CarGurus Logo Homepage Link
  • Buy
    • Used cars
    • New cars
    • Certified pre-owned
    • Start your purchase online
    • Dealerships near me
  • Sell
    • Sell my car
    • Car values
    • Sell my car FAQs
  • Finance
    • Prequalify for financing
    • How does it work?
    • Financing FAQs
  • Research
    • Test drive reviews
    • Price trends
    • Tips & advice
    • Electric cars
    • Compare cars
  • Discover
    The latest way to shop:
    smarter research, better
    listings.
  • Saved cars & searches
  • Sign in / Register
    • My account
    • Saved searches
    • Saved cars
    • Recommended cars
    • Browsing history
    • Financing dashboard
      • United States (EN)
      • Estados Unidos (ES)
      • Canada (EN)
      • Canada (FR)
      • United Kingdom

Used Subaru for Sale Under $40,000 Near Monticello, NY

8,576 results
Kiamesha Lake, NY
2019 Subaru Outback 2.5i Limited AWD Island Subaru

2019 Subaru Outback

2.5i Limited AWD

62,462 miles

$17,997

Good Deal
Staten Island, NY
81 mi away
Year:
2019
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Outback
Body type:
Wagon
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Magnetite Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
28 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
62,462
Stock number:
555649
VIN:
4S4BSANC8K3324483

Sponsored

2025 Subaru WRX Limited AWD

2025 Subaru WRX

Limited AWD

1,319 miles

$37,744

Fair Deal
Certified Pre-Owned
Woodbridge Township, NJ
78 mi away
Year:
2025
Make:
Subaru
Model:
WRX
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
271 hp 2.4L H4
Exterior color:
Ignition Red
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Mileage:
1,319
Stock number:
S7984
VIN:
JF1VBAN63S8801812

Sponsored

2024 Subaru WRX TR AWD

2024 Subaru WRX

TR AWD

38,707 miles

$32,500

Fair Deal
Doylestown, PA
96 mi away
Year:
2024
Make:
Subaru
Model:
WRX
Body type:
Sedan
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
271 hp 2.4L H4
Exterior color:
Blue
Combined gas mileage:
22 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Manual
Mileage:
38,707
Stock number:
R9804239
VIN:
JF1VBAY63R9804239

Sponsored

2019 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Premium AWD

2019 Subaru Crosstrek

2.0i Premium AWD

120,607 miles

$10,851

Great Deal
Hackettstown, NJ
57 mi away
Year:
2019
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Crosstrek
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
152 hp 2L H4
Exterior color:
Crystal White Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
30 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
120,607
Stock number:
KH339065
VIN:
JF2GTACC1KH339065

2017 Subaru Outback 2.5i Limited AWD

2017 Subaru Outback

2.5i Limited AWD

112,319 miles

$11,995

Great Deal
Bristol, CT
89 mi away
Year:
2017
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Outback
Body type:
Wagon
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Crystal White Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
28 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Slate Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
112,319
VIN:
4S4BSAKC7H3308532

2019 Subaru Crosstrek 2.0i Premium AWD

2019 Subaru Crosstrek

2.0i Premium AWD

80,429 miles

$15,701

Good Deal
Wappingers Falls, NY
40 mi away
Year:
2019
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Crosstrek
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
152 hp 2L H4
Exterior color:
Blue
Combined gas mileage:
30 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
80,429
Stock number:
V409
VIN:
JF2GTACC5KH217020

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 Subaru Crosstrek

Limited AWD

12,784 miles

$22,488

Great Deal
West Nyack, NY
55 mi away
Year:
2021
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Crosstrek
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Ice Silver Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
30 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
8-Speed CVT
Mileage:
12,784
Stock number:
48036B
VIN:
JF2GTHMCXM8260634

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 Subaru Ascent

Limited AWD

80,230 miles

$20,624

Good Deal
Middletown, NY
22 mi away
Year:
2021
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Ascent
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Exterior color:
Crystal White Pearl
Interior color:
White (Warm Ivory)
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
80,230
Stock number:
M3466150C
VIN:
4S4WMALD8M3466150

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2015 Subaru Outback

2.5i Limited

131,741 miles

$10,998

Fair Deal
East Granby, CT
100 mi away
Year:
2015
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Outback
Body type:
Wagon
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Silver
Combined gas mileage:
29 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
131,741
Stock number:
1.YEAR.WARRANTY
VIN:
4S4BSAJC2F3224231

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2015 Subaru Forester

2.5i Premium

114,942 miles

$10,495

Fair Deal
Poughkeepsie, NY
38 mi away
Year:
2015
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Forester
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Black
Combined gas mileage:
28 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
114,942
Stock number:
1952
VIN:
JF2SJADC9FH567559

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 Subaru Crosstrek

Premium AWD

124,163 miles

$13,777

Good Deal
Danbury, CT
68 mi away
Year:
2021
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Crosstrek
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
152 hp 2L H4
Exterior color:
Magnetite Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
30 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
124,163
Stock number:
N8869A
VIN:
JF2GTAEC4M8280299

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2016 Subaru Crosstrek

Premium AWD

86,972 miles

$13,260

Fair Deal
Stroudsburg, PA
59 mi away
Year:
2016
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Crosstrek
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
2L H4
Exterior color:
Quartz Blue
Combined gas mileage:
30 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
White (Ivory)
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
86,972
Stock number:
F22931
VIN:
JF2GPABC9G8222931

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2016 Subaru Forester

2.5i Premium

71,112 miles

$13,990

Fair Deal
Tinton Falls, NJ
98 mi away
Year:
2016
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Forester
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Crystal White Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
28 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
71,112
Stock number:
SH454110A
VIN:
JF2SJADC5GH518506

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2015 Subaru Crosstrek

XV Limited AWD

63,297 miles

$13,375

Good Deal
Valley Stream, NY
86 mi away
Year:
2015
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Crosstrek
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
2L H4
Exterior color:
Ice Silver Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
30 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
6-Speed CVT
Mileage:
63,297
Stock number:
1006
VIN:
JF2GPAMC9F8224741

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2014 Subaru Forester

2.5i Premium

67,251 miles

$11,995

Good Deal
Hudson, NY
61 mi away
Year:
2014
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Forester
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
170 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
White
Combined gas mileage:
28 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Brown (Tan)
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
67,251
Stock number:
1701
VIN:
JF2SJAEC9EH507553

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 Subaru Forester

Crossover AWD

45,254 miles

$19,740

Great Deal
Pittsfield, MA
91 mi away
Year:
2021
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Forester
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Crystal Black Silica
Combined gas mileage:
29 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
45,254
Stock number:
E3811
VIN:
JF2SKADC9MH446069

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2019 Subaru Crosstrek

2.0i Limited AWD

71,033 miles

$16,939

Great Deal
Hamilton, NJ
95 mi away
Year:
2019
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Crosstrek
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
152 hp 2L H4
Exterior color:
Dark Gray Metallic
Combined gas mileage:
30 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
71,033
Stock number:
KH248257
VIN:
JF2GTANC8KH248257

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2015 Subaru Outback

2.5i

115,796 miles

$9,495

Good Deal
Linden, NJ
75 mi away
Year:
2015
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Outback
Body type:
Wagon
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Gray
Combined gas mileage:
29 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
115,796
VIN:
4S4BSAAC2F3272263

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2019 Subaru Crosstrek

2.0i Premium AWD

144,686 miles

$9,700

Good Deal
Uniondale, NY
88 mi away
Year:
2019
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Crosstrek
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
152 hp 2L H4
Exterior color:
Cool Gray Khaki
Combined gas mileage:
30 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
144,686
VIN:
JF2GTACC1K9245973

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2018 Subaru Outback

2.5i Touring AWD

80,491 miles

$18,999

Good Deal
Granby, CT
99 mi away
Year:
2018
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Outback
Body type:
Wagon
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
White
Combined gas mileage:
28 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Brown
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
80,491
Stock number:
J3306956
VIN:
4S4BSATCXJ3306956

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2025 Subaru Forester

Crossover AWD

5,295 miles

$27,059

Good Deal
Hazle Township, PA
84 mi away
Year:
2025
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Forester
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Crystal White Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
29 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
5,295
Stock number:
SH413070P
VIN:
JF2SLDAC5SH413070

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2021 Subaru Crosstrek

62,131 miles

$17,998

Great Deal
Clifton Park, NY
93 mi away
Year:
2021
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Crosstrek
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Engine:
152 hp 2L H4
Exterior color:
White
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Black
Transmission:
Automatic
Mileage:
62,131
Stock number:
FS287
VIN:
JF2GTABC6M8311301

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2020 Subaru Forester

2.5i Limited AWD

24,499 miles

$23,499

Great Deal
Binghamton, NY
70 mi away
Year:
2020
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Forester
Body type:
SUV / Crossover
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
182 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Horizon Blue Pearl
Combined gas mileage:
29 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Interior color:
Gray
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
24,499
Stock number:
T9041A
VIN:
JF2SKAUC2LH435235

Preparing for a close up...

Photos coming soon

2015 Subaru Outback

2.5i

110,289 miles

$11,523

Fair Deal
Torrington, CT
81 mi away
Year:
2015
Make:
Subaru
Model:
Outback
Body type:
Wagon
Doors:
4 doors
Drivetrain:
All-Wheel Drive
Engine:
175 hp 2.5L H4
Exterior color:
Silver
Combined gas mileage:
29 MPG
Fuel type:
Gasoline
Transmission:
Continuously Variable Transmission
Mileage:
110,289
Stock number:
S000917A
VIN:
4S4BSAAC2F3315516

Sponsored

  1. Home
  2. / Used Cars
  3. / Subaru
  4. / New York
  5. / Monticello
Connect with us
Download our app
Download on the App Store Get it on Google Play
  • Company
  • About CarGurus
  • Our team
  • Press
  • Investor relations
  • Price trends
  • Careers
  • Advertise with CarGurus
  • For dealers
  • Dealer signup
  • Dealer resources
  • Terms
  • Terms of use
  • Privacy policy
  • Interest-based ads
  • Security
  • Help
  • Help center
  • Contact us
Click for the BBB Business Review of this Auto Listing Service in Cambridge MA
    • United States (EN)
    • Estados Unidos (ES)
    • Canada (EN)
    • Canada (FR)
    • United Kingdom

© 2026 CarGurus, Inc., All Rights Reserved.