Looking for a Used Forester in your area?
CarGurus has 30,455 nationwide Forester listings starting at $650.
2015 Subaru Forester Test Drive Review
With a Top Safety Pick and Best Value under its belt, the Subaru Forester is a great choice in a crossover—especially if you don't care about the latest, greatest tech or the most luxurious interior.
The Forester is still fresh off a 2014 redesign that had everyone singing its praises. Motor Trend named it SUV of the Year, and the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) called it out as a Top Safety Pick. I’ve been a Subaru fan for many years and have logged my fair share of miles in Outbacks and WRXs alike, even driving one special example up and down the eastern seaboard. But for this new Forester, I just wasn’t sure what all the fuss was about. After a week with a 2.5i Premium trim, I understand a little better.
Look and Feel
Available with either an asthmatic or turbocharged boxer 4-cylinder, the Forester follows the traditional design style of Subarus past and offers understated or slightly aggressive versions of the same car, depending on your choice of powertrain. Pick the regular 2.5-liter, and you’ll get a sharp, handsome crossover SUV that really has only aesthetic competition from the Mazda CX-5. Go with the turbo, and you’ll be treated with extra lines and angles that tell everyone you mean business in the way only forced induction can.
Regardless of choice, you’ll get a capable crossover that rides like a car, hauls like a truck, and can even drive over a few things if you so choose. The interior is still below par, and the infotainment system is one of the worst in the industry, but otherwise the Forester is a nimble, utilitarian, and—most importantly—very safe option in the segment.
For my week with the Forester, Subaru provided me with the 2.5i Premium (MSRP $25,095) with the added All-Weather and EyeSight packages for an extra $1,295 ($500 off for 2015), bringing the total to a reasonable $27,439 with delivery ($850) and the auto-dimming mirror with built-in compass ($199).
Subaru has come very close to providing a perfect balance of performance and economy with its series of boxer engines, but a few small grievances prevent it from getting top marks. The base 2.5-liter 4-cylinder can be matched with a 6-speed manual or a CVT in the 2.5i and 2.5i Premium, but move above that, and you’re stuck with the uninspired CVT. Not that the manual is perfect, either. The Forester I spent a week with came with the CVT, but I’ve driven the 6-speed as well, and while long throws and slight sloppiness keep it from inclusion on any best-of lists, it’s a great way to wring all the potential power out of the 2.5 and make that anemic engine a bit more fun.
But with only 170 hp and 174 lb-ft of torque, that fun is limited. Sadly this is made even worse with the 6-speed, where higher revs make the engine sound like it's really struggling. Harsh is the word here, and that’s a big penalty to pay when it takes 9 seconds to get to 60 mph. But on the bright side, the CVT will reward you with 24 mpg city/32 highway, while the 6-speed can manage only 22/29. For more power, the turbocharged 2.0XT comes with a 250-hp 2.0-liter engine with 258 lb-ft of torque. Even with the lackluster CVT, this engine provides plenty of power and can motivate the 3,300-pound Forester to 60 mph in just over 6 seconds. Sadly, it has a relatively low tow rating of just 1,500 pounds, a figure shared with the base Forester. But it doesn’t come with the expected fuel penalty and still manages a claimed 23/28 rating, though those numbers have been difficult to reproduce in real-world testing. My time with the Forester failed to replicate its claimed 27 combined rating, and my averages were most often in the lower-to-mid 20s.
Still, the Forester offered a nimble, agile suspension that was light enough for city and parking duty yet capable enough to tackle more aggressive terrain. All-wheel drive (AWD) kept things balanced, and the extra length in the wheelbase gained during the last redesign offered a composed ride even at highway speeds. Steering feel isn’t the most engaging in the industry, but I also encountered none of the vagueness or unpredictable modulation I’ve found with other electric setups. The Forester offers a good balance for a reliable family and grocery hauler.
Form and Function
When the Forester debuted back in 1997, Subaru was still an underdog offering more performance than most people recognized. Now that Subaru has become synonymous with rally racing, the Forester has actually lost some of that edge. Yet it still remains the competent commuter with some off-road prowess it was always meant to be. Outside, this story is obvious. The current generation looks like someone blended the old Forester with a second-generation Escape—edges are softer, and the profile is somehow more generic. It’s not bad, it’s just not as recognizably Subaru.
Inside, the cabin is awash in hard surfaces. The bulk of my time in Subarus was spent in the early 2000s, and this looks only a generation ahead of those plastic landscapes. The fact that so many have praised Subaru for the interior improvements of late only speaks to how bad they used to be. Of particular annoyance was a persistent rattle coming from the panoramic moonroof, situated frustratingly above my right ear. That said, it was a problem Subaru was eager to fix, and I absolutely love all the extra light you get inside with this feature. It's a must-have option in my opinion.
Faux aluminum accents are made worse with a “brushed applique” added to the door handles, and I worry about wear. A nice steering wheel is only slightly crowded with too many buttons, but it’s nice to look through the gap to see a simple, dual-gauge setup with a single info screen in the middle. Switches are nicely damped if a bit outdated, especially on the stereo, which is perhaps the worst offender of the “looks like it was sourced from a 10-year-old parts bin” group.
Seats look quite nice and fold flat in the rear with a one-touch mechanism for a full 68.5 cubic feet of space (74.7 in trims without the panoramic moonroof), but tend to feel a bit flat, especially if you try and test the AWD with some spirited cornering. Leg bolsters are the big issue here, as they squish like an overripe avocado rather than supporting like a compassionate spouse. That said, they weren’t uncomfortable and handled longer rides without fatigue.
Tech is one area where the Forester truly lags behind the competition. While every Forester now comes with a standard backup camera—just added for 2015—the screen on which it displays is one of the smallest, lowest-resolution setups in the industry at 4.3 inches. The sight of it in the dashboard was almost comical to some passengers, who likened it to the postage-stamp screens seen on old console televisions. The optional navigation system is $1,100 on top of the mandatory All-Weather and EyeSight packages ($1,295), and it’s simply dreadful. Luckily you don’t have to buy it, and even better, my example didn’t come with it, but I have been frustrated by this system in the past. If you do check the box, you’ll get a 6.1-inch touchscreen slotted into the stereo space, and you’ll spend most of your time cursing at its lag and poor resolution.
However I did get to test out the EyeSight system, which was included here (at a $500 discount for 2015) along with the All-Weather Package. It adds driver safety aids like pre-collision braking, adaptive cruise, lane-departure and sway warnings, as well as a pre-collision throttle-management system, all designed to prevent an accident before it happens. Subaru warns that this is an optical rather than a radar system, utilizing 2 cameras on the back of the rear-view mirror. Because of this, low-visibility situations may cause the system to disengage—things like fog, snow, rain—basically the times you’d need it most. I didn’t encounter a lot of that driving around Oakland, but the system frequently shut off in direct sunlight during my week with the Forester, and that just seems unforgivable. So basically you’re left with a system you can rely on only during cloudy days where it’s not foggy, raining, or snowing.
There are other little issues as well, some more confusing than frustrating. There’s an SD-card slot, but it can be used only for providing the navigation system with map data. Why even include it? You can get satellite radio, but the screen won’t display a list of the stations you can select. Strange.
If there’s one area in which the Forester excels, it’s safety. An IIHS Top Pick, the Forester delivers standard safety features like Surabu's lauded symmetrical AWD system, antilock discs, traction and stability control, and an impressive list of airbags including front pelvis/torso, side-curtain, and driver's knee airbags. Add the EyeSight system and you’ll get all the avoidance features mentioned above, with the braking system getting special recognition from the IIHS with a rating of Superior.
The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration had similar things to say, awarding the Forester a 5-star rating, with only front impacts getting a 4-star score. Braking distance from 60 mph is average for the class, floating between 120-125 feet depending on trim, and honestly a figure I’d like to see Subaru (and all manufacturers) concentrate on dropping in the future.
Let me start by saying this, because it warrants mentioning: Kelley Blue Book has named Subaru the brand with the highest resale value and lowest cost to own for 2015.
Among competitors, pricing is right in line with that of the Escape, CX-5, and CR-V. The CX-5 and the Escape offer a more engaging ride, though you’ll have to pay a little extra for AWD. But you’ll also get better mileage with the CX-5 and the CR-V, and much better tech and interiors in anything you choose. With that in mind, it’s really going to come down to feel. Some people still aren’t used to the unique character of a boxer engine, so drive them all and see which seems most livable to you.
A CarGurus contributor since 2008, Michael started his career writing about cars with the SCCA - winning awards during his time as editor of Top End magazine. Since then, his journalistic travels have taken him from NY to Boston to CA, completing a cross-country tour on a restored vintage Suzuki. While his preference is for fine German automobiles - and the extra leg room they so often afford - his first automobile memories center around impromptu Mustang vs. Corvette races down the local highway, in the backseat of his father's latest acquisition.
What's your take on the 2015 Subaru Forester?
2015 Subaru Forester Top Comparisons
Users ranked 2015 Subaru Forester against other cars which they drove/owned. Each ranking was based on 9 categories. Here is the summary of top rankings.
Cars compared to 2015 Subaru Forester
Looking for a Used Forester in your area?
CarGurus has 30,455 nationwide Forester listings starting at $650.
Subaru Forester Questions
Subaru Forester AC Quits When Idling.
The AC works correctly out on the road (dealer fixed refrigerant leak under warranty). AC quits working and the compressor will not turn on for several minutes or longer after idling in a take out ...
2015 Forester Key Fob Battery
Where is the battery in the 2015 Key Fob?
When Should I Change Oil
change oil how many miles
How Does Your New Subaru's AC Work?
My AC works fine on flat ground but when climbing hills it blows put hot air instead of cold. Even accelerating on flat ground causes the air temperature to rise immediately. The more throttle you ...
XT Forester Stalls While Driving
My new 2litre XT Premium Forester sometimes just turns its engine off while I'm driving it - happened 10 times now - dealer has fitted a recorder - not conclusive - Fair Trading says - leave it to the...
- 2.0XT Premium
- Avg. Price: $20,960
- 2.0XT Touring
- Avg. Price: $23,327
- Avg. Price: $17,887
- 2.5i Convenience
- 2.5i Limited
- Avg. Price: $20,668
- 2.5i Premium
- Avg. Price: $19,099
- 2.5i Touring
- Avg. Price: $22,151
Subaru Forester Experts