New & Used 2025 Toyota Prius for Sale near Effingham, IL

## Summary - With 1,002 currently listed for sale on CarGurus and an **average price of $28,090.00**, 31.9% of 2025 Toyota Priuses for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals. - **Expert rating:** CarGurus experts rated the 2025 Toyota Prius 6.67 / 10. - **92.6% of 2025 Prius models on CarGurus are accident free**. - The 2025 Toyota Prius continues to be the fuel economy champion among hybrids while incorporating a new Nightshade trim that features a stylish design with blacked-out elements. ## Why it stands out The 2025 Toyota Prius holds its ground as a leader in fuel efficiency landscapes, maintaining a reputation established over decades. This latest iteration features a sleek and futuristic aesthetic that modernizes its iconic boomerang shape. Notable for this year is the introduction of the Nightshade Edition, distinguished by its bold blacked-out styling, which enhances its visual appeal. Although its performance remains sprightly with a combined output of 194 horsepower from its hybrid drivetrain, real-world fuel economy tests indicate that it may not consistently meet the EPA’s estimates, averaging about 39.2 mpg compared to the rated 52 mpg. Also, while the technology and safety ratings are impressive, buyers should note the limited rear seat space and cargo capacity, which present considerations when comparing options in the hybrid segment. ## Other model years to consider - **[2024 Toyota Prius](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2024-Toyota-Prius-c33201)** - Average price: $26,967.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 32.5% - User rating: 4.4 / 5 - Total listings: 1,146 - **[2023 Toyota Prius](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2023-Toyota-Prius-c32701)** - Average price: $26,407.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 31.6% - User rating: 4.36 / 5 - Total listings: 1,016 - **[2024 Toyota Prius](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2024-Toyota-Prius-c33201)** - Average price: $26,967.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 32.5% - User rating: 4.4 / 5 - Total listings: 1,146 This analysis is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from February 17, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.