles

$25,000

Good Deal

Indianapolis, IN

38 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Honda
Model:: Prologue
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: Electric
Exterior color:: Raven Black
Combined gas mileage:: 95 MPG
Fuel type:: Electric
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 1,437
Stock number:: 2P6504
VIN:: 3GPKHVRJ3RS517582

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Jeep Grand Cherokee 4xe

Overland 4WD

6,497 miles

$40,425

Good Deal

Indianapolis, IN

39 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Jeep
Model:: Grand Cherokee 4xe
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Four-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 375 hp 2L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Velvet Red Pearlcoat
Combined gas mileage:: 57 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Global Black
Transmission:: 8-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 6,497
Stock number:: NP130366
VIN:: 1C4RJYD63RC130366

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Kia Niro

SX Touring FWD

4,897 miles

$28,200

Good Deal

Indianapolis, IN

38 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Kia
Model:: Niro
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 1.6L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Snow White Pearl
Combined gas mileage:: 49 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black (Charcoal)
Transmission:: 6-Speed Dual Clutch
Mileage:: 4,897
Stock number:: KRSL5640
VIN:: KNDCT3LE2S5219111

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Mazda CX-70

PHEV Premium Plus AWD

6,282 miles

$42,325

Good Deal

Certified Pre-Owned

Westfield, IN

41 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Mazda
Model:: CX-70
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 323 hp 2.5L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Jet Black Mica
Combined gas mileage:: 57 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 6,282
Stock number:: P16556
VIN:: JM3KJEHA7S1109169

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Mercedes-Benz GLC

GLC 350e 4MATIC

3,824 miles

$49,978

Great Deal

Indianapolis, IN

39 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Mercedes-Benz
Model:: GLC
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 2L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Black
Combined gas mileage:: 65 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: AMG Neva Gray
Transmission:: 9-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 3,824
Stock number:: HICO5884
VIN:: W1NKM5GB2SF305977

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Kia Sportage Hybrid Plug-In

X-Line Prestige AWD

1,773 miles

$34,990

Good Deal

Certified Pre-Owned

Fishers, IN

34 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Kia
Model:: Sportage Hybrid Plug-In
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 1.6L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Fusion Black
Combined gas mileage:: 84 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: 6-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 1,773
Stock number:: F5323A
VIN:: KNDPZDDHXS7191626

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Audi Q8 e-tron

quattro Premium Plus AWD

12,693 miles

$38,606

Great Deal

Fishers, IN

34 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Audi
Model:: Q8 e-tron
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: Electric
Exterior color:: Gray
Combined gas mileage:: 81 MPG
Fuel type:: Electric
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 12,693
Stock number:: 9P5159
VIN:: WA15AAGE9RB015151

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Toyota Corolla Hybrid

SE FWD

13,069 miles

$25,960

Fair Deal

Indianapolis, IN

37 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Toyota
Model:: Corolla Hybrid
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 1.8L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Celestite
Combined gas mileage:: 50 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Moonstone
Transmission:: Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:: 13,069
Stock number:: T1075A
VIN:: JTDBCMFE0R3068417

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Mazda CX-70

PHEV Premium AWD

7,895 miles

$39,135

Great Deal

Westfield, IN

41 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Mazda
Model:: CX-70
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 323 hp 2.5L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Zircon Sand Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 57 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Greige
Transmission:: Automatic
Mileage:: 7,895
Stock number:: P16555
VIN:: JM3KJDHAXS1108592

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Jeep Wrangler 4xe

Willys 4WD

26,627 miles

$31,466

Good Deal

Indianapolis, IN

35 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Jeep
Model:: Wrangler 4xe
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Four-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 375 hp 2L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Silver Zynith Clearcoat
Combined gas mileage:: 49 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: 8-Speed Automatic
Mileage:: 26,627
Stock number:: 127966GW
VIN:: 1C4RJXN62RW127966

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Kia Niro

EX FWD

6,124 miles

$24,640

Good Deal

Certified Pre-Owned

Fishers, IN

34 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Kia
Model:: Niro
Body type:: SUV / Crossover
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 1.6L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Steel Gray
Combined gas mileage:: 49 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black (Charcoal)
Transmission:: 6-Speed Dual Clutch
Mileage:: 6,124
Stock number:: FRSL5866
VIN:: KNDCR3LE4S5225684

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Toyota Camry

LE FWD

42,924 miles

$24,198

Good Deal

Indianapolis, IN

37 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Toyota
Model:: Camry
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 2.5L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Gray
Combined gas mileage:: 52 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:: 42,924
Stock number:: 8FN8WL
VIN:: 4T1DAACK6SU015112

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Honda Accord Hybrid

Touring FWD

18,836 miles

$31,300

Fair Deal

Indianapolis, IN

38 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Honda
Model:: Accord Hybrid
Body type:: Sedan
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: Front-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 204 hp 2L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Canyon River Blue Metallic
Combined gas mileage:: 44 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Black
Transmission:: Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:: 18,836
Stock number:: 2P6879
VIN:: 1HGCY2F88RA061295

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2024 Toyota Prius

XLE AWD

4,213 miles

$30,960

Good Deal

Indianapolis, IN

37 mi away

Year:: 2024
Make:: Toyota
Model:: Prius
Body type:: Hatchback
Doors:: 4 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 2L I4 Hybrid
Exterior color:: White (Wind Chill Pearl)
Combined gas mileage:: 49 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: Gradient Black
Transmission:: Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:: 4,213
Stock number:: T0019A
VIN:: JTDADABU7R3021986

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Bentley Continental GTC

Speed AWD

4,849 miles

$339,990

Fair Deal

Indianapolis, IN

40 mi away

Year:: 2025
Make:: Bentley
Model:: Continental GTC
Body type:: Convertible
Doors:: 2 doors
Drivetrain:: All-Wheel Drive
Engine:: 4L V8 Hybrid
Exterior color:: Claret by Mulliner
Combined gas mileage:: 53 MPG
Fuel type:: Hybrid
Interior color:: White (Linen)
Transmission:: 8-Speed Dual Clutch
Mileage:: 4,849
Stock number:: SC020865A
VIN:: SCBDR4ZG0SC020865

Sponsored