Used 2021 Tesla Model Y for Sale near Indianapolis, IN
352 results
CarGurus Analysis:
2021 Tesla Model Y
With 345 currently listed for sale near Indianapolis, IN and an average price of $23,540.00, 34.5% of 2021 Tesla Model Ys for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2021 Tesla Model Y 4.91 / 5 stars.
97.4% of 2021 Model Y models on CarGurus are accident free.
CarGurus Analysis: 2021 Tesla Model Y
Summary
With 345 currently listed for sale near Indianapolis, IN and an average price of $23,540.00, 34.5% of 2021 Tesla Model Ys for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.
Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2021 Tesla Model Y 4.91 / 5 stars.
97.4% of 2021 Model Y models on CarGurus are accident free.
Why it stands out
The 2021 Tesla Model Y has quickly gained a strong reputation thanks to its remarkable blend of electric efficiency, advanced technology, and enjoyable driving dynamics. Sharing about 75% of its parts with the Tesla Model 3, the Model Y effectively meets the demand for a compact luxury crossover while maintaining a competitive edge against other electric vehicles. Owners particularly appreciate its eco-friendliness, impressive acceleration, and spacious cargo area, making it suitable for both everyday tasks and adventures. While some users note concerns regarding its high price and reliance on touchscreen controls, the overall feedback reflects excitement and satisfaction with the vehicle's innovative features. The combination of high accident-free rates and owner enthusiasm positions the Model Y as an attractive choice for used electric vehicle buyers.
Other model years to consider
- Average price: $31,938.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 42.3%
- User rating: 4.75 / 5
- Total listings: 447
- Average price: $27,589.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 34.1%
- User rating: 4.81 / 5
- Total listings: 460
- Average price: $39,991.00
- Good/great deal percentage: 49.6%
- Total listings: 250
This analysis is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from April 14, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.
Relevant articles
The Best Cars for Dogs in 2026
Dogs are part of the family, and we’d like to take them with us wherever we go. With that in mind, here are some of the best cars for transporting dogs.
Tesla Model Y Buying Guide: Cost, Reliability, and the Best Years to Buy
Our definitive Tesla Model Y buying guide covers everything you need to know about this hugely popular EV, including its specs, history, and the best and worst versions to buy.
Tesla Model X Buying Guide: Cost, Reliability, and the Best Years to Buy
Our definitive Tesla Model S buying guide covers all the bases, with detailed info on the model's history, specs, and the best and worst versions to buy.
5.0 Overall rating
Filter by rating
Scott V
Reviewed a 2021 Tesla Long Range AWD on Dec 8, 2025
Amazing car! Smooth ride, very clean. Lots of room and very tech advanced. Best car I’ve own. Would prefer more miles per 80% charge but the pros make the purchase worth it.
Ken H
Reviewed a 2021 Tesla Model Y on Jul 2, 2024
Great. Can’t believe all this car can do. At first wasn’t that happy about everything on the screen. But now I like it. Takes time to find everything it can do but once you do, it’s amazing. Drives amazing. Love it.
Lieshia J
Reviewed a 2021 Tesla Long Range AWD on Sep 30, 2025
Excellent features. I feel the value of the car was good and was priced fairly.
Samar T
Reviewed a 2021 Tesla Long Range AWD on Oct 17, 2024
This car has an outstanding performance. No need to worry to change any parts.
2021 Tesla Model Y Trims
| Trim type | MSRP |
|---|---|
| Standard Range RWD | $41,990 |
| Long Range AWD | $49,990 |
| Performance AWD | $59,990 |
2021 Tesla Model Y Price Trends
CarGurus tracks the prices of millions of used car listings every year. See how the average price of 2021 Tesla Model Y prices has changed over time.
See more price trends
