Summary

• With 516 currently listed for sale near Indianapolis, IN and an average price of $32,890.00, 39.3% of 2023 Tesla Model Ys for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals.

• Favorably reviewed: Owners rated the 2023 Tesla Model Y 4.78 / 5 stars.

• 100.0% of 2023 Model Y models on CarGurus are accident free.

Why it stands out

The 2023 Tesla Model Y stands out as a compact luxury crossover that blends EV practicality with strong performance and a roomy cabin. It is based on the Tesla Model 3 and shares 70% to 75% of its parts, but its taller, hatchback-style body gives it more space and versatility than a sedan-based design. Standard equipment is generous, with a 15-inch infotainment touchscreen that doubles as a gauge cluster, heated front and rear seats, reclining rear seats, a glass roof, four USB ports, video streaming capability, and Tesla’s Autopilot system. Cargo space is another major draw, thanks to under-floor storage in the rear and a front trunk.

For 2023, the Model Y also benefited from a series of updates that improved its appeal. In mid-2023, Tesla began rolling out updated high-definition cameras, ambient lighting, updated suspension tuning, and a new Autopilot processor. Range estimates for the Long Range model increased to 330 miles in 2023, while the Performance model was estimated at 279 miles. Buyers looking at this model year can also appreciate the available tow hitch with a 3,500-pound tow rating, along with optional Full Self-Driving (Supervised) capability and Smart Summon.

At the same time, the 2023 Model Y is not without drawbacks. It lacks Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, the ride is firm, and almost all controls are handled through the touchscreen. Even so, for shoppers who want a used EV with quick acceleration, a large cargo area, and a long list of standard features, the 2023 Tesla Model Y remains an appealing choice.

Other model years to consider

• 2022 Tesla Model Y

  • Average price: $32,098.00
  • Good/great deal percentage: 36.5%
  • User rating: 4.82 / 5
  • Total listings: 513

• 2021 Tesla Model Y

  • Average price: $28,970.00
  • Good/great deal percentage: 28.8%
  • User rating: 4.91 / 5
  • Total listings: 302

• 2025 Tesla Model Y

  • Average price: $38,594.00
  • Good/great deal percentage: 42.7%
  • Total listings: 206

This analysis is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from August 11, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.