Problem with charging/cooling... linked?

Asked by Jan 24, 2016 at 04:02 PM about the 1988 Jeep Comanche

Question type: Maintenance & Repair

I have a 1988 Comanche that I bought well used back in '07. Soon after, I
had to replace the water pump and thermostat. After that, it would never
get up to full temperature. Even on a 90 degree day the temp gauge would
just barely register any temp at all. I didn't worry about it since it was
running fine and was not my daily driver. But just the other day as I was
coming home from work I noticed that the temp gauge was showing almost
full operating temperature. Since it was 17 degrees outside, it seemed
really unusual. I also noticed the voltmeter was very low... about 9 or so.
Not good. Anyway, after just a couple minutes, both the temp dropped to
the usual non existent, and the volt meter returned to normal 14v. I felt my
chances of getting home were better but still, something is wrong. Later, as
I kept an eye on the gauges, the temp started climbing... at the same time
the voltage dropped. It eventually overheated and I had to get towed home.  

I'm at a loss to guess what the problem might be. The water pump may
have gone (the heater was blasting cold air, the reservoir was full).. with
possibly an alternator issue. But both at the exact same time? Only
connection I can make is the serpentine belt. But it isn't broken, and seems
to be in good shape. I'm lost with this, any help out there?


9 Answers


If you did not have this issue before changing the water pump and t-stat sounds like air was not completely removed from cooling system. Does your vehicle have the over flow tank with cap to add anti freeze ?


Do not think you have to separate issues just vehicle shut down from over heating.

Ok, I guess I should have included one detail. I replaced the pump way back in '07. Never had any issue with it til about a week ago. And that's one thing that is puzzling me, I don't know if they are related or separate issues. I just know they both happened at the same time.


You did say in your question that after replacing those items would not get up to full temperature. It is strange that you went this long before having this problem but I would try removing all air from cooling system. Will the vehicle start now since it has cooled down ?

Oh yeah.. it seems to be running normal right now, it's charging the battery and everything. When all this stupid snow clears out I'm thinking of taking it out for a drive and see what happens. Right now it's got a huge pile of snow blocking it in so it'll be a while.


Understand that just finished digging my vehicles out. Like I said do not believe you have a problem with charging system because when a vehicle over heats it shuts the vehicle off and dash lights will come on when vehicle shuts off before turning off the key.

I really don't think the discharging was a result of the overheating. Let me describe the scenario in detail... It was about 9:30 pm, I'm leaving work. It's 17 degrees outside, I have an hour drive to get home and no heat. Yay. About ten minutes into the drive I happened to notice the voltage was down around 9, in the red. At the same time I looked at the temp gauge, which is normally showing the needle just barely above the 100 degree mark is now around 150 or so and climbing. Just a few seconds later, the temp dropped to 'normal' and the volts went back to 14. Everything seemed ok, but I was still worried. Twenty minutes later, I'm about halfway home, keeping an eye on the gauges, when the temp begins climbing again. At the same instant the volts drop to 9. Before it ever got a chance to overheat. But this time the temp kept on climbing. I managed to find a place to pull over and stop before the temp gauge hit the ceiling, although it did overheat. There was a puddle of coolant on the ground after I stopped. So I'm wondering if these are two separate events that happened at the same time, if so.... how? Or is there something going on that could have caused both to happen simultaneously? I really don't think the discharge was a result of the overheating.


Did you find out where the anti freeze leak was coming form ?


I believe once you fix the anti freeze leak you will be good to go. I still believe it was from the vehicle over heating because when a vehicle over heats does not do it instantly as vehicle is getting to that point of over heating the vehicle is starting to shut down.

Your Answer

Add photo

Related Questions

  • No electrical power to any system. 2 answers

    The truck is a 4.0 l. w auto transmission. I tried to start the truck within a minute of coming home and turning it off. The engine would not turn over and nothing else that required electricity wo...

    1988 Jeep Comanche STD 4WD


    Maintenance & Repair

  • does the 88 camanche have a fuel pump relay switch? 2 answers

    it starts but does not stay running we replaced the fuel pump with brand new one. my freind says its a fuel pump relay switch but i can't find one does it have such a part and if not can you tell me w...

    1988 Jeep Comanche


    Maintenance & Repair

  • How far should i jack up my '88 jeep comanche? 7 answers

    How far should i jack up my comanche? should i even jack it up, because i like the mileage

    1988 Jeep Comanche


    Car Customization

  • Is there a possible link with code p3040 and the transmission 2 answers

    2 days ago my check engine light came on and the code was p3040 and since then it has stalled twice and the transmission feels like it jerks for like 2-3 seconds sometimes when I exselerate, it fee...

    2006 Jeep Liberty Sport 4WD


    Maintenance & Repair

  • what are options for a drag link broken frame bracket? 1 answer

    drag link bracket broke in half at frame.

    1999 Jeep Cherokee


    Maintenance & Repair


Looking for a Used Comanche in your area?

CarGurus has 7 nationwide Comanche listings and the tools to find you a great deal.


Search Jeep Comanche Questions

Jeep Comanche Experts

#1 Calen Weed
Calen Weed
Reputation 100
#2 John Price
John Price
Reputation 70
#2 NVSmith
Reputation 70
View All

Related Models For Sale

Used Jeep Wrangler
271 Great Deals out of 18,084 listings starting at $2,950
Used Jeep Cherokee
414 Great Deals out of 52,538 listings starting at $1,800
Used Jeep Wagoneer
12 listings
Used Ford F-150
2,176 Great Deals out of 206,277 listings starting at $1,499

Content submitted by Users is not endorsed by CarGurus, does not express the opinions of CarGurus, and should not be considered reviewed, screened, or approved by CarGurus. Please refer to CarGurus Terms of Use.