2004 Why xj8 suspension
They may or may not all go out at once but to preserve the handling and safety it would be best to replace all of them at once,
Ditto, replace them all as a set, not just individually. (I would only replace an individual one if all of them were fairly new, and one took damage, then I'd replace just that one.)
Search Jaguar XJ-Series Questions
Are you a UK consumer? CarGurus now has a discussion forum in the UK.
Jaguar XJ-Series Experts