winter tires


Asked by May 17, 2010 at 02:22 AM

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

i use studded tire on all 4 wheels in the winter and i swear by them. So why do some places ban them in the winter ?
My front wheel drive with studded tire seem to handle just as good on road in the winter as a 4 wheel drive.
So why does places like Ontario ban them in the winter.

1 Answer


If you compare the traction level of studded winter tires with that of 4wd system (usually equipped with all-season tires), you are grossly under estimating what studded tires can do on snowy/icy surfaces! Whether you have front, rear or all wheel drive (including 4wd), the traction level you have is only as good as the tires you use. Other factors which may affect winter performance are: tire (not rim) diameter (the bigger the better) and ground clearance (although at SUV height or taller, the vehicle may be at significantly increased risk of flipping under certain conditions!). Studded tires destroy asphalt and as it is we are already paying too much tax maintaining our roads/highways. Studded tires have very compromised dry pavement performance and unless you live in outlying areas where pavements were snow covered all winter long, it is just an overkill. Recent advances in snow tire design have allow very well rounded performance of non-studded (called "friction") winter tires - quiet, comfortable, good handling (comparable to performance all-season tires), and longevity (as long as ambient temp. remains low) on winter dry pavements, yet can still scale a few inches of snow/slush and ice with ease! Ultimately, the answer depends on where one lives and thus the type of pavement one drives on, and most of all, one's driving habit.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

  • The best winter tires to buy for this car? 2 answers

    What is the best winter tires to buy for the Aztek? I currently have Goodyear Fortera on and these tires do not go good in the snow.

    2005 Pontiac Aztek STD


    Maintenance & Repair

  • Does anyone find water in the spare tire compartment in the winter and if so how did you fix it 5 answers

    the water freezes in the spare tire well in the winter, how do you stop it

    2007 Pontiac Torrent Base


    Maintenance & Repair

  • What's the best winter tires for a Toyota Prius? 1 answer

    I live in New England and after last winter I want to make sure I'm getting quality tires. I travel a lot for work.

    2007 Toyota Prius Base


    Maintenance & Repair

  • Pax tire repair 2 answers

    My Pax tire had a nail. Dealer pluged it. Repair lasted for a while and now the tire leaks. Pax dealer will not patch it and wants me to buy a new tire. Any suggestions? Can I re-plug the leak? ...

    2008 Acura RL AWD w/ CMBS and PAX Tires


    Maintenance & Repair

  • Winter tires 2 answers

    Looking at purchasing winter tires with rims. I live in a rural community 45 min north west of Toronto. Snow pillowed roads, hard packed, some slush and ice conditions. Dealer offering Pirelli winte...

    2013 Subaru Impreza 2.0i Hatchback




Search Maintenance & Repair Questions

Maintenance & Repair Experts

#1 Tom Demyan
Tom Demyan
Reputation 150,350
#2 FordNut
Reputation 103,200
#3 dandyoun
Reputation 84,260
View All