Is it illegal for a car dealership to sell you an all-wheel drive car with different tires on it?

Asked by Sep 12, 2013 at 05:35 PM

Question type: General

I recently bought an 2002 Audi Allroad from a used car dealership. I took it to Firestone to  
get an oil change and after, they told me that it has different tires on the car. They told
me that they need to be changed asap and it's dangerous for me to drive the car. I told
my friend who knows a bunch about cars and things that have to do with cars and he told
me that it was illegal for the dealership to sell me an all-wheel drive car with different
tires. Is it true? If so, what do I do?

2 Answers


Illegal? I never heard that. Maybe if you were buying a new car. But you bought a used car. While you shouldn't have different tires on the car, and if they are all the same size and worn the same amount you are fine. Firestone wants your business. Different treaded tires will place undue wear on the drive system if the tires are very much different. So if the tires are worn/close to the wear bars then by all means replace them.


Illegal, no. There are a lot of unknowns here, but the car can come with no wheels at all, if you bought it as is as seen, its up to you to investigate your purchase before you sign. There is a small window of diameter difference like 2-3mm before bad things happen, even different tread patterns. Its ideal to get 4 new matching tires that will wear together and follow the rotation schedule, check air pressure etc. While not being, illegal, there is nothing stopping you from bringing it to their attention and asking for help, if they are a decent dealership they may have overlooked it and will correct it.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

  • Can car dealerships sell you a car with broken seat belts? Or is it illegal? 14 answers

    2007 Nissan Sentra



  • I bought a car with bald tires, what can I do? 13 answers

    I bought my car off of I found out the car has bald tires and should not have passed inspection. (9/17) What can I do? Isn't the dealership where I bought the car responsible? Two were ...

    2014 Toyota Camry



  • Can I put my own car for sell? 1 answer

    Silver 2005 Jeep Liberty Automatic 4x4 All-wheel drive With automatic windows, automatic mirrors and automatic sunroof. 4 Winter tires included as well as 4 winter carpets. 137863 km of millage as ...

    2005 Jeep Liberty Rocky Mountain 4WD



  • So, how do you write a review for a dealership? 37 answers

    So, why is there not a link/button/switch, whatever, that allows me to write a review for a car dealership? Do they just not let you do that any more? Signed in, registered. Looks like they don't t...

    Jeep Grand Cherokee



  • Tire/wheel combos 12 answers

    Hi. I'm new to this forum & looking for advice so please be gentle. I have a 76 Rally Sport that is completely stock. The wheels are rusty and tires are begining to dry rot. I am looking to replace th...

    1976 Chevrolet Camaro


    Car Customization


Search General Questions

UK Questions

Are you a UK consumer? CarGurus now has a discussion forum in the UK.

General Experts

#1 Tom Demyan
Tom Demyan
Reputation 42,770
Reputation 36,160
#3 FordNut
Reputation 29,650
View All