Should I replace the transmission in my Vanagon?

Asked by Jul 28, 2011 at 12:30 AM about the 1983 Volkswagen Vanagon

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

Hi,
My 1983 vanagon needs a new transmission.  The price is just above $2k.  Before
moving forward with it we decided to have an engine compression test done.  The
results were: Engine compression: #1 - 120 psi, #2 - 125 psi, #3 - 110 psi, #4 - 90
psi.  The results of the other test (oil pressure) were excellent. You have about 30
psi at idle and 50-55 psi at higher rpms.

We won't be able to afford an engine rebuild for a couple years.   So my question
is: would you spend the money on the tranny now with the risk that the engine will
crap out or would you save the money, sell the van, and get a new one.

Thanks,
Andy

2 Answers

435

If you can't afford the tranny and the engine repair (say 5 grand), what makes you think you can get a new one by selling the one you have? Your 83 with a bad tranny and questionable engine won't get you $2000. Roll the dice and get the tranny rebuilt.

1 out of 1 people think this is helpful.

I believe you can get a used transmission for about 800 bucks or less. Try to do it this way. I found one but in Mexico and it cost a lot less but it was many years ago. It wasn't easy because in Mexico they don't have this type of Vanagon, but they import by the container many transmissions from Germany and some of these were for your type of van. I think it cost me about 250 dollars and it included the labor to put it in. Don't buy a new transmission.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

  • VW Westy vanagon repair 5 answers

    My 1990 VW Westy vanagon has been sitting for several years. What repairs can I expect to get it running again?

    1990 Volkswagen Vanagon GL Camper Passenger Van

    -

    Maintenance & Repair

  • 1981 Vanagon Lurching 1 answer

    My 81 vanagon won't go past certain speeds. Raining this morning, it was REALLY bad. Feels like a fuel flow problem, but I replaced the fuel filter, and I smell gasoline. The engine just chokes at a l...

    1981 Volkswagen Vanagon

    -

    Maintenance & Repair

  • 87 Vanagon Leaking Fluids 2 answers

    I brought drove my 87 Vanagon from central California to central oregon about three weeks ago just before the last snow storm. It sat and froze for a week. After the though and when it was warm en...

    1987 Volkswagen Vanagon Wolfsburg Passenger Van

    -

    Maintenance & Repair

  • has anyone modified metal rear bumper 251 807 311D to replace the fiberglass number on 1991 vanagon? 4 answers

    I have a 1991 vanagon and would like to replace the fiberglass number. The bumper for sale say they do not replace the plastic ones. Except gowesty who says they will fit with modification. thank...

    1991 Volkswagen Vanagon

    -

    Maintenance & Repair

  • 1990 Vanagon GL 4 answers

    I am thinking of buying a used Vanagon and would like to ask some opinion if the car I am buying is a good deal. I used to owned a 1984 Vanagon and very familiar about the layout of this engine. Since...

    1990 Volkswagen Vanagon

    -

    Shopping & Pricing

Search Volkswagen Vanagon Questions

Volkswagen Vanagon Experts

#1 Scott Sr.
Scott Sr.
Reputation 830
#2 Ryan Redenbaugh
Ryan Redenbaugh
Reputation 250
#3 chassy
chassy
Reputation 200
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used Toyota 4Runner
381 Great Deals out of 19,763 listings starting at $1,987