Premium Fuel vs. Regular Fuel question and Vehicle Dynamic Control question

SharonD
30

Asked by SharonD Sep 22, 2008 at 07:39 PM about the Nissan Altima Coupe

Question type: Shopping & Pricing

I'm planning on getting a Nissan Altima Coupe this year.  It will be either the 2.5 or 3.5SE with Premium package.

I know the V6 (3.5 SE) indicates in requires Premium fuel. What is the impact if I do Premium every other fill up or less (just fill with Special or Regular)?

The 2009's require Tech package to get VDC (Vehicle Dynamic Control) but the 2008's did not.  Does one really need VDC, what does it gain one?

13 Answers

Daniel McGreal
65

If you start out by putting regular and continue to put only regular in you'll be fine. Higher octane fuel is just recommended because it helps to prevent the engine knocking/engine pinging in high performance engines. So you could use regular and be fine cause it would adjust to that. However, if you went from premium to regular it would mess with the engine and you would just damage it over time.

2 out of 2 people think this is helpful.
Michael McGrail
5,295

As long as the 3.5L is not forced induction, using reg unl fuel is ok. The computer is able to compensate and retard timing to correct any detonation issues caused by using lower octane fuel giving the engine is not forced induced.

2 out of 2 people think this is helpful.
Adam Morgan
4,085

The vehicle has a 10.3 to1 compression ratio... On the lower end of high compression motors... My geuss is that they the engine with a fairly advanced timing curve in order to recomend higher octane fuel. Likely the car will retard the timing in order to prevent engine damage, however you'll likely loose both power and efficiency using cheaper fuel, negateing the minuscule savings of running regular... I believe the '09 is suppose to get 21 mpg... so lets say using regular losses you a barely noticeable 1.5 mpg due to a retarded timing curve.... so 92.86% of normal engine efficiency... We'll say base line cost is 3.70 per gal... so premium we'll say is 4.00 even... regular is 92.5% the price... 0.36% diffrence between loss of mileage and cost savings between useing premium and regular. If you have a station nearby that still does 10 cent increments between grades instead of 15 cent ones it would be cheaper to use premium... at best you're saving 2 cents per gallon, so why bother? This is negating the fact that even with a retarded timing you may experience occasional pre-detonation which would prematurely wear the engine, and that premium fuel usually has more detergents added to keep your engine clean. Long story short... Just get the premium, there is almost no noticable change in cost to you between premium and regular, even if your car didn't loose efficiency, if it didn't it'd be more likely to ping resulting in wear and damage, it's only a few dollars per tank. I mean do you really think the manufacturer puts that rating on there for fun? It's not like it helps sell cars...

4 out of 4 people think this is helpful.
SharonD
30

Thanks for the info. I'm in Florida. Gas here right now is @3.87/gallon Regular, @4.20/gallon Premium. Also, what do you think about Dynamic Vehicle Control? The 2009 requires Tech package to get it. What does it gain me?

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.
Neil Haupt
205

VDC is a safety feature and keeps the car under control. It doesn't really give you performance gains. When it's on, it controls the brakes and the throttle. So, for example, if you're taking a turn too fast, it will apply a little bit of the brakes so you don't lose control of the car. If you're accelerating too hard while the car is in a turn, it will reduce the amount of throttle that is available to you. From what I've read, it's very subtle and you won't notice it too much...unless you're going WAY too fast and/or jerk the steering wheel suddenly, at which point the car might not have time to react and save your crazy ass. :D

2 out of 2 people think this is helpful.
Tom Zhang
50

I don't know about the fuel mileage thing, but if you're strapped for cash at one fill-up, using regular should be fine, the engine will just retard the timing (to the best of my knowledge) Also, VDC really isn't needed because the car tends toward nice, safe understeer anyway. However, if you tend to drive crazy fast and/or in slippery conditions, I'd say VDC would be helpful.

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.
Emilio Berkeley Jr.
105

what ive learned is that if you use regular that u jave to use fuel injector cleaner and u can buy that anywhere and that will do just about the same as using premium. most cars say use premium bc all it has is the cleaner and other cleaners but i think its cheaper to buy these cleaners ur self instead of using premium everytime and u dont have to use the cleaners everytime u can use them every other fill up or 3000-30000 miles for some.

2 out of 2 people think this is helpful.
Adam Morgan
4,085

The cleaners are just an added benefit mate. engineers don't take those into account since not all stations have added detergents in the premium fuels. It is there for one of two reasons... An advanced timing curve where more controllable spark propagation is necessary or in a high pressure (forced induction or high compression motor) where the pressure can cause the fuel charge to detonate prematurely resulting in excess wear and potentially engine damage.

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.
Joe Braccia
65

it wont damage the engine by putting regular if its supposed to take premium. thats one of the reasons that cars have computers on them, to help manage the engine and adjust for the octane provided. my car is supposed to take prremium but for 4 years it ran on middle. onlyh this year i started putting premium in it and its fine because the computer adjusted for it.

2 out of 2 people think this is helpful.
Daniel McGreal
65

I wasn't saying it would damage the engine. I stated that it may cause detonation to occur. I also said it may happen if you went from premium to regular not the opposite way around. I am indeed aware of the fact that the computers in a car are there to help it adjust for lower octane. The chances simply increase a tad that something may happen in the event you go from premium to regular.

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.
SharonD
30

A friend here at work indicates if the manual indicates Premium and I use Regular, it could void the engine warranty. Can that happen?

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.
Adam Morgan
4,085

It depends on the component... For example if any part of your fuel system goes out they can't blame the fuel since there is no correlation between octane level and wear on fuel components... Bad news is they can say it caused knock and void warranty on your rotating assembly, all relevant bearings, the valve train, head gasket, cams, and any related mechanical systems. They can only void warranty on related parts, that would have been affected by the use of low grade fuel. IE anything that would undergo excess strain when the engine pings... (sorry I realize I kinda flip flop pinging=pre-detonation=knock... although knock is usually misleading so I'll try to stick to one of the first too)) It'd take a real super prick to check your gas tank if the head gasket blew though. There really isn't much of a cost variance though, so you should only use it once in a blue moon anyway and then you should never get a full tank, just enough to get to the next time you have $3-5 more to get a tank of premium... It's really not much more expensive, so why is it an issue. A more relevant and costly question would be the regular maintenance schedule? Does the engine require synthetic over regular oil due to thermal properties? How often must the coolant be flushed? Will I have to deal with a transmission flush, if so how often? All these are worth more time than worrying about if you can put regular in... You talking of spending thousands of dollars on the car, but not being willing to spend a few buck more a week.

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.
SharonD
30

Thank you all for your GREAT input. Currently, I drive a 2002 Saturn SC1 coupe (bought in Oct 2001) and plan on getting the Altima coupe (probably the V6, Premium package)in October/November. To be on safe side, I'll do the Premium gas. Like a friend said "Penny Wise can be Pound Foolish", i.e. trying to pinch pennies can, in long run, be detrimental. This is a GREAT forum / website!

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

Altima Coupe
Looking for a Used Altima Coupe in your area?
CarGurus has 2,929 nationwide Altima Coupe listings starting at $6,790.
ZIP:

Search Nissan Altima Coupe Questions

Nissan Altima Coupe Experts

#1 Racer_X
Racer_X
Reputation 60
#1 Adam Morgan
Adam Morgan
Reputation 60
#3 engloveuab
engloveuab
Reputation 30
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used Nissan Altima"
1,995 Great Deals out of 73,042 listings starting at $1,000
Used Honda Accord Coupe"
240 Great Deals out of 8,152 listings starting at $5,900
Used Nissan Maxima"
691 Great Deals out of 19,329 listings starting at $946
Used Honda Civic Coupe"
256 Great Deals out of 8,105 listings starting at $5,495
Used Infiniti G35"
190 Great Deals out of 3,675 listings starting at $3,495
Used Nissan 350Z"
126 Great Deals out of 1,714 listings starting at $3,600
Used Ford Mustang"
1,073 Great Deals out of 23,464 listings starting at $950
Used Honda Accord"
1,444 Great Deals out of 66,644 listings starting at $995
Used Infiniti G37"
414 Great Deals out of 7,193 listings starting at $10,400
Used Toyota Camry"
2,020 Great Deals out of 75,810 listings starting at $1,007
Used Hyundai Genesis Coupe"
82 Great Deals out of 3,856 listings starting at $10,697
Used Scion tC"
196 Great Deals out of 6,717 listings starting at $3,250
Used Honda Civic"
922 Great Deals out of 49,340 listings starting at $1,600
Used Chevrolet Camaro"
668 Great Deals out of 28,070 listings starting at $2,399
Used Nissan 370Z"
54 Great Deals out of 2,378 listings starting at $15,994