Used Toyota Tacoma for Sale near Lima, OH

Summary

• With 8,369 currently listed for sale on CarGurus and an average price of $39,276.50, 34.3% of 2024 Toyota Tacomas for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
• Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2024 Toyota Tacoma 4.5 / 5 stars and CarGurus experts gave it an 7.8 / 10.
• 92.9% of 2024 Tacoma models on CarGurus are accident free.
• The 2024 Toyota Tacoma introduced a new hybrid drivetrain, delivering up to 326 horsepower while achieving the best fuel efficiency in its class.

Why it stands out

The Toyota Tacoma stands out in the midsize truck segment with its exceptional off-road capability and a strong reputation for reliability and durability. Built on the robust TNGA-F platform, it offers a range of powerful turbocharged engines, including an innovative hybrid option set to launch in 2024, enhancing both performance and fuel efficiency. With modern safety features and advanced infotainment systems standard across its six trim levels, the Tacoma seamlessly blends rugged utility with everyday drivability, making it an ideal choice for active lifestyles.

Other model years to consider

When considering the Toyota Tacoma, the 2021 and 2022 model years are particularly noteworthy due to their balance of affordability and quality ratings. The 2021 model, priced at approximately $32,200, boasts an impressive user rating of 4.8/5, making it a strong contender for those seeking a reliable vehicle with high satisfaction levels. Meanwhile, the 2022 model is available at a slightly higher average price of $33,439 but maintains a solid user rating of 4.3/5 along with favorable inventory availability, with about 35% classified as good or great deals.

For budget-conscious buyers looking for older options, the 2016 Tacoma stands out as moderately suitable; it offers a reasonable average price of around $24,453 and maintains a user rating of 4.3/5 with similar deal percentages.

Model years to approach with caution

Based on the current marketplace data for Toyota Tacoma model years, the 2002 and 2001 models stand out as having high user ratings of 4.6/5, but both face a significant proportion of listings (80% and 81%, respectively) classified as not good/great deals, indicating potential financial challenges in securing a value purchase. The more recent models, such as the 2018 Tacoma, average around $28,027.46 with a user rating of 4.2/5 but similarly show about 65% of deals not meeting favorable conditions, suggesting that while quality remains consistent, financial feasibility may be less favorable in this segment. In contrast, earlier years like the 1999 model with a high user rating of 4.6/5 but an even higher percentage (88%) of not good/great deals may present similar availability constraints and financial considerations that potential buyers should weigh carefully.

These recommendations are based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from November 11, 2025, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.