Summary

• With 252 currently listed for sale near Indianapolis, IN and an average price of $28,162.00, 40.5% of 2021 Tesla Model Ys for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.

• Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2021 Tesla Model Y 4.91 / 5 stars.

• 100.0% of 2021 Model Y models on CarGurus are accident free.

• The 2021 Tesla Model Y stands out with its electric performance, spacious interior, and advanced technology features.

Why it stands out

The 2021 Tesla Model Y has quickly become a favorite among electric vehicle enthusiasts, thanks to its impressive combination of performance, space, and technology. Sharing around 75% of its parts with the Model 3, the Model Y offers a smooth driving experience with rapid acceleration and a range that often exceeds expectations, allowing drivers to explore without the constant worry of recharging. It features a minimalist yet high-tech interior, dominated by a large touchscreen interface that controls most of the car's functions. Although the tech interface can require a learning curve, the overall enthusiasm of owners, who appreciate the vehicle's eco-friendliness and driving dynamics, is evident in their high ratings. The Model Y offers a spacious cargo area and the reliability that comes with Tesla's comprehensive warranty, making it an excellent choice for those looking for an electric compact luxury crossover.

Other model years to consider

• 2023 Tesla Model Y

  • Average price: $30,023.00
  • Good/great deal percentage: 63.9%
  • User rating: 4.78 / 5
  • Total listings: 385

• 2022 Tesla Model Y

  • Average price: $31,241.00
  • Good/great deal percentage: 57.9%
  • User rating: 4.81 / 5
  • Total listings: 375

• 2020 Tesla Model Y

  • Average price: $25,498.00
  • Good/great deal percentage: 29.3%
  • User rating: 4.77 / 5
  • Total listings: 150

This analysis is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from May 26, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.