Should my 525i transmission have failed?


Asked by Jan 30, 2013 at 09:31 AM about the 2004 BMW 5 Series 525i

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

I have a 2004 525i and with about 103,000 miles on it received a transmission fault message and the car would only operate in one gear. Needless to say I spent $3,500 to rebuild the transmission - the dealer wanted $6700 for a new one. This is supposed to be a BMW. Should the tranny have failed after approximately 100,000 miles?

16 Answers

rae, a BMW is one of the finest engineered cars on the road. The thing with the dealer does not surprise me, quite predictable actually, they, not just bimmers but all makes dealers are at least double. But at 100,000 miles is just about the point where the trouble may begin. I think you probably didn't get as much mileage as most bimmers but it is not entirely unheard of for it to fail then, especially if you did not buy it new and could have been abused. Or did you buy it new?

5 out of 5 people think this is helpful.

Thanks for the response. I bought it as a certified used auto in 2005 from a BMW dealer in Henderson, Nevada. I thought certified used was almost the equivalent of buying new. That's not the only issue though. Just go a left front parking lamp failure message and the repair shop said you can't replace the bulb for the parking lamp, you have to replace the whole headlight assembly. (and we all know what that would cost)

Hold on, that does not sound right, he is trying to get away with something, let me look that up

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.

ok, but the parking lamp is that led ring around the main headlight I think.

does it look like

2 out of 2 people think this is helpful.
Best Answer


2 out of 2 people think this is helpful.

2nd photo hard to tell, but looks very much like the first photo - white auto -

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.

Ok and back to "certified" means that the vehicle has been inspected, usually about a 150 point inspection, by a factory trained licensed mechanic, or better yet technician, and is "certified" to be in need of no repair. At the time the inspection was done. Certainly not "like new" it can be certified with many many thousands of miles on it

2 out of 2 people think this is helpful.

Ok, guess I'll call the dealer here to get the part because the local repair shop is the one who said I needed a whole new headlight assembl . I know the whole headlight assembly price I was quoted (installed) was $1,100.

I looked at no less than 5 yeah FIVE places and every body agrees, you can buy the led ring and do NOT have to replace the entire assembly at $900 and up, and THAT is just the PART not labor ..and some of them have regular bulbs

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.

Yeah, because it costs them that $900 but they can do it in 20 minutes...find another shop. the one you have been to sounds a bit, uh, less than reputable?


Ok, guess I should have called the dealer in the first place. You are correct, they just replace the "bulb" or ring around the headlamp and it takes about 30 minutes. Thanks for your help - I would have just driven around with that bulb out, thinking I had to buy a new headlight assembly. as far as the transmission is concerned spending $3,500 to repair with a 2 yr warranty beats having to buy another car

Got that right, and with some TLC that engine will drive you to the moon, no need for a new car at all

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.

thanks again!


I also bought a 525i BMW (2005) with 16,000 miles on it,approximately 1 year old & the car was certified.. I drove it another 150,000 miles and started having "transmission fault" errors & downshifting problems - car dropping from third gear to 1'st and when braking hard the trans would wind down fast and lunge forward with a thump sound. Needless to say it has 162,00 miles on it and the dealer in Chicago wanted $7,000 for a new one and a transmission shop quoted me $3,500 for a completely rebuilt transmission with a 1 year 12,000 mile warranty. Since the car is paid off and no other problems I felt it was worth the repair money. The model hasn't change since 2005 and people think it's a relatively new car - has great style & beautiful ride. I am happy with my decision. Sandra - Chicago

3 out of 3 people think this is helpful.

The problem with BMW's is their policy "life time transmission fluid" after 50000 km/35000miles transmission fluid stars degrading, no matter the brand, BMW, GM, Toyota or whatever, that's why most Bmw's have transmission fault after 100000 miles, if abused, before 100000miles, transmission fluid service MUST BE DONE by an expert,other wise your transmission will break down just leaving the shop, the procedure requires special equipment, transmission should not be flushed, while draining dirty fluid, clean fluid is injected, must be at the right temperature with engine running, Make it done every 50000km and your bmw will run up to 400.000 km, Follow the dealer recommendation and your transmission will fail just right after warranty is over

4 out of 4 people think this is helpful.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

5 Series

Looking for a Used 5 Series in your area?

CarGurus has 14,489 nationwide 5 Series listings starting at $1,375.


Search BMW 5 Series Questions

BMW 5 Series Experts

#1 Tom Demyan
Tom Demyan
Reputation 1,990
#2 Michael Branan
Michael Branan
Reputation 770
#3 Robert Charlson
Robert Charlson
Reputation 670
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used BMW 3 Series
993 Great Deals out of 34,919 listings starting at $900
Used BMW 7 Series
172 Great Deals out of 6,133 listings starting at $3,500
Used Mercedes-Benz E-Class
410 Great Deals out of 22,362 listings starting at $1,999
Used BMW X5
392 Great Deals out of 15,746 listings starting at $1,300
Used BMW 6 Series
79 Great Deals out of 3,299 listings starting at $4,500
Used Mercedes-Benz C-Class
534 Great Deals out of 30,370 listings starting at $1,500
Used BMW M5
21 Great Deals out of 611 listings starting at $13,997
Used Audi A6
113 Great Deals out of 6,685 listings starting at $950
Used BMW M3
59 Great Deals out of 1,894 listings starting at $6,999
Used Mercedes-Benz S-Class
150 Great Deals out of 6,365 listings starting at $2,300
Used Honda Accord
701 Great Deals out of 82,117 listings starting at $500
Used Audi A4
196 Great Deals out of 10,864 listings starting at $1,333

Used Cars For Sale

2017 BMW 5 Series For Sale
1,781 listings starting at $51,988
2016 BMW 5 Series For Sale
62 Great Deals out of 1,603 listings starting at $29,977
2015 BMW 5 Series For Sale
11 Great Deals out of 342 listings starting at $21,995
2014 BMW 5 Series For Sale
174 Great Deals out of 3,286 listings starting at $16,981
2013 BMW 5 Series For Sale
49 Great Deals out of 1,167 listings starting at $13,995