Looking for a Used 5 Series in your area?
CarGurus has 17,390 nationwide 5 Series listings starting at $1,900.
Average User Score
4.2 ⁄ 5 stars
Based on 16 reviews
2009 BMW 5 Series ReviewThe Good
With standard-setting quality on literally every level, the 2009 BMW 5 Series seems poised to maintain its position as a class leader.The Bad
iDrive and Active Steering are the chinks in the 2009 5 Series’ armor, so be glad the Active Steering at least is optional.
The CarGurus View
When it comes to premium midsize vehicles, the BMW 5 Series is a sterling example of refinement. Its performance doesn’t get in the way of comfort or practicality, and that’s a rare thing today. Skip the Active Steering system until it has had a chance to get the bugs worked out, and strongly consider AWD if you live in the frozen north.
At a Glance
The 5 Series is BMW’s midsize offering, virtually unchanged since the mid-cycle refresh done last year. In production since 1972, the 5 Series, now in its fifth generation, hit a milestone earlier this year with 5 million cars sold since the model’s inception.
Available as both a sedan and a wagon, the 5 Series comes in three trims with three distinct engines, rear- or all-wheel drive, and either a manual or automatic six-speed transmission.
The 528 and 535 both utilize the same 3.0-liter inline six-cylinder engine used in the 3 Series. And just like in the 3 Series, the difference lies in the aspiration. 528s get a naturally aspirated 3.0-liter, while the 535 benefits from a twin-turbo setup that adds 70 hp and eliminates the turbo lag often experienced with single-turbo setups. The 528's NA version produces 230 hp at 6,500 RPM and 200 lb-ft of torque at 2,750 RPM, while the turbocharged six in the 535 is boosted to just under 6 psi to produce a manufacturer-rated (and highly suspect) 300 hp at 5,800 RPM and 300 lb-ft of torque at 1,400 RPM. EPA estimates for both engines are quite close - for the 528, it’s rated at 18/28 mpg for the six-speed manual transmission and 19/28 for the six-speed automatic, while the 535 is close with 17/26 for both transmissions.
The 550i gets a monstrous 4.8-liter V8 producing 360 hp and 360 lb-ft of torque. With the six-speed manual transmission, EPA estimates are 15/22. With the six-speed automatic, one mpg is gained on the highway for an estimate of 15/23.
The 3.0-liter straight six is a formidable engine, turbocharged or not. NA versions have adequate power, barring perhaps in wagons fully loaded with cargo. The twin-turbo setup on the 535 adds 70 hp and provides more than enough power for any situation. The 550 will travel from 0 to 60 mph in 5.5 seconds flat, so power is hardly an issue. The manual transmission is smooth and precise, although the automatic has been criticized as slow to downshift. This has been noted as being corrected with the optional steering-wheel paddles.
Ride & Handling
Take the legendary handling of the 3 Series, and add even more composure. The longer wheelbase of the 5 Series, by almost a full 5 inches, keeps the squirreliness of the 3 Series well in check while maintaining the firm aggression that allows you to tackle quick turns with little body lean or loss of traction. The sport suspension is even better still, with the Active Roll Stabilization combating even more body lean, and its forgiving progressive spring rate absorbs all but the most punishing potholes. Some have found issue with the Active Steering system, however, which is intended to increase low-speed maneuverability, whose operation has been found to be less than uniform. That said, the 5 Series’ handling is still the benchmark for its class.
Cabin & Comfort
For anything other than a quick change of the radio station or slight climate adjustments, drivers should pull over, as they’ll have to utilize BMW’s infamous iDrive system, which requires a long look away from the road. I suppose accolades are deserved for any manufacturer that has stuck to their guns this long, despite a continual flood of complaints regarding the tainted system, if stubbornness is to be considered a virtue.
Above and beyond the iDrive, the rest of the controls are convenient and intuitive, and the materials of the cabin are of high quality and build. Fit and finish are top-notch, above even the class average.
Interior space is abundant, even in the rear. Only the tallest of rear seat occupants will have issues, and even those over 6 feet shouldn’t have a problem, unless sitting directly in a row. A bit of short/tall staggering should do the trick, just don’t try to cram an entire basketball team inside. The driver’s seat and steering wheel are fully adjustable, allowing for any number of positions, and the seats are both comfortable enough for long distance motoring and supportive enough for spirited jaunts through the twists. Surprisingly, storage in the trunk of the sedan is sub-par for the class, with an awkward opening and shallow recess. Wagons on the other hand enjoy almost 60 cubic feet of cargo volume, with a low, easily accessible rear entry.
The 5 Series comes standard with dual front and front side airbags, as well as side head-protecting airbags, antilock four-wheel disc brakes with brake assist and an antiskid system, as well as a tire-pressure monitoring system. 550’s additionally benefit from a front and rear obstacle detection system.
NHTSA crash test results awarded three stars to frontal crashes involving the driver and five stars for frontal crashes involving the passenger. Side crash ratings were five stars all around, and rollover resistance was rated at four stars.
What Owners Think
It’s only fair to bring up the complaints that have been heard regarding the Active Steering system and of course iDrive, but very honestly these are small issues plaguing an otherwise very happy customer base. The 5 Series is a class leader in performance, handling, economy, and quality. It’d sure be nice to see BMW do something right with that iDrive, though.
A CarGurus contributor since 2008, Michael started his career writing about cars with the SCCA - winning awards during his time as editor of Top End magazine. Since then, his journalistic travels have taken him from NY to Boston to CA, completing a cross-country tour on a restored vintage Suzuki. While his preference is for fine German automobiles - and the extra leg room they so often afford - his first automobile memories center around impromptu Mustang vs. Corvette races down the local highway, in the backseat of his father's latest acquisition.
What's your take on the 2009 BMW 5 Series?
BMW 5 Series Questions
Looking To Buy A '09 528xi But The Carfax Says It Was Not Serviced Until 17...
Car Won't Start
I took my 535 xi for an oil change and also tthey noticed that my vacuum lines were leaking which they've replaced. Took the car home then the next day drove to CT now on my way back I stop for a sna...
Cracked Windshield. Do I Need To Replace With Oem Glass?
Have a growing crack in my windshield, and my insurance company is being difficult about using OEM glass.
Any Problems Reported With "09 Bmw 528i-xdrive
Is A Car That Is Certified That Different Than Car Still Under Warrenty
looking at used car thst is listed as certified is it worth what the dealer thinks it is