Does the engine in my 2005 Saturn ION need to be replaced?


Asked by Feb 08, 2015 at 11:33 AM about the 2005 Saturn ION 1

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

The oil light came on, and then went right back off, in my 2005 Saturn ION Friday night.  
She's got 156, 427 miles on her. Saturday morning I took it for an oil change.  The
mechanic said there was no oil at all in it.  They did not report any leakage of oil (I
After they were done, I drove for about 10 minutes along regular street roads, without
incident.  After which I was in the post office for about 10 minutes.  Then I drove about
30 minutes, along regular street roads and on an interstate, without incident.  This was
a stop at the butcher that took about 10 minutes.  Then I drove about 30 minutes along
an interstate, and in the last 3 minutes, it began to sputter, like it would if it had a
clogged fuel filter.  I gave it more gas and it was fine.  I parked the car and went into the
store to run my errands. I was meeting a friend in the area, so I waited in my car until it
was time.  About two hours time elapsed here.
I tried to start the car and it was a pretty loud metal racket going on, which I was afraid
meant damage from no oil, but if it were, I thought, then it would be running all this
time.  I tried it again, same ghastly noise.
AAA tow truck driver arrived and tried to start it.  It made a similar, but less violent
noise.  The battery was starting to go now.
My husband tried to start it after the car got towed, and it wouldn't turn over at all
(standard dead battery sound).  Checked the oil level and the dipstick read it was
FULL, albeit quite a bit darker than it should be for brand new.
Any suggestions on possible causes, problems, repairs, costs, would be greatly

2 Answers


Personally I would junk it and get something second hand. You've probably driven it for 10 years already. The amount of time and money you will sink into it, will probably come out to the same price as buying a good used car. If the engine has to be replaced, you will be looking at around $1600 for a crate engine, plus whatever labor costs. Usually after putting in a new engine, a myriad of other problems will come up. I would take the 3k you will end up spending in labor, and get a good used car.


Thanks Reelin68 ... I've had it since '09 and it's been exactly what I needed, and I come from a long line of Saturns, so I was hoping somebody would say, oh, it only needs X and that will only cost $500 (I'm a dreamer). After the mechanic said it was completely out of oil, I started looking online at used cars while I waited for the oil change to manage my expectations of price and availability.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

Search Saturn ION Questions

Saturn ION Experts

#1 Edgar987669
Reputation 820
Reputation 500
#3 charlene1960
Reputation 400
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used Saturn ION Red Line"
33 listings starting at $2,495
Used Saturn VUE"
54 Great Deals out of 2,822 listings starting at $1,895
Used Honda Civic"
1,170 Great Deals out of 59,022 listings starting at $1,300
Used Toyota Corolla"
1,487 Great Deals out of 67,842 listings starting at $1,295
Used Honda Accord"
1,312 Great Deals out of 78,754 listings starting at $1,395
Used Chevrolet Cobalt"
100 Great Deals out of 5,587 listings starting at $950
Used Toyota Camry"
1,645 Great Deals out of 99,026 listings starting at $895
Used Volkswagen Jetta"
669 Great Deals out of 32,713 listings starting at $1,200
Used Nissan Altima"
1,493 Great Deals out of 88,169 listings starting at $1,195
Used Ford Focus"
1,214 Great Deals out of 57,391 listings starting at $1,495
Used Nissan Sentra"
925 Great Deals out of 49,968 listings starting at $500

Used Cars For Sale