Used 2021 Tesla Model Y for Sale near New York, NY

## Summary - With 2,295 currently listed for sale on CarGurus and an **average price of $24,847.00**, 24.7% of 2021 Tesla Model Ys for sale on CarGurus are rated as good or great deals. - **Favorably reviewed:** Owners rated the 2021 Tesla Model Y 4.75 / 5 stars. - **83.1% of 2021 Model Y models on CarGurus are accident free.** - The 2021 Tesla Model Y stands out for its electric powertrain, advanced technology features, and enjoyable driving dynamics, appealing particularly to environmentally conscious buyers. ## Why it stands out The 2021 Tesla Model Y marks a significant entry into the compact SUV segment of electric vehicles, effectively combining the practicality of an SUV with the cutting-edge technology expected from Tesla. This model benefits from a robust electric performance, with many owners highlighting its enjoyable driving dynamics and substantial electric range—attributes that set it apart in the growing EV market. Moreover, the advanced tech interface, which includes features like over-the-air updates and a high-tech infotainment system, adds to its appeal. While some buyers might find the car's price steep and notice a learning curve associated with its digital controls, the overall enthusiasm from owners conveys that the driving experience and eco-friendliness more than make up for these concerns. ## Other model years to consider - **[2022 Tesla Model Y](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2022-Tesla-Model-Y-c32066)** - Average price: $27,740.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 23.1% - User rating: 4.58 / 5 - Total listings: 3,120 - **[2020 Tesla Model Y](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2020-Tesla-Model-Y-c30278)** - Average price: $23,399.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 25.5% - User rating: 4.56 / 5 - Total listings: 1,290 - **[2023 Tesla Model Y](https://www.cargurus.com/Cars/l-Used-2023-Tesla-Model-Y-c32549)** - Average price: $30,722.00 - Good/great deal percentage: 20.7% - User rating: 4.25 / 5 - Total listings: 2,569 This analysis is based on CarGurus' proprietary market data from February 16, 2026, CarGurus experts' opinions, and generative AI.