Used Subaru Legacy in Indianapolis, IN

New Search

Filter Results

listings

Price

- Loading...

Mileage

- Loading...

Accidents Reported

Photos

Text Search

Price Drops

Add Similar Cars

CarGurus Quick Poll

Why buy used?

4,129 new Subaru Legacy listings
2009 Subaru Legacy 2.5 i Limited Review
by Scott

Good car, good gas mileage, good handling but I wish it was a GT.

Great car, lovely interior, and decent acceleration for a 4 cyl. Its sort of sluggish off the line if you really don't punch it, and the car sounds great when you're 4000 and higher in the RPM range. Revving to 8000 easily, but I really don't recommend it because it drinks some fuel when that happens due to it not being a performance engine.

First Previous
Loading...
Next
Featured Listings
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/11/17/08/53/2012_subaru_legacy-pic-2338964496460042414-152x114.jpeg

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Indianapolis, IN 46254

Great Deal
$2,800 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $14,795

Price: $11,995

Mileage: 92,358

Location: Indianapolis, IN 46254

Average time on market: 24 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Maroon Description: Used 2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $11,995, 92,358 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (7 reviews) "Very rude, the salesman could not get off the phone fast enough. I drove up there anyway because of the lack of information given on the phone, the pictures posted online were very deceiving. The vehicle was in poor condition but described to be great. Will not be returning to this "dealership". "
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/03/16/21/00/2014_subaru_legacy-pic-8423388785227820400-152x114.jpeg

2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Indianapolis, IN 46240

Great Deal
$2,618 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $22,411

Price: $19,793

Mileage: 23,897

Location: Indianapolis, IN 46240

Average time on market: 52 days Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Tungsten Description: Used 2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $19,793, 23,897 miles with option.display_name.sunroof_moonroof
Avg. Dealer Rating: (13 reviews) "Polite but took to long to respond I had to call 3 times to get a reply."
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/02/05/07/35/2012_subaru_legacy-pic-4148382767348859979-152x114.jpeg

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Fishers, IN 46037

Great Deal
$2,146 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $14,741

Price: $12,595

Mileage: 93,239

Location: Fishers, IN 46037

Average time on market: 24 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Silver Description: Used 2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $12,595, 93,239 miles with option.display_name.bluetooth, option.display_name.alloy_wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (1 review) "Laid back dealer. Easy to work with and eager to please."
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/02/02/11/59/2013_subaru_legacy-pic-6543737120159145281-152x114.jpeg

2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Indianapolis, IN 46254

Great Deal
$2,389 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $20,941

Price: $18,552

Mileage: 15,263

Location: Indianapolis, IN 46254

Average time on market: 29 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Satin White Pearl Description: Used 2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $18,552, 15,263 miles with option.display_name.alloy_wheels
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/04/14/20/52/2013_subaru_legacy-pic-754085313400806481-152x114.jpeg

2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Indianapolis, IN 46240

Great Deal
$2,167 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $19,100

Price: $16,933

Mileage: 40,191

Location: Indianapolis, IN 46240

Average time on market: 29 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 1-Speed CVT Color: White Description: Used 2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $16,933, 40,191 miles with option.display_name.bluetooth, option.display_name.aluminum_wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (17 reviews) "Started off very helpful, when I told them my credit was less then perfect (640) they stopped responding all together! Went to Bob Poynter and got a great car at a great interest rate! "
http://static1.cargurus.com/gfx/cg/noImageAvailable_150x113.png

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Greenwood, IN 46143

Great Deal
$1,597 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $18,597

Price: $17,000

Mileage: 29,840

Location: Greenwood, IN 46143

Average time on market: 24 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Crystal Black Silica Description: Used 2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $17,000, 29,840 miles with option.display_name.bluetooth, option.display_name.sunroof_moonroof, option.display_name.aluminum_wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (13 reviews) "Deceiving pictures and waste of time."
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/02/27/01/14/2012_subaru_legacy-pic-1653323412410632253-152x114.jpeg

2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited Used Cars in Greenwood, IN 46143

Great Deal
$1,755 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $20,655

Price: $18,900

Mileage: 30,980

Location: Greenwood, IN 46143

Average time on market: 28 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Automatic Color: Caramel Bronze Pearl Description: Used 2012 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Limited for sale - $18,900, 30,980 miles with option.display_name.bluetooth, option.display_name.leather_seats, option.display_name.sunroof_moonroof, option.display_name.aluminum_wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (13 reviews) "Overall good experience"
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/03/20/04/30/2005_subaru_legacy-pic-1257210213530150344-152x114.jpeg

2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Used Cars in Noblesville, IN 46060

Good Deal
$1,169 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $9,619

Price: $8,450

Mileage: 84,056

Location: Noblesville, IN 46060

Average time on market: 16 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic Color: White Description: Used 2005 Subaru Legacy 2.5i for sale - $8,450, 84,056 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (21 reviews) "Very easy going guys to work with. This was my first solo car buying experience and it went more smoothly than I could have imagined. Thanks again guys!"
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/01/22/03/28/2010_subaru_legacy-pic-3341576391777999882-152x114.jpeg

2010 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Used Cars in Fishers, IN 46038

Good Deal
$1,229 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $15,129

Price: $13,900

Mileage: 50,736

Location: Fishers, IN 46038

Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 5-Speed Automatic Color: Tan Description: Used 2010 Subaru Legacy 2.5i for sale - $13,900, 50,736 miles with option.display_name.steel_wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (11 reviews) "They responded quickley"
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2014/09/07/04/44/2013_subaru_legacy-pic-5252121648914997880-152x114.jpeg

2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Indianapolis, IN 46240

Good Deal
$1,044 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $20,899

Price: $19,855

Mileage: 15,839

Location: Indianapolis, IN 46240

Average time on market: 29 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 1-Speed CVT Color: Gray Description: Used 2013 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $19,855, 15,839 miles with option.display_name.bluetooth, option.display_name.aluminum_wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (17 reviews) "Salesman at Ed Martin Acura was very informative and responsive. We hadn't scheduled an appointment but stopped by while in town to take a look at the vehicle. It was up on a lift in the shop being worked on, but he took us back there to check it out anyways. Bought a different vehicle that was more what we were looking for elsewhere, but don't have anything negative at all to say about our experience."
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/04/22/10/33/2014_subaru_legacy-pic-2966873249198034994-152x114.jpeg

2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Indianapolis, IN 46240

Good Deal
$1,021 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $22,521

Price: $21,500

Mileage: 11,895

Location: Indianapolis, IN 46240

Average time on market: 52 days Certified Pre-Owned: Yes Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Satin White Pearl Description: Used 2014 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $21,500, 11,895 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (13 reviews) "Car was already sent to auction. Two weeks later, the car has never been removed from all the online listings."
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/03/10/10/33/2004_subaru_legacy-pic-155444530941548193-152x114.jpeg

2004 Subaru Legacy L 35th Anniversary Edition Used Cars in Bloomington, IN 47404

Good Deal
$833 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $5,528

Price: $4,695

Mileage: 171,000

Location: Bloomington, IN 47404

Average time on market: 24 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 4-Speed Automatic Color: Silver Description: Used 2004 Subaru Legacy L 35th Anniversary Edition for sale - $4,695, 171,000 miles with option.display_name.sunroof_moonroof
Avg. Dealer Rating: (2 reviews) "Karl literally yelled at me on the phone when I asked if they offered refundable holding deposits on their vehicles since I would be driving from an hour and a half away. I couldn't believe how rudely he was willing to treat a customer. He thought that I had asked him over and over about it, though when I looked back at the emails, I had only asked once about it and he never responded, so I asked again on the phone and got chewed out. And HE ended up hanging up on ME. I am glad I had that conversation with him to keep me from driving all that way and wasting my time on a rude guy."
http://static1.cargurus.com/gfx/cg/noImageAvailable_150x113.png

2006 Subaru Legacy Used Cars in Fishers, IN 46038

Good Deal
$1,117 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $11,617

Price: $10,500

Mileage: 137,269

Location: Fishers, IN 46038

Average time on market: 20 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: 5-Speed Manual Color: Black Description: Used 2006 Subaru Legacy for sale - $10,500, 137,269 miles with option.display_name.navigation_system, option.display_name.sunroof_moonroof, option.display_name.alloy_wheels
Avg. Dealer Rating: (15 reviews) "Did not tell me when car came back from shop and it sold before I could make offer. "
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/04/18/05/57/2011_subaru_legacy-pic-4547066513631667822-152x114.jpeg

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium Used Cars in Plainfield, IN 46168

Good Deal
$768 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $13,326

Price: $12,558

Mileage: 102,718

Location: Plainfield, IN 46168

Average time on market: 29 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Transmission: Continuously Variable Transmission Color: Caramel Bronze Pearl Description: Used 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Premium for sale - $12,558, 102,718 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (8 reviews) "I never heard back from this dealer, but went there and looked at. I was ready to buy. Dealer could care less whether I bought or not. Didn't even try to negotiate or sell me a car. I told them I was ready to buy and they let me walk out the door. Very unimpressed. Lots of cars, lots of inventory, but they are evidently willing to sit on it. The car I wanted to buy had been on CarGurus for almost 200 days. They way they acted, I'm sure they will sit on it for another 200 days. "
http://static.cargurus.com/images/forsale/2015/04/05/10/01/2011_subaru_legacy-pic-7956632814046001231-152x114.jpeg

2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i Used Cars in Indianapolis, IN 46240

Fair Deal
$579 BELOW
Instant Market Value of $17,578

Price: $16,999

Mileage: 31,975

Location: Indianapolis, IN 46240

Average time on market: 32 days Certified Pre-Owned: No Description: Used 2011 Subaru Legacy 2.5i for sale - $16,999, 31,975 miles
Avg. Dealer Rating: (14 reviews) "Excellent"
Please wait ...
All Listings
Please wait ...
Featured Listing
First Previous
Page # of #
Next

Email me price drops and new listings for these results.

You will receive listing updates from CarGurus.com when new listings match your search. Privacy Policy.

Filter your search criteria!

A large number of listings matched your criteria. You are seeing the top listings.

Similar Cars

Subaru Impreza
196 Great Deals out of 10,273 listings starting at $1,495
Subaru Outback
364 Great Deals out of 13,870 listings starting at $1,700
Subaru Impreza WRX
29 Great Deals out of 2,539 listings starting at $15,950

New Subaru Legacy By Year

2015 Subaru Legacy
4,525 listings
2014 Subaru Legacy
781 listings

Used Subaru Legacy By City

Subaru Legacy in Cincinnati OH
3 Great Deals out of 98 listings starting at $5,499
Subaru Legacy in Dayton OH
3 Great Deals out of 103 listings starting at $4,699
Subaru Legacy in Fort Wayne IN
4 Great Deals out of 46 listings starting at $4,995
Subaru Legacy in Louisville KY
4 Great Deals out of 62 listings starting at $5,988
Subaru Legacy in Champaign IL
12 listings starting at $8,995
Subaru Legacy in Evansville IN
2 listings
Subaru Legacy in Lexington KY
5 Great Deals out of 66 listings starting at $9,297
Subaru Legacy in Chicago IL
253 listings starting at $3,500
Subaru Legacy in Columbus OH
39 listings starting at $4,400
Subaru Legacy in Springfield IL
16 Great Deals out of 809 listings starting at $2,794
Subaru Legacy in Toledo OH
3 Great Deals out of 78 listings starting at $4,999
Subaru Legacy in Grand Rapids MI
49 listings starting at $9,800
Subaru Legacy in Saint Louis MO
32 listings starting at $4,495
Subaru Legacy in Detroit MI
103 listings starting at $2,590
Subaru Legacy in Milwaukee WI
5 Great Deals out of 196 listings starting at $4,999