Used Ferrari 458 Italia for Sale in New York, NY

New Search

Filter Results

listing

Price

- Loading...

Mileage

- Loading...

Dealer Promotions

Days on Market

- Loading...

Accidents Reported

Photos

Text Search

Price Drops

Add Similar Cars


CarGurus Quick Poll

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Review
by Jonathan

Excellent car

This car is an awesome piece of engineering marvel. Hands down the best performing car I have ever had the pleasure of driving. It is fun to drive whether you are going 5MPH or 100+MPH. The ride quality is unrivaled in my opinion. Would love to own one of these one day.

First Previous
Loading...
Next
Featured Listings
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/09/24/13/51/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-949046006313947169-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Larchmont, NY 10538

Great Deal
$21,835 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $213,293

Price: $191,458

Mileage: 8,417

Location: Larchmont, NY 10538

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 7-Speed Automatic Color: Blu Pozzi Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $191,458, 8,417 miles with Navigation System, Leather Seats, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (7 reviews) "Karina, the Porsche Brand Ambassador, reached out to me within the same day as my inquiry. I have not yet seen the car, but am planning to go and take a look at it."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/07/14/00/45/2010_ferrari_458_italia-pic-2793359600233596909-152x114.jpeg

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base Used Cars in Teterboro, NJ 07608

Good Deal
$15,182 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $183,177

Price: $167,995

Mileage: 17,516

Location: Teterboro, NJ 07608

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 7-Speed Automatic Color: Nero Description: Used 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base for sale - $167,995, 17,516 miles with Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (99 reviews) "Resonsive and honest. "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/09/24/06/12/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-1219744014531487109-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Syosset, NY 11791

Good Deal
$10,304 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $245,804

Price: $235,500

Mileage: 5,051

Location: Syosset, NY 11791

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Blu Pozzi Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $235,500, 5,051 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (15 reviews) "They did respond quickly advising me that I would be contacted. So far no contact from them. Another car is on my radar now."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/05/24/13/11/2013_ferrari_458_italia-pic-4974623110882881401-152x114.jpeg

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Spring Valley, NY 10977

Good Deal
$9,314 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $259,214

Price: $249,900

Mileage: 5,758

Location: Spring Valley, NY 10977

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Rosso Corsa Description: Used 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $249,900, 5,758 miles with Bluetooth, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (2 reviews) "Very responsive. Great to work with. Ask for Justin!"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/07/22/03/37/2013_ferrari_458_italia-pic-8528904386775902097-152x114.jpeg

2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Spring Valley, NY 10977

Good Deal
$8,607 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $238,507

Price: $229,900

Mileage: 13,900

Location: Spring Valley, NY 10977

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Rosso Corsa Description: Used 2013 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $229,900, 13,900 miles with Bluetooth, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (2 reviews) "Prompt response, very courteous very efficient"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/07/29/21/28/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-1628728061528878340-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Greenwich, CT 06830

Good Deal
$6,803 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $251,703

Price: $244,900

Mileage: 6,386

Location: Greenwich, CT 06830

Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Automatic Color: Nero Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $244,900, 6,386 miles with Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (11 reviews) "Called and followed up. My interest had changed"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/09/26/17/23/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-9160272896906855156-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Great Neck, NY 11021

Good Deal
$8,781 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $208,776

Price: $199,995

Mileage: 36,860

Location: Great Neck, NY 11021

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Yellow Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $199,995, 36,860 miles with Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (28 reviews) "Dealer response twice, unfortunately I've not decided yet when I can make the trip to the dealer."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/06/25/20/55/2014_ferrari_458_italia-pic-9138367149316206227-152x114.jpeg

2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Plainview, NY 11803

Good Deal
$6,493 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $276,393

Price: $269,900

Mileage: 2,931

Location: Plainview, NY 11803

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Red Description: Used 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $269,900, 2,931 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (18 reviews) "Excellent ! Responsive "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/08/13/08/47/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-6416915483649727869-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Plainview, NY 11803

Fair Deal
$5,046 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $247,946

Price: $242,900

Mileage: 9,053

Location: Plainview, NY 11803

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Black Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $242,900, 9,053 miles with Navigation System, Bluetooth, Leather Seats
Avg. Dealer Rating: (18 reviews) "Excellent"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/08/17/20/53/2011_ferrari_458_italia-pic-8106452522389007982-152x114.jpeg

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Plainview, NY 11803

Fair Deal
$6,697 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $206,597

Price: $199,900

Mileage: 6,873

Location: Plainview, NY 11803

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Bl Description: Used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $199,900, 6,873 miles with Navigation System, Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (18 reviews) "Excellent"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/09/13/21/03/2010_ferrari_458_italia-pic-8663175754683421138-152x114.jpeg

2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base Used Cars in Greenwich, CT 06830

Fair Deal
$4,389 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $194,289

Price: $189,900

Mileage: 8,823

Location: Greenwich, CT 06830

Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Automatic Color: Blu Pozzi Description: Used 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia Base for sale - $189,900, 8,823 miles with Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (11 reviews) "First class immediate responce"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/08/09/16/16/2011_ferrari_458_italia-pic-6533278490888228917-152x114.jpeg

2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Greenwich, CT 06830

Fair Deal
$5,653 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $211,553

Price: $205,900

Mileage: 3,225

Location: Greenwich, CT 06830

Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Automatic Color: Giallo Modena Description: Used 2011 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $205,900, 3,225 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (11 reviews) "It was a good experience talking with them."
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/03/13/06/43/2005_ferrari_superamerica-pic-4564588137813099191-152x114.jpeg

2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible Used Cars in Plainview, NY 11803

Fair Deal
$1,669 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $291,569

Price: $289,900

Mileage: 865

Location: Plainview, NY 11803

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Red Description: Used 2015 Ferrari 458 Italia Convertible for sale - $289,900, 865 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (18 reviews) "quick reply"
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/09/21/04/52/2012_ferrari_458_italia-pic-6334770761593451687-152x114.jpeg

2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Spring Valley, NY 10977

Fair Deal
$1,000 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $223,900

Price: $222,900

Mileage: 3,815

Location: Spring Valley, NY 10977

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Nero Description: Used 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $222,900, 3,815 miles with Bluetooth, Alloy Wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (2 reviews) "Awesome experience... Customer service was great...knowledgeable, friendly, experienced. "
https://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2016/05/31/20/36/2014_ferrari_458_italia-pic-7016022919126327461-152x114.jpeg

2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe Used Cars in Greenwich, CT 06830

Fair Deal
$1,071 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $238,971

Price: $237,900

Mileage: 2,905

Location: Greenwich, CT 06830

Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Automatic Color: Grigio Titanio Description: Used 2014 Ferrari 458 Italia Coupe for sale - $237,900, 2,905 miles with Bluetooth
Avg. Dealer Rating: (11 reviews) "Quick response. I have purchased an Aston Martin from them previously and they are a top notch dealer."
Please wait ...
All Listings
Please wait ...
Featured Listing
First Previous
Page # of #
Next

Filter your search criteria!

A large number of listings matched your criteria. You are seeing the top 2,000 listings.

Used Ferrari 458 Italia By Year

Vehicle Deals Starting Price Total Available
2015 Ferrari 458 Italia 3 Great Deals $238,895 67 listings
2014 Ferrari 458 Italia 3 Great Deals $219,000 62 listings
2013 Ferrari 458 Italia 3 Great Deals $205,000 77 listings
2012 Ferrari 458 Italia 4 Great Deals $179,000 62 listings
2011 Ferrari 458 Italia - $172,751 51 listings