Should I replace all lifters while replacing a few defective ones?

Asked by Jul 21, 2014 at 01:10 PM about the 1995 Subaru Legacy 4 Dr LS AWD Wagon

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

2.2L engine has a least one questionable bad lifter and maybe more.  I plan to test each
one.  What is the wisdom of buying a set of 16 and just replacing them all?  The car has
268K miles.  My concern is that after market anything will not be good as the original
along the line if it ain't broke don't fix it. So what would be the best route?

2 Answers


That's a lot of miles on the engine. All parts are worn. It doesn't seem cost effective to just replace the one or two parts when the entire engine is so worn.


I would do the full set, might as well do them all cause if you have another old one fail down the road you'll just have to do it all over again. Prevent the issue from reoccuring. Also often times, if you buy from a reputable company, aftermarket parts are as good of quality if not better because they have had time to figure out any flaws in the factory parts and fix them and half the time they are cheaper too. I do my research on anything I buy, but 9 times out of 10 I will buy aftermarket over factory replacements.

Your Answer

Subaru Legacy Experts

  • #1
  • #2
  • #3
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used Subaru Impreza
167 Great Deals out of 20,849 listings starting at $1,333
Used Honda Accord
529 Great Deals out of 93,656 listings starting at $1,495
Used Toyota Camry
787 Great Deals out of 71,592 listings starting at $175
Used Honda Civic
341 Great Deals out of 52,141 listings starting at $1,200
Used Nissan Altima
748 Great Deals out of 67,282 listings starting at $750
Used BMW 3 Series
909 Great Deals out of 33,016 listings starting at $1,000
Used Toyota Corolla
643 Great Deals out of 66,145 listings starting at $1,599
Used Honda CR-V
541 Great Deals out of 67,089 listings starting at $1,800

Used Cars For Sale

2018 Subaru Legacy For Sale
7,882 listings starting at $19,318
2017 Subaru Legacy For Sale
28 Great Deals out of 1,269 listings starting at $14,589
2016 Subaru Legacy For Sale
15 Great Deals out of 618 listings starting at $11,995
2015 Subaru Legacy For Sale
52 Great Deals out of 1,481 listings starting at $8,999
2014 Subaru Legacy For Sale
14 Great Deals out of 445 listings starting at $6,999

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use.