Nissan Rogue Buying Guide: Cost, Reliability, and the Best Years to Buy

by Leo Wilkinson

Nissan arrived late to the compact crossover sector when it introduced the Rogue in 2007, more than a decade after key rivals such as the first Honda CR-V and Toyota RAV4 hit dealerships. It’s not that Nissan didn’t do SUVs, because it already had a healthy back catalog of those, including the Armada and the Pathfinder. But the Rogue was something different: a more compact, sleek affair hoping to woo buyers with a combination of cost-effectiveness, style, and a drive focused on ease-of-use, rather than off-road ability.

The first Rogue had a similar look to the upscale Murano but it was smaller and lower, with dimensions close to the concurrent Toyota RAV4’s. The model lineup was simple, with just one 2.5 liter engine, a CVT automatic transmission and the choice of front-wheel drive (FWD) or all-wheel drive (AWD). It was keenly priced, with an MSRP starting at less than $20,000. That first Nissan Rogue proved very popular, and the two subsequent Rogue models (released in 2013 and 2020) have followed a similar formula. In fact, with each iteration, the Rogue has retained almost identical dimensions – the only notable change is that the second- and third-generation cars are slightly taller and have a boxier, more conventional SUV look. The drivetrain options haven’t changed much, either, apart from the switch from a naturally aspirated 2.5-liter engine to a 1.3-litre turbo engine in 2021.

Today, the Rogue is Nissan’s best-selling model in the US. It’s evolved into a high-tech family car, packed with advanced features, such as wireless integration for Android Auto or Apple CarPlay, and Nissan’s latest ProPilot Assist driver assistance feature, which can steer, brake and accelerate the car on the highway.

As with many successful franchises, the Rogue has had a couple of spin-offs, both of which are related to it but classed as different cars. First up was the Rogue Select – a version of the first-generation car that was sold alongside the second one from 2014 to 2015 at a lower price point. This was possible because, from its second generation onwards, the Rogue has been built at Nissan’s factory in Smyrna, Tennessee, whereas the first was built in Japan. There’s also the Rogue Hybrid, a hybrid-powered version of the second-generation model that was sold between 2017 and 2020, and the 2017-2022 Rogue Sport – a smaller model that shares some parts (including most of its interior) with the Rogue but is a much smaller car.

Here, we’re focusing on the main attraction – the Nissan Rogue. In this guide we’ll cover which models are available, the key specs for each version, and which Nissan Rogue models are the best to buy.

Nissan Rogue Buying Guide: Cost, Reliability, and the Best Years to Buy

Frequently Asked Questions

Which Nissan Rogue years are the best?

The latest Nissan Rogue model, from the 2021 model year onwards, is the best yet. It’s well priced, has plenty of equipment, is smooth to drive, and practical. The MSRP is the highest of any Rogue so far, but it’s still good value overall.

What are the worst Nissan Rogue years?

The 2013 Nissan Rogue takes the (unwanted) prize for the worst year for the model – data from carcomplaints.com suggests cars of this age are prone to transmission issues, with owners citing juddering, noisy or unresponsive transmissions, as well as total failure. It’s a problem that affects many Rogue model years, but 2013 seems to be the nadir.

Is a used Nissan Rogue a good deal?

The Nissan Rogue is a good deal if you’re looking for a family car that offers lots of space and standard features, a decent drive, and very competitive prices. The latest model is the easiest to recommend, but there are some reliability issues to be aware of with every version.

Nissan Rogue Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Roomy and family-friendly
  • Available with some advanced safety features
  • Good value for money

Cons:

  • CVT transmission not to all tastes and prone to failure
  • Limited choice of drivetrains
  • VC-Turbo engines can be troublesome

Nissan Rogue Generations


Third Generation (2020-present)

The latest, third-generation Nissan Rogue went on sale in 2020 for the 2021 model year. It’s dimensions are almost identical to the second-generation’s, yet it appears larger due to its chunkier square-edged design, which also makes it the most rugged-looking Rogue yet. It’s the most technologically advanced, too. Highlights for all new cars include a central touchscreen, LED headlights and Apple Carplay and Android Auto integration. Most Rogue models of this era have a power liftgate and ProPilot Assist – a driver-assistance feature that can help to control acceleration, braking and steering both in heavy traffic and on the open highway. Higher-spec trim levels have ProPilot Assist with Navi-link, which uses navigation map data to reduce speed for freeway curves, junctions, and exits.

At launch, the drivetrain was an update of the previous Rogue model’s, with a 2.5–liter engine (with 181 horsepower and 181 lb-ft of torque) paired with a CVT transmission and either front-wheel drive (fwd) or all-wheel drive (AWD). In late 2021, a new 1.5-litre, three-cylinder turbocharged engine replaced the four-cylinder 2.5. The new variable-compression engine – labeled VC-Turbo by Nissan – was more powerful, with 202 horsepower and 225 lb-ft of torque. It also returned better fuel economy, with an EPA combined rating of 33mpg for front-wheel drive models – a 3mpg improvement. There was a new CVT transmission, too, which helped to make the Rogue generally smooth and comfortable. Rogue S, Rogue SV, Rogue SL, and Rogue Platinum trim levels offer an increasingly opulent standard of equipment.

The latest Rogue feels like a more premium product than its predecessor, with an interior that uses high-grade tech and materials. The Nissan Rogue Platinum – which has electric adjustment for the front seats, quilted leather upholstery, and a heated steering wheel as standard – is positively luxurious.

All but the entry-level Rogue S models have a wi-fi hotspot, while a head-up display is an option for the top two trim levels. Every Rogue of this generation is very practical, with features geared towards making it a good fit for families. These include rear doors that open to almost 90 degrees, boosting accessibility and making it easy to get child seats in and out. There’s also the option of heated rear seats and tri-zone climate control that allows those in the back seat to select a different temperature to those in the front. Rogue Platinum models have a dual-panel panoramic moonroof (a big sunroof, basically), while a motion-activated power liftgate is an option for higher-spec models. Whereas some rivals offer seating for seven, the third-generation Rogue is only available as a five-seater.

The standard of safety equipment is high – since its introduction this Rogue model has featured Nissan Safety Shield 360 as standard – a package that includes automatic emergency braking with pedestrian detection, blind spot warning, rear cross traffic alert, lane departure warning, high beam assist, and rear automatic braking.

A light refresh in early 2024 brought a few upgrades, with new front and rear fascia designs, new tail lights and the availability of “Google built-in”, which integrates Google apps directly into the car’s infotainment system without having to pair a phone. It also added a new Rogue Rock Creek AWD model, which includes a range of off-road biased tech and cosmetic details.

There’s no doubt the current Rogue is – by most criteria – the best yet, but it’s not without its problems. While its overall reliability record is solid, some owners have reported issues with the air-con not working properly, but more concerning is a potential class action lawsuit relating to the 1.5 VC-Turbo engine. In December 2023, the National Highway of Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) announced plans to investigate reports of engine failures, loss of power, engine knocking noises, and metal chunks and shavings found in the oil pans of cars with this engine.

Prices for the latest Rogue start at about $14,000 for a sub-100k mileage used example. There are lots to choose from, so our advice is to shop around and avoid cars that haven’t been well cared for. Newer top-spec cars with options can cost up to $40,000 – slightly less than the MSRP for a brand-new Rogue Platinum model.

2020 Nissan Rogue Preview summaryImage

Second Generation (2013-2020)

The new Nissan Rogue that arrived in 2013 was all-but-identical in size and drivetrain spec to the one it replaced, but it represented a big step forwards, not least in the way it looked. This time around, the Rogue was less a crossover and more a full-fat SUV, with a tougher, more upright stance in line with rivals such as the Honda CR-V and the Toyota RAV4. It also packed a lot more high-tech convenience and safety features, felt more premium, and remains the only Rogue offered with seven seats as an option. All versions had reclining second-row seats and ‘Divide-N-Hide’ – a system of folding panels that allows you to organize, or hide, items in the trunk.

The model lineup is straightforward: a 2.5-liter engine with 170 horsepower and 175 lb-ft of torque was the only power option, mated to Nissan’s ‘Xtronic’ CVT transmission and either FWD or AWD. The EPA fuel economy rating was pretty average, ranging, with mid-20s mpg. The core trim levels were Rogue S, Rogue SV, and Rogue SL – even entry-level S included a rear-view camera, while Nissan Rogue SV models and above have dual-zone climate control, power driver’s seat adjustment, automatic headlights, Sirius satellite radio, and NissanConnect, which integrated a range of apps into the infotainment system.

Nissan Rogue SL models have a power liftgate and Nissan’s “Intelligent around view monitor”, which combined the view from external cameras to show a bird’s eye view of the car on the touchscreen display – a real boon when parking in tight spaces. One special-edition model worth mentioning is the “Nissan Rogue: Rogue One Star Wars Limited Edition”, a special-edition model introduced in 2016, as a tie-in with the Star Wars movie Rogue One: A Star Wars Story. May the force be with you if you buy one of those.

An update for the 2017 model year included some minor cosmetic changes, such as a new grille and revised tail lights. A bigger development for the 2018 model year was the introduction of ProPilot Assist as an option – this semi-autonomous driving feature helped to accelerate, brake, and steer the car on the highway. At the same time, automatic emergency braking and a blind spot warning system became standard for all models. Nissan also dropped the seven-seat option for the 2018 model year.

Despite Nissan’s expertise with CVT technology, the Xtronic transmission the 2013-2020 Rogue model used can be problematic. Some owners have cited problems with juddering or noise, along with total failure of the transmission, despite comparatively low mileage. In 2024, Nissan agreed to pay more than $277 million to settle a class action lawsuit related to defective Xtronic transmissions.

Its popularity means there is a huge number of used Nissan Rogues available. That means you can afford to be choosy, and we’d recommend about $9,000 as the starting point, which will get you an early model with less than 100,000 miles on the odometer. Better still, if you can stretch to $14,000 or so you can get a higher-spec, post-facelift model.

2011 Nissan Rogue Preview summaryImage

First Generation (2007-2013)

The first Nissan Rogue was an instant sales hit, proving Nissan’s hunch that buyers wanted a budget-friendly family car that was a touch more SUV-like than the average hatchback or sedan was on the money.

Choice isn’t something that you got a lot of with the first-gen Rogue – the only engine option was a 170-horsepower 2.5-liter, combined with Nissan’s Xtronic CVT transmission. It had reasonable performance, although some rival cars have more powerful options, and the EPA fuel economy rating is nothing special. You can choose between front-wheel drive or all-wheel models, with the majority being sold with AWD. First-gen Nissan Rogue trim levels were Rogue S, Rogue SV, and Rogue SL. Each one had a decent standard of equipment for the time, with safety features such as front, side and curtain airbags. Optional features included a Bose premium audio system, Bluetooth, xenon headlights, and cruise control.

A facelift for the 2011 model year brought some design tweaks and updated features, such as a rear-view camera and new 18-inch aluminum-alloy wheels. It also added the limited-edition Rogue Krom Edition to the range, which got a sporty makeover with bespoke front and rear bumpers, alloy wheels, and a central exhaust tail pipe, among other elements.

If you’re in the market for a used Rogue, then transmission problems are the main thing to look out for. In every year of the first-generation Rogue’s production run, this is, by a long way, the top-ranked problem cited by Rogue owners on carcomplaints.com. They complain of poor performance, whirring noises, and outright transmission failure, so keep an eye out.

As a new car, the MSRP for the Rogue started just below $20,000, but you can pay as little as 10% of that now. If you don’t want a car that looks ready for the scrapheap, though, you should budget for $6,000 or more and get one with less than 100,000 miles on the clock. Stretch to $8,000 and you should be able to get a post-2011 Rogue AWD model that’s covered less than 80,000 miles.

Related Topics

Leo is a writer and editor specialising in the automotive sector. He has held senior roles at What Car?, MSN Cars, The Telegraph and Cazoo, and since gone on to write for brands including Auto Trader and CarGurus. Over the past twenty-plus years he has driven and reviewed hundreds of cars, from budget-priced runarounds to luxury SUVs.

The content above is for informational purposes only and should be independently verified. Please see our Terms of Use for more details.