Question about High Performance Snow Tires

5

Asked by Nov 16, 2009 at 06:24 PM

Question type: Car Customization

I am looking into buying a set of high performance snow tires and am trying to decide between the "Vredestein Wintrac Xtreme Runflat", "Dunlop SP Winter Sport M3 ROF" and "Bridgestone Blizzak LM-25 RFT".

Although the snow/ice handling is important, I am interested in good dry/wet handling and durability overall (i.e., 2-3 seasons with normal driving conditions).  Winters in the Milwaukee area are bad at times, but most of the time is slush, wet and dry conditions.

Do you have any opnions regarding any of the choices listed above?

Thanks!

3 Answers

1,955

I do not have experience with Wintrac nor the Blazzak, but I had the Dunlop M3 on my '01 740iL and '03 M5. On dry pavement and low temp. (single digit to low teen), the Dunlop tended to trigger the traction control way too often while accelerating or powering out of turns. This was due to sudden loss of traction. In powdered snow, slush, and rain, these performed just a hair better than all-seasons tires (Kumho ASX, Falken Ziex 512 in my case). Didn't think they made a difference on icy surface either. I had Conti T810S on my '05 911TT and the difference was night and day. No wheel hops under hard accelerations on dry pavement, very gradual break away, and noticeably more traction. The Conti were also manageable on ice. This could be due to the fact that the Porsche has AWD and better weight distributions, but the Conti tires also have the latest continuous tread pattern design to work better with electronic traction control systems. I have driven other non performance snow tires (eg. Nokian RSi) and found, despite the lower dry pavement traction, still exhibits good behaviour with the car's traction control, proofing once again it is important to find the right tread designs to accommodate modern chassis dynamics.

5

I appreciate your feedback. Interesting point you make about the thread design. I had considered the Continental ContiWinterContact TS810 (Performance Snow), but I am currently leaning towards the Vredestein. I am attaching picture of it for a closer look at its thread design.

forget about performance in the winter and get tires with the biggest lugs and gaps you can find. i'm about 200-300 miles south of you. i get the same crap as you.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

  • What are the best snow tires for this car. 8 answers

    Hi there, Winter is fast approaching and I am in the market for snow tires as well as new rims. Any suggestions. Anyone have success with Tire Rack?

    2007 Audi RS 4

    -

    Car Customization

  • tires 1 answer

    Going to get a new set of tires for a 1994 reg cab. Any suggestions? Has anyone had any Hercules Terra Trac tires, if so how did they perform and what kind of milage did you get out of them? I want s...

    1994 Toyota Pickup

    -

    Car Customization

  • Low profiles in snow? 1 answer

    I just bought a 2013 Subaru impreza hatchback without realizing the low profile tires. Will I need regular tires for the snow? If so, will regular tires fit the rims?

    2013 Subaru Impreza 2.0i Premium Hatchback

    -

    Car Customization

  • Sentra and snow 2 answers

    What customization can I do to a 2012 Nissan Sentra SL to make it powerful enough for snow conditions. Other than better tires, are there any options?

    2012 Nissan Sentra 2.0 SL

    -

    Car Customization

  • How will the tires on the 2014 G63 perform in snow? 1 answer

    Do I need to get winter tires or can i buy all season tires for the G63 for the snow. I have a 2008 range rover with 20" performance tires that do have some slippage in the snow, but I am told the ...

    2014 Mercedes-Benz G-Class G63 AMG

    -

    General

Shortcuts

Search Car Customization Questions

Car Customization Experts

#1 FordNut
FordNut
Reputation 4,810
#2 Tom Demyan
Tom Demyan
Reputation 4,770
#3 dandyoun
dandyoun
Reputation 3,090
View All