Best 2016 Compact Luxury Sedans by Value

User Rankings

#1 — Cadillac ATS

Research

740 listings

Used Starting From
$10,999
Value
10
Front Seats
9
Back Seats
6.9
Cargo Capacity
8.4
Overall
8.8
Power
8.3
Handling
6.6
Looks/Style
10
Family Car
5.9

Based on 631 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#2 — Audi S3

Research

187 listings

Used Starting From
$17,781
Value
8.3
Front Seats
9.7
Back Seats
9
Cargo Capacity
8.2
Overall
9.9
Power
9.7
Handling
10
Looks/Style
8.2
Family Car
6.4

Based on 1,189 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#3 — Volvo S60

Research

622 listings

Used Starting From
$11,995
Compact Luxury Sedan Trims
Value
8
Front Seats
7.6
Back Seats
10
Cargo Capacity
9.9
Overall
6.5
Power
6.2
Handling
5.2
Looks/Style
3.9
Family Car
10

Based on 985 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#4 — Cadillac ATS-V

Research

53 listings

Used Starting From
$32,499
Compact Luxury Sedan Trims
Value
7.7
Front Seats
4.1
Back Seats
7
Cargo Capacity
4.8
Overall
7
Power
8.3
Handling
7
Looks/Style
8.3
Family Car
5.3

Based on 368 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#5 — Audi A3

Research

1,082 listings

Used Starting From
$9,841
Value
7.7
Front Seats
5.6
Back Seats
5.6
Cargo Capacity
7.2
Overall
5.9
Power
6.1
Handling
6.8
Looks/Style
5.5
Family Car
5.6

Based on 700 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#6 — Lexus IS 350

Research

288 listings

Used Starting From
$21,999
Compact Luxury Sedan Trims
Value
7.3
Front Seats
6.3
Back Seats
6.6
Cargo Capacity
8.4
Overall
5.9
Power
5
Handling
4.5
Looks/Style
7.4
Family Car
4.5

Based on 687 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#7 — Buick Verano

Research

1,137 listings

Used Starting From
$7,299
Value
6.1
Front Seats
2.9
Back Seats
5.3
Cargo Capacity
5.3
Overall
4
Power
3.7
Handling
5.1
Looks/Style
4.4
Family Car
5.6

Based on 1,074 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#8 — INFINITI Q50

Research

1,497 listings

Used Starting From
$13,000
Value
5.9
Front Seats
5.7
Back Seats
7
Cargo Capacity
7.4
Overall
5.1
Power
5.9
Handling
5.4
Looks/Style
6
Family Car
5.5

Based on 675 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#9 — BMW 4 Series

Research

1,815 listings

Used Starting From
$14,995
Value
5.7
Front Seats
5.9
Back Seats
7.5
Cargo Capacity
7.3
Overall
4.8
Power
5.7
Handling
6.3
Looks/Style
5.6
Family Car
5.5

Based on 659 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#10 — Lexus IS 200t

Research

1,242 listings

Used Starting From
$14,998
Compact Luxury Sedan Trims
Value
5.4
Front Seats
3.4
Back Seats
5.4
Cargo Capacity
6.1
Overall
4.5
Power
4.8
Handling
5
Looks/Style
5
Family Car
3.6

Based on 575 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#11 — INFINITI Q50 Hybrid

Research

34 listings

Used Starting From
$19,298
Compact Luxury Sedan Trims
Value
5.4
Front Seats
7.1
Back Seats
8.6
Cargo Capacity
5.8
Overall
4.5
Power
7.4
Handling
4.2
Looks/Style
8.3
Family Car
7.1

Based on 592 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#12 — Mercedes-Benz C-Class

Research

3,795 listings

Used Starting From
$14,500
Compact Luxury Sedan Trims
Value
5.1
Front Seats
7
Back Seats
8.3
Cargo Capacity
7.7
Overall
4.9
Power
6.4
Handling
5.3
Looks/Style
6.2
Family Car
6.4

Based on 403 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#13 — Audi S4

Research
Value
4.9
Front Seats
6.2
Back Seats
6.4
Cargo Capacity
7.8
Overall
4.8
Power
7.2
Handling
5.8
Looks/Style
4.8
Family Car
4.6

Based on 986 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#14 — BMW 3 Series

Research

5,277 listings

Used Starting From
$10,975
Value
4.8
Front Seats
5.1
Back Seats
5.9
Cargo Capacity
6.6
Overall
4.8
Power
5
Handling
5.7
Looks/Style
4
Family Car
4.5

Based on 561 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#15 — Lexus IS 300

Research

749 listings

Used Starting From
$16,989
Compact Luxury Sedan Trims
Value
4.4
Front Seats
4.7
Back Seats
5.4
Cargo Capacity
4.7
Overall
4.1
Power
3.4
Handling
6.4
Looks/Style
4.4
Family Car
4.5

Based on 381 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#16 — Audi A4

Research

689 listings

Used Starting From
$11,883
Value
3.5
Front Seats
2.8
Back Seats
4.4
Cargo Capacity
9.4
Overall
2.3
Power
2.3
Handling
2.7
Looks/Style
2.6
Family Car
5.5

Based on 307 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#17 — Mercedes-Benz CLA-Class

Research

1,572 listings

Used Starting From
$15,900
Compact Luxury Sedan Trims
Value
3.5
Front Seats
6.2
Back Seats
7.3
Cargo Capacity
5.4
Overall
3.7
Power
4
Handling
3.6
Looks/Style
6.8
Family Car
5

Based on 565 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

#18 — Acura ILX

Research

513 listings

Used Starting From
$10,500
Value
2.7
Front Seats
1.7
Back Seats
2.4
Cargo Capacity
5.5
Overall
1.6
Power
2.2
Handling
1.6
Looks/Style
3.1
Family Car
2.5

Based on 861 user rankings. Driven or own this vehicle? Rank this vehicle to share your opinion.

For informational purposes only. User rankings do not represent the opinion of CarGurus.