Used Ferrari 458 Italia for Sale in New York, NY

New Search

Filter Results

listing

Price

- Loading...

Mileage

- Loading...

Days on Market

- Loading...

Recent Listings

Vehicle History

Vehicle history data provided by Experian AutoCheck. This data, and any reliance on it, is subject to the AutoCheck Terms and Conditions and the CarGurus Terms of Use
Hide vehicles with:

Photos

Price Drops

Text Search

Nationwide Shipping

Add Similar Cars


2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Review
by Jonathan

Excellent car

This car is an awesome piece of engineering marvel. Hands down the best performing car I have ever had the pleasure of driving. It is fun to drive whether you are going 5MPH or 100+MPH. The ride quality is unrivaled in my opinion. Would love to own one of these one day.

First Previous
Loading...
Next
Featured Listings
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/09/02/03/35/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-504954234107292449-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Great Neck, NY 11021

Great Deal
$21,923 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $194,918

Price: $172,995

Mileage: 36,860

Location: Great Neck, NY 11021

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Yellow Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $172,995, 36,860 miles with Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (60 reviews) "Fantastic "
https://static1.cargurus.com/gfx/cg/noImageAvailable_150x113.png

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Used Cars in Spring Valley, NY 10977

Great Deal
$25,959 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $216,209

Price: $190,250

Mileage: 10,832

Location: Spring Valley, NY 10977

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 7-Speed Manual Color: Bianco Avus Description: Used 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia for sale - $190,250, 10,832 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (27 reviews) "phone conversation informative from dealer. thank you "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/12/06/07/08/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-8628464846159727844-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Plainview, NY 11803

Great Deal
$16,222 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $231,122

Price: $214,900

Mileage: 5,351

Location: Plainview, NY 11803

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Blue Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $214,900, 5,351 miles with Bluetooth, Leather Seats, Aluminum Wheels, Navigation System
Avg. Dealer Rating: (26 reviews) "Fair price for car as represented. "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/08/18/04/29/2013_ferrari_458_italia-pic-6133593300741448158-152x114.jpeg

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Greenwich, CT 06830

Great Deal
$12,067 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $211,967

Price: $199,900

Mileage: 4,950

Location: Greenwich, CT 06830

Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Automatic Color: Blu Tour De France Description: Used 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $199,900, 4,950 miles with Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (22 reviews) "Alex is the best salesman I've ever worked with period! His patience, professionalism, and knowledge are unmatched! For sure a major asset to miller motor cars!!!"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/07/23/06/37/2014_ferrari_458_italia-pic-5336800020490988122-152x114.jpeg

2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Plainview, NY 11803

Good Deal
$9,380 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $239,280

Price: $229,900

Mileage: 9,326

Location: Plainview, NY 11803

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: White Description: Used 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $229,900, 9,326 miles with Bluetooth, Leather Seats, Aluminum Wheels, Navigation System
Avg. Dealer Rating: (26 reviews) "reached out to answer any and all questions."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/09/01/18/34/2014_ferrari_458_italia-pic-4615674652451493215-152x114.jpeg

2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Plainview, NY 11803

Good Deal
$7,513 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $227,413

Price: $219,900

Mileage: 4,741

Location: Plainview, NY 11803

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Black Description: Used 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $219,900, 4,741 miles with Bluetooth, Leather Seats, Aluminum Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (26 reviews) "Salesman, Kevin, had been on top of everything and very professional. "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/07/27/11/56/2011_ferrari_458_italia-pic-6765857273299764353-152x114.jpeg

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Greenwich, CT 06830

Good Deal
$8,370 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $188,270

Price: $179,900

Mileage: 8,329

Location: Greenwich, CT 06830

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Rosso Corsa Description: Used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $179,900, 8,329 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (22 reviews) "Great guys and a great selection of vehicles"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/09/02/12/36/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-6629499134476475379-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Spring Valley, NY 10977

Good Deal
$6,319 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $204,819

Price: $198,500

Mileage: 5,904

Location: Spring Valley, NY 10977

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 7-Speed Manual Color: Giallo Modena Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $198,500, 5,904 miles with Bluetooth, Leather Seats, Navigation System, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (5 reviews) "Very quick reply with detailed information."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/09/11/16/03/2013_ferrari_458_italia_convertible-pic-8797199614315936211-152x114.jpeg

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in New York, 10014

Good Deal
$9,200 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $239,200

Price: $230,000

Mileage: 7,500

Location: New York, 10014

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 7-Speed Automatic Color: Silver Description: Used 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $230,000, 7,500 miles with Navigation System, Leather Seats, Backup Camera
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/08/18/06/41/2013_ferrari_458_italia-pic-3727483342044076763-152x114.jpeg

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Plainview, NY 11803

Good Deal
$4,891 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $238,791

Price: $233,900

Mileage: 3,037

Location: Plainview, NY 11803

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Black Description: Used 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $233,900, 3,037 miles with Bluetooth, Leather Seats, Aluminum Wheels, Navigation System
Avg. Dealer Rating: (26 reviews) "Justin is a gentleman "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/07/29/09/39/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-8055194520895602326-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Huntington Station, NY 11746

Good Deal
$5,056 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $203,044

Price: $197,988

Mileage: 6,635

Location: Huntington Station, NY 11746

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 7-Speed Automatic Color: Red Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $197,988, 6,635 miles with Bluetooth, Aluminum Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (3 reviews) "They were very helpful"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/09/15/06/42/2013_ferrari_458_italia-pic-8439702140957614752-152x114.jpeg

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Plainview, NY 11803

Fair Deal
$4,205 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $212,105

Price: $207,900

Mileage: 4,863

Location: Plainview, NY 11803

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Red Description: Used 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $207,900, 4,863 miles with Bluetooth, Leather Seats, Aluminum Wheels, Navigation System
Avg. Dealer Rating: (26 reviews) "Very professional approach. Lots of timely interaction in a short span. My correspondant, Greg Choute, was personable and competent. Car was spotless. Great customer service. Didn't take the car as it wasn't as practical as I thought it would be for my wife. But definitely felt comfortable with my interaction. "
https://static1.cargurus.com/gfx/cg/noImageAvailable_150x113.png

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Spring Valley, NY 10977

Fair Deal
$4,137 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $202,637

Price: $198,500

Mileage: 11,207

Location: Spring Valley, NY 10977

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 7-Speed Manual Description: Used 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $198,500, 11,207 miles with Leather Seats, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (5 reviews) "The whole group that I work with are incredible."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/08/02/15/16/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-4886588412417204049-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Greenwich, CT 06830

Fair Deal
$2,009 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $229,909

Price: $227,900

Mileage: 6,386

Location: Greenwich, CT 06830

Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Automatic Color: Nero Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $227,900, 6,386 miles with Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (22 reviews) "It was rather pleasurable, but the car was priced $30K over general market and I had to pass."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2017/09/06/18/01/2013_ferrari_458_italia-pic-2557972181757501477-152x114.jpeg

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Spring Valley, NY 10977

Fair Deal
$1,402 BELOW
CarGurus IMV of $226,752

Price: $225,350

Mileage: 5,993

Location: Spring Valley, NY 10977

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 7-Speed Manual Description: Used 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $225,350, 5,993 miles with Leather Seats, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (5 reviews) "By good chance, the first person I talked to was Marty Field-24 hours later I purchased my first Ferrari from him. The manager welcomed me to the Ferrari 'family' and the service manager and I discussed the F1 season. They arranged financing, registration, taxes, title...etc. A few days later they unloaded a gorgeous 458 Spider at my front door ready to go. Marty has checked in a few times just to see how everything is going. I am happy to be a member of the Wide World family."
Please wait ...
All Listings
Please wait ...
Featured Listing
First Previous
Page # of #
Next

Filter your search criteria!

A large number of listings matched your criteria. You are seeing the top 2,000 listings.

Used Ferrari 458 Italia By Year

Vehicle Deals Starting Price Total Available
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia 2 Great Deals $220,520 66 listings
2014 Ferrari 458 Italia 5 Great Deals $199,999 68 listings
2013 Ferrari 458 Italia 3 Great Deals $189,946 77 listings